The denial at Spirit Cave was that the dead were too old to be anyone’s kin. On 26 June 2000 the Nevada State Office of the Bureau of Land Management determined that the human remains from the cave were not culturally affiliated with any modern individual, Indian tribe, or other group. The Fallon Paiute-Shoshone disputed that finding. What later changed was not a Bureau finding that affiliation had been proved. In November 2016 the Bureau transferred control of the assemblage to the tribe as the people of the aboriginal land, after years in which the Bureau had said a shared group identity could not be traced. The remains had been treated as unaffiliated because of their age.
Spirit Cave was found in 1940 by Sydney and Georgia Wheeler during salvage excavations for the Nevada State Parks Commission east of Fallon, on land then United States land and now administered by the Bureau. The assemblage is four individuals and ten associated funerary objects, curated at the Nevada State Museum in Carson City. The 2016 inventory names them: a mummified adult male, about forty to forty-four, burial 2; a cremation; an adult woman of about thirty to thirty-five; a youth of about fifteen. The ten objects are mats, moccasins, a rabbit-skin blanket, and woven bags. Radiocarbon estimates in that notice run from 5,400 to 10,600 years ago. The Interior Department’s account of the return adds that textile dates in the mid-1990s put one burial, the mummified set, in excess of 10,000 years, among the oldest known in North America.
The 2000 refusal is restated, with its reasons, in the inventory notice of 18 October 2016. The Bureau wrote that material culture in the grave — the blanket, the moccasins, the mats — fits a broad Numic pattern shared by Paiute, Shoshone, Ute, and Goshute peoples, not a trace that singles out one tribe. DNA analysis, the same notice says, illustrates that the Spirit Cave remains are more closely related to Native Americans than to any other population. The same notice says that result does not identify an earlier cultural group under the affiliation rule. Officials determined that a relationship of shared group identity cannot reasonably be traced. The tribe’s claim was already on the museum’s books before that second refusal. A 1999 Nevada State Museum newsletter records the Bureau preparing a NAGPRA decision on which present-day tribe, if any, should receive the remains, and records the Fallon-Shoshone position that the cave lies within traditional tribal territory and that the tribe should have a voice. The museum was housing the remains and withholding public display of a skull and bust reproduction until affiliation was decided. The NAGPRA Review Committee took the dispute on 17–19 November 2001. Its findings, published in the Federal Register on 10 April 2002, were six to one. The majority found a shared group identity, reasonably traced, between the Fallon Paiute-Shoshone Tribe and the Spirit Cave remains, and found that the Nevada office had not weighed all the evidence fairly. It recommended repatriation. The notice says those findings do not necessarily represent the National Park Service or the Secretary, who had not taken a position. The Nevada State Museum’s February 2007 newsletter records what the Bureau did next. It reaffirmed non-affiliation. In February 2004 the national director of the Bureau affirmed the Nevada determination. The tribe sued. In September 2006 Judge Larry Hicks, in federal district court in Nevada, found no error in the 2000 determination, no bias, and adequate consultation, and he did not order the remains returned. He remanded only for a clearer account of why the Bureau had rejected the committee’s findings.
The October 2016 notice is still a non-affiliation notice. The land is, by Indian Claims Commission judgments cited there, aboriginal land of the Northern Paiute, and the notice lists the tribes who represent that aboriginal title, the Paiute-Shoshone Tribe of the Fallon Reservation and Colony among them. Disposition could go to those tribes. Transfer to Fallon could proceed if no other requestor wrote by 17 November 2016. On 23 November 2016 the Department of the Interior announced that, effective 18 November, the Bureau had transferred control to the Fallon Paiute Shoshone Indian Tribe, described as the closest tribe living on aboriginal lands near the burial. The tribe, Secretary Sally Jewell’s release says, now had full legal control and might take permanent possession. In December 2017 Bryan Hockett of the Nevada Bureau told the agency’s preservation board that resolving the case had taken about twenty years from the 1990 statute. The remains had been unaffiliated in the Bureau’s determinations of 2000 and 2016. Control passed on the aboriginal-land rule to the tribe that had asked for them since the 1990s.
Department of the Interior, transfer effective 18 November 2016: https://www.doi.gov/pressreleases/secretary-jewell-announces-return-native-american-funerary-objects-and-human-remains.
Federal Register, inventory notice, 18 October 2016: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2016/10/18/2016-25128/notice-of-inventory-completion-us-department-of-the-interior-bureau-of-land-management-nevada-state.
Federal Register, Review Committee findings, 10 April 2002: https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2002/04/10/02-8577/native-american-graves-protection-and-repatriation-review-committee-findings-and-recommendations.
Nevada State Museum newsletter, February 2007, on the Hicks ruling: https://epubs.nsla.nv.gov/statepubs/epubs/211385-2007-02.pdf.
Nevada State Museum newsletter, 1999, Spirit Cave Man update: https://epubs.nsla.nv.gov/statepubs/epubs/211385-1999-Sep.pdf.
Bureau of Land Management Preservation Board, December 2017: https://edit.blm.gov/sites/default/files/docs/2022-08/December2017_Preservation_Board_report.pdf.
What Documented Settles
Documented: a 1940 cave assemblage of four people and ten funerary objects, held at the Nevada State Museum under Bureau control; a 2000 determination of no cultural affiliation; a 2002 Review Committee finding of affiliation that the Bureau did not adopt; a 2006 court remand that did not order return; an October 2016 notice that again found no affiliation and opened disposition to Fallon; and a transfer of control effective 18 November 2016. The notice’s only DNA statement is that comparison, and the same notice says it did not establish affiliation.
