The case for Oxford
In 1920 an English schoolmaster, J. Thomas Looney, published "Shakespeare" Identified in Edward de Vere, the Seventeenth Earl of Oxford. Rather than start with a candidate, he started with the plays and drew a portrait of the man he thought must have written them. Among the "general features" he listed: "A matured man of recognized genius," "Apparently eccentric and mysterious," "Of intense sensibility, a man apart," and "Of superior education, classical, the habitual associate of educated people."
He added special characteristics: "A man with Feudal connections," "A member of the higher aristocracy," "Connected with Lancastrian supporters," "An enthusiast for Italy," "A follower of sport (including falconry)," "A lover of music," "Loose and improvident in money matters," and "Of probable Catholic leanings, but touched with scepticism." He found that man in Edward de Vere, the 17th Earl of Oxford.
The doubters
The Shakespeare Authorship Coalition's Declaration of Reasonable Doubt asks the central question: "How could William 'Shakspere' of Stratford have been the author, William Shakespeare, and leave no definitive evidence of it that dates from his lifetime?" It lists past doubters including Mark Twain, Henry James, Walt Whitman, Ralph Waldo Emerson, Orson Welles, Charlie Chaplin, Sir John Gielgud, Sigmund Freud, and Supreme Court Justices Harry A. Blackmun and Lewis F. Powell Jr. "The case for him as the author rests largely on testimony in the First Folio ... published in 1623, seven years after he died."
The scholars' answer
Mainstream scholars disagree. Professor Jonathan Bate, speaking for the Shakespeare Birthplace Trust, says: "There is ample evidence that William Shakespeare, a man from Stratford-upon-Avon ... became an actor, became a playwright, then eventually returned to Stratford and died." He points to the monument to Shakespeare in Holy Trinity Church in Stratford; to Ben Jonson's tribute to the "sweet swan of Avon"; to the actors John Heminges and John Condell, who compiled the First Folio and were "remembered in the will"; and to Francis Meres, who named Shakespeare among England's writers in 1598. In Bate's view, the Oxford theory began with a question of class: "how could this grammar schoolboy from the provinces have known so much about courts and aristocracy?"
The moot court
On September 25, 1987, three Supreme Court justices, William Brennan, Harry Blackmun and John Paul Stevens, heard the case in a moot court at American University. About 1,000 people filled a Washington church, the Los Angeles Times reported.
Brennan said the burden "was on Oxford to prove" his authorship, and noted that "several of the more important plays actually surfaced after Oxford's death in 1604." He added: "if a single one of the plays that surfaced after 1604 was not written by Oxford before his death, then I think the whole case collapses." Blackmun said of the Oxfordians: "My own feeling is that they come closer to proving it than anyone else has."
The justices agreed "that the case for De Vere was, as a Scotch verdict puts it, not proved." But, the paper reported, "the possibility that ... the man from Stratford did not write the works of Shakespeare, can no longer be summarily dismissed." Brennan said they were "a little bit at sea."
The doubters' answer
The Shakespeare Oxford Fellowship answers the 1604 problem directly: "1604: Not a 'Problem'." It points out that the First Folio's letter to readers says the author was "by death" deprived of the chance "to have set forth, and overseen his own writings," and argues that "No Shakespearean work has ever been proved to be written after 1604." It asks: "Where's the paper trail? ... no one has found a single letter written by Shakspere to anyone." And it notes that the Folger Shakespeare Library holds Oxford's annotated Geneva Bible, "with many marked verses linking intriguingly to biblical references" in the plays. Was the Bard the man from Stratford, or an earl in disguise?