How the papers surfaced
According to the case record kept by Weight of Evidence, "A roll of 35mm film said to have arrived by mail from an unidentified sender in December 1984 carried images of two purported 'Top Secret / Eyes Only' records." One was a one-page memo attributed to President Truman, dated September 24, 1947. The other was a briefing paper dated November 18, 1952, describing a committee of scientists and generals, called Majestic 12, formed to handle recovered craft. The papers were made public in 1987. Philip J. Klass dates the release to May 29, 1987, by three researchers.
The case as its champions present it
The website Majestic Documents is "led by Robert and Ryan Wood," whom it describes as "a father and son team with 50 years of combined UFO study." The site calls itself "the first to authenticate top secret UFO documents," and presents a timeline of crash retrievals "from 1941 until three days before President Kennedy's assassination in 1963."
What the Archives found
The U.S. National Archives searched the relevant record groups. The results "were all negative except for a Memorandum for General Twining, from Robert Cutler, Special Assistant to the President, Subject: 'NCS/MJ-12 Special Studies Project' dated July 14, 1954. The memorandum, one page, refers to a briefing to take place on July 16. The memorandum does not identify MJ-12 or the purpose of the briefing."
The Archives lists questions about that note. It has no record of a National Security Council meeting on July 16, 1954, and the July 1954 council minutes do not mention MJ-12 or Majestic. Cutler was overseas on July 14, 1954. The paper type is questioned, and the Archives says that "Lay or Cone would have signed it." It adds a general caution: "We do not authenticate documents."
The FBI teletype
The Weight of Evidence record reports that on September 15, 1988, an agent of the Air Force Office of Special Investigations delivered "a copy of the briefing document" to the FBI in Dallas. On November 30, 1988, the Air Force office advised that the document was fabricated, and an FBI headquarters teletype of December 2, 1988, recorded that it is "completely bogus."
The typewriter and the signature
Writing in Skeptical Inquirer in 1990, Klass reported that a questioned document examiner found the Truman memo's typeface matched "a Smith-Corona machine that first appeared in 1963." The examiner later called the signature "a classic signature transplant," a photocopy of Truman's real signature from an October 1, 1947 letter to Vannevar Bush.
In his first article, in 1988, Klass argued that "the format of the September 24 memorandum to Defense Secretary Forrestal differs significantly" from other memos of the period, and that its second paragraph is "un-Truman-like."
The adherents' answer
Robert Wood answered at the MUFON symposium in 2001. He argued that "chromatographic ink dating and other state of the art techniques clearly indicate that the documents were likely to have been created long ago," and that they could not be modern forgeries. Comparisons with archival documents, he said, "show the expected similarities," and the content fits "arcane facts known to only scholars." For the papers' defenders, a forger would have needed both period materials and a historian's knowledge. Who typed the memo, and when?