The start
According to the National Institute of Dental and Craniofacial Research, "In 1945, Grand Rapids became the first city in the world to fluoridate its drinking water." The Michigan city began on January 25, 1945, as the Science History Institute records. Over the next decade, as the Cold War deepened, other cities followed, and some Americans began to see something sinister in the taps.
The witness
In May 1954 the House Committee on Interstate and Foreign Commerce held hearings on a bill about water fluoridation. One witness, Mrs. Hugo (Golda) Franzen, told the committee: "Unquestionably, practically everything in this Nation is infiltrated by Communists, subversives, and their dupes or tools." She went on: "Invasion and sabotage, by remote control, through the water mains. What could be more clever or effective? Our enemies take over, city by city." And then: "I know that fluoridation is a Communist scheme, frankly, the master plan, but I cannot prove it, for those who have informed me, cannot testify; they would be liquidated, if they did."
The idea spreads
The Science History Institute traces how the idea spread. A 1960 issue of the publication The Independent "declared unequivocally, 'Former Communists have stated that fluoridation is known to Communists as a method of Red Warfare,'" and "implied that the U.S. Public Health Service had been infiltrated by Communists." "Right-wing groups like the John Birch Society have long implied dark motives behind fluoridation."
The fear became famous enough for Hollywood. In Stanley Kubrick's Dr. Strangelove (1964), General Jack D. Ripper asks: "Do you realize that fluoridation is the most monstrously conceived and dangerous Communist plot we have ever had to face?"
The German strand
A second version said the Nazis planned it first. PolitiFact traced the claim that "both the Germans and the Russians added sodium fluoride to the drinking water of prisoners of war" back through later books to a man named Perkins, who "purportedly learned from a big German chemical producer that it had developed a plan to fluoridate occupied countries." The Holocaust historian PolitiFact consulted, Patricia Heberer, "knew of no such project."
The historians
On the public radio program BackStory, historian Andrew Case said that "by the 1950s, anxieties about a Communist conspiracy were helping to fuel a backlash against fluoride." The 1954 bill, he noted, "never really gets out of committee." Franzen's testimony, he said, "captures lots of elements of conspiracy thinking. There's a master plan, but we also can't reveal the master plan."
Case also pointed to a deeper worry: "the notion of mass medication," something applied "regardless of individual choice," often "at the behest of a city council or local leadership without a popular referendum."
Historian Catherine Carstairs, writing in the American Journal of Public Health in 2015, found that in the wider debate "there were occasional references to a Communist conspiracy," but that "this was not a common feature of the debate."
The believers' answer
For many opponents, the plot was never the point. As Carstairs writes, "opponents believed that they should not have to take medicine against their will." Believers frame the issue as consent: a city council, not the person at the tap, decided what everyone would drink. Who decides what goes into everyone's water?