Affiliation was refused, and study proceeded, because the bones were treated as too old to trace. On 28 July 1996 two men found a skull in the Columbia River at Kennewick, Washington, on land of the Army Corps of Engineers at the McNary project. James Chatters, called in by the coroner, first thought the bones might be those of an early European settler. A stone point in the hip, and a radiocarbon estimate, pushed the skeleton back. The Corps’ later determination states the initial date as between 8,340 and 9,200 years. Tribes of the Columbia Plateau asked for the remains under the Native American Graves Protection and Repatriation Act. The Corps agreed and moved to transfer them to the Confederated Tribes of the Colville Reservation, the Confederated Tribes of the Umatilla Indian Reservation, the Confederated Tribes and Bands of the Yakama Nation, the Nez Perce Tribe, and the Wanapum Band. In October 1996 eight scientists sued to study the skeleton instead. They knew the man, in the court papers, as Kennewick Man. The tribes knew him as the Ancient One.
The Interior Department, given the decision in 1998, found the remains Native American on 13 January 2000 and culturally affiliated with the claimant tribes on 25 September 2000, and the Corps again prepared to transfer them. The district court in Oregon set that finding aside. On 4 February 2004, in an opinion amended that April, the Ninth Circuit affirmed. NAGPRA’s definition, the court held, is in the present tense: remains are Native American only if they are of, or relating to, a tribe, people, or culture that is indigenous. The record, the court said, did not show a special genetic or cultural relationship to any presently existing tribe. The age of the bones made that showing, on the studies then in hand, almost impossible. Geographic location was not enough. The court held that the remains were not Native American under the statute as it read them, that NAGPRA did not apply, and that study could proceed under the Archaeological Resources Protection Act. The Burke Museum, which had held the remains under contract to the Corps since 1998, records that the plaintiffs then came three times to study, and that tribal representatives came to conduct ceremonies and did not drop the claim. The Burke’s later account gives a subsequent age for the skeleton of about 8,400 to 8,690 years, a narrower figure than the 8,340 to 9,200 years in the court opinion and the Corps memorandum. Both figures are left as the pages state them.
This file is not Spirit Cave. It is not a Bureau of Land Management determination, and it is not a Nevada cave. The refusal here was a reading of NAGPRA by the Ninth Circuit in a Corps case on the Columbia River. The scientists are not villains in it, and the tribes are not obstacles. The opinion sets out both demands: study of a rare skeleton, and burial of an ancestor. It decided the statutory question. It did not decide which demand was the decent one.
What changed was evidence the 2004 record did not have, and then a statute. In 2015 Eske Willerslev and colleagues published a genome from the remains. The Corps commissioned a check of that work and, in April 2016, received a report that agreed: the DNA sequence is genetically closer to modern Native Americans than to any other population worldwide. On 28 April 2016 Brigadier General Scott Spellmon determined that Kennewick Man is Native American under NAGPRA. The Army’s notice is careful about the next step. A Native American determination is not a finding of cultural affiliation. Affiliation, it says, is a separate inquiry and needs a preponderance of the evidence. The remains stayed at the Burke while that inquiry was to begin.
Congress did not wait on it. Section 1152 of the Water Infrastructure Improvements for the Nation Act, Public Law 114-322, is titled Kennewick Man. It defines the claimant tribes as the Colville, Yakama, Nez Perce, Umatilla, and the Wanapum Band of Priest Rapids, and it defines the remains as Kennewick Man or the Ancient One, including the projectile point in the right ilium and residue from earlier sampling, collection 45BN495. Notwithstanding NAGPRA, the Secretary, through the Chief of Engineers, was to transfer the remains within ninety days to the Washington Department of Archaeology and Historic Preservation, on condition that the state repatriate them to those tribes, for burial in Washington. The Corps’ implementation memorandum stopped the NAGPRA custody review and carried out that direction. On 17 February 2017, at the Burke Museum, it transferred the remains to the state, and the state repatriated them the same day to the five Columbia River Plateau tribes. The Burke’s statement says the remains were reburied in a private ceremony, according to the tribes’ traditions, and that they had never been on display. The only genetic sentence these pages support is the one the Corps used: closer to modern Native Americans than to any other population worldwide. No percentage is stated here because none of these pages states one.
Corps of Engineers, Native American determination, 28 April 2016: https://www.army.mil/article/166972/corps_determines_kennewick_man_is_native_american.
Corps determination memorandum: https://usace.contentdm.oclc.org/digital/api/collection/p16021coll11/id/949/download.
Ninth Circuit, Bonnichsen v. United States, 367 F.3d 864: https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F3/367/367.F3d.864.02-35996.02-35994.html.
Burke Museum, on the return of 17 February 2017: https://www.burkemuseum.org/news/ancient-one-kennewick-man.
Corps implementation memorandum for section 1152: https://usace.contentdm.oclc.org/utils/getfile/collection/p16021coll5/id/35597.
Public Law 114-322, section 1152: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-114publ322/pdf/PLAW-114publ322.pdf.
What Documented Settles
Documented: discovery on 28 July 1996 on Corps land; a tribal claim and a scientists’ suit; a 2004 holding that the remains were not Native American under NAGPRA because no relationship to a presently existing tribe was shown, so study could proceed; an April 2016 Corps finding that they are Native American, using a DNA comparison the Corps states without a percentage; and a statutory transfer on 17 February 2017 to Washington for repatriation to the five Plateau tribes. The April 2016 paper did not itself complete a cultural-affiliation finding. The return was directed by statute notwithstanding NAGPRA.