Harold Holt vanished in the surf in 1967; a coroner found he drowned, and spy, submarine, and suicide claims persist. The National Film and Sound Archive describes a joint police report of January 1968 that found no indication the disappearance was anything other than accidental. Prime Minister John Gorton said that month there would be no official enquiry beyond the police report. Archive files, as an ABC documentary reported them in 2011, hold cables, a sabotage letter, and no evidence for a submarine. A 1983 book said Holt was a Chinese spy taken off by submarine, and in 2005 the Victorian coroner found that he drowned and called the rival theories fanciful.
The police report and its film
The curator's notes on Australian Screen, part of the National Film and Sound Archive, for a Victorian Police film say Holt disappeared while swimming at Cheviot Beach near Portsea, Victoria, on Sunday 17 December 1967, and that his body was never recovered. They say the investigation began on Monday 18 December, headed by Inspector Jackson of the Commonwealth Police Force and Inspector Ford of the Victoria Police Force, and that in January 1968 the two forces submitted a 95-page joint report. No cause of death was determined, the notes say, but the report stated that there was "no indication that the disappearance of the late Mr Holt was anything other than accidental." The film is unedited silent footage, shot on Tuesday 19 December, the day witness statements were taken, re-enacting the movements of the witnesses; the notes quote the report saying the beach party and eye witnesses were gathered so that "a continuous movie film was taken in the form of an enactment of the circumstances."
NFSA, curator's notes, Holt police film re-enactment: https://aso.gov.au/titles/sponsored-films/holt-film-re-enactment/notes/
No official enquiry in 1968
At a press conference at Parliament House on 17 January 1968, Gorton was asked whether Cabinet would consider an official enquiry into the disappearance. "The answer to that is no," he said. He said there had been an enquiry by the Victorian Police into all the events of that day, that the report had been presented, and that in view of some of the matter printed in it he proposed to make the report available. He added that there was "no need to go any further than that."
PM Transcripts, press conference by John Gorton, 17 January 1968: https://pmtranscripts.pmc.gov.au/sites/default/files/original/00001760.pdf
What the National Archives files show
An ABC radio documentary by Brendan Trembath, broadcast 20 December 2011, drew on recently released letters and cables in the National Archives. It says Holt, 59, went swimming at Cheviot Beach with four friends and disappeared from view about 60 metres out, and that close to 200 people were searching by dark. It says documents show the Queen sent condolence messages that same day, to be released if death were confirmed, and that Attorney-General Nigel Bowen called the period one of "dreadful uncertainty." It says the governor-general, Lord Casey, terminated Holt's commission, that John McEwen stepped in, and that the search was not officially ended until 5 January 1968. It says ASIO made a 21-minute surveillance film at the memorial service, and that the archives hold a 1967 letter from a United States attorney with a hunch of "expert sabotage, probably foreign." It notes the claim that Holt faked his death to run away with a mistress, and it says the files do not provide any evidence for the submarine theory.
ABC PM, radio current affairs documentary on Harold Holt, 20 December 2011: https://www.abc.net.au/pm/archive/articles/2011/12/20/s3395014.htm
The spy and submarine claim
The British Archive for Contemporary Writing describes the papers behind Anthony Grey's 1983 book The Prime Minister Was a Spy, published by Weidenfeld and Nicolson. It says Grey's source, Ronald M. Titcombe, a former Royal Australian Navy officer, convinced him that throughout his political career Holt had clandestinely sent intelligence about Australian domestic and foreign policy to the Chinese, citing among other evidence a copy of Holt's diary from the early 1950s. It says Titcombe suggested that Holt, fearing detection by Australian intelligence officers, sought asylum in a small submarine waiting off Portsea. The UEA record says the Observer published articles alleging the book was perpetrated by Titcombe, then attended the High Court to retract the allegation and paid him damages and costs, and that in 1989 the Press Council upheld Grey's complaint against the paper. It says Grey republished the book in 2005, saying it reaffirmed his conviction, and promised a further book that was never published.
British Archive for Contemporary Writing, AG/LIT/16, The Prime Minister Was a Spy: https://archivecollections.uea.ac.uk/ag.lit.16
The 2005 finding
The Sydney Morning Herald reported on 2 September 2005 that State Coroner Graeme Johnstone found Holt drowned while swimming in the surf off Cheviot Beach on 17 December 1967. Coroners had been unable to investigate deaths where no body was found until the Coroners Act of 1985 changed the law. Johnstone said the theories ranged from Holt being taken by a Chinese submarine to suicide, and found them fanciful. "Unfortunately, there was no open inquiry at the time so this detailed material did not become general public knowledge," he said, adding that an inquiry might have avoided "some of the unsubstantiated rumours and unusual theories." He said "a simple reading of the original investigative material provides the real and credible explanation." The case was one of 85 drownings with no body recovered.
Sydney Morning Herald, 2 September 2005: https://www.smh.com.au/national/harold-holt-drowned-coroner-finds-20050902-gdlzs9.html
The Age reported the same day that the finding dismissed claims Holt had been taken by a Chinese mini-submarine or killed by the CIA. It quoted the report: "There is nothing of significance in any of the material gathered ... that would indicate anything other than drowning occurred to Mr Holt." Lawrence Newell, the retired deputy commissioner who coordinated the search, told the inquest it was accidental drowning: "There were a number of conjectures put forward, and I thought about them carefully and none of them seemed to me to be at all credible."
The Age, 2 September 2005: https://www.theage.com.au/national/final-verdict-on-holt-disappearance-20050902-ge0sxy.html
The record on the claims
Adherents of the spy account cite Titcombe's story, Holt's diary, and a submarine off Portsea; other published claims name the CIA, suicide, sabotage, or a faked death. The 1968 police report found no indication of anything but accident, and the National Archives files, as ABC reported them, show no submarine. The 2005 coroner found that Holt drowned and called the other theories fanciful.