What the published accounts denied was that Steinhoff’s growth and retail story rested on statements later found false, misleading, or deceptive. The how, in the regulator and court record, was irregular and fictitious transactions that inflated profits and asset values, kept out of the public overview until investigators and courts forced more into view. The why was the listed-group growth narrative on the Johannesburg and Frankfurt exchanges.
What the Boards Told the Market
On 6 December 2017 Steinhoff’s Supervisory Board announced accounting irregularities requiring further investigation, engagement of PwC, and the resignation of CEO Markus Jooste. Deloitte had refused to sign off the 2017 statements. PwC’s March 2019 report ran to thousands of pages; the company released an eleven-page overview stating that former executives and other non-Steinhoff executives had structured fictitious and irregular transactions that substantially inflated profits and asset values. The Supreme Court of Appeal later treated that overview as a gist disclosure of the irregularities and ordered release of the full report to media requesters under PAIA.
SAFLII — Ibex RSA Holdco Ltd v Tiso Blackstar Group (Pty) Ltd [2024] ZASCA 166 (4 December 2024): https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZASCA/2024/166.html Supreme Court of Appeal — judgment PDF, Ibex RSA Holdco Ltd v Tiso Blackstar [2024] ZASCA 166: https://inforrm.org/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/SCA2024-166.pdf
FSCA Market-Abuse Findings on False Statements
On 19–20 March 2024 the Financial Sector Conduct Authority issued a R475 million administrative penalty against Jooste for contraventions of section 81(1)(a) and (b) of the Financial Markets Act arising from Steinhoff International Holdings Ltd and NV annual financial statements and annual reports for 2014–2016 and the 2017 half-year. The FSCA found that Jooste and Dirk Schreiber made or published false, misleading, or deceptive statements, including by omission of material facts. Schreiber entered a leniency agreement; no administrative penalty was imposed on him under that agreement. Earlier, the FSCA had imposed a R1.5 billion group penalty remitted to R53 million. Those are regulator administrative findings, not a criminal judgment.
FSCA — Administrative penalty order, Markus Johannes Jooste (section 81 false statements, 19 March 2024): https://www2.fsca.co.za/Enforcement-Matters/Lists/Enforcement%20Actions/Attachments/385/SNH%20Signed%20Order%20Letter%20_%20Mr%20Jooste%20_%2019%20March%202024.pdf
FSCA — Regulatory Actions Report (Box 4: Steinhoff – Markus Jooste; R475 million): https://www2.fsca.co.za/Documents/FSCA%20Regulatory%20Actions%20Report%20-%2028%20June.pdf
Insider-Trading Administrative Door
Separately, on 6 December 2022 the FSCA issued an administrative penalty order against Jooste for encouraging others to deal in Steinhoff securities while an insider, under section 78(5) of the Financial Markets Act, after a Financial Services Tribunal reconsideration. The order imposed R20 million. That door is market-abuse administrative process on tipper-encouragement facts around late November 2017; it is not the accounting-irregularity criminal case.
FSCA — Administrative penalty order, Markus Johannes Jooste (insider trading, 6 December 2022): https://www2.fsca.co.za/Enforcement-Matters/Documents/SNH%20Signed%20Penalty%20Order%20%20-%20insider%20trading%20-%20Mr%20Jooste%20_%206%20December%202022.pdf
High Court Access Fight
In the Western Cape High Court PAIA litigation that preceded the SCA appeal, media applicants sought the full PwC forensic report after Steinhoff refused access on privilege grounds. The SCA record recounts that the High Court ordered production; Steinhoff’s successors (Ibex entities) appealed and lost. The documented core for this page remains the accounting irregularities described in the overview and FSCA section 81 findings. Wider guilt-by-association and unfinished criminal dockets stay outside L1.
SAFLII — Tiso Blackstar Group (Pty) Ltd v Steinhoff International Holdings N.V. [2022] ZAWCHC 265: https://www.saflii.org/za/cases/ZAWCHC/2022/265.html
Roles, Not Color
Jooste appears as CEO who resigned on 6 December 2017, FSCA noticee on section 81 and section 78 orders, and a person the SCA judgment notes died before criminal charges were brought. Schreiber appears as co-contravener under a leniency agreement. Directors and boards appear as publishers of SENS announcements and overview text. No lifestyle gloss.
Quantum in the Overview and the FSCA Tables
The SCA judgment recounts that Steinhoff’s overview described irregular income creation totaling some R6.5 billion across financial years 2009 to 2017 in certain profit-and-asset-creation channels, with loans or receivables lacking economic substance, and that share value fell by over 98% after December 2017. The FSCA’s March 2024 section 81 order, as set out in the Authority’s 19 March 2024 order, itemizes misstatements the Authority attributed to Jooste’s creation or causing of transactions without economic substance: for 2014, operating profit before tax overstated by about R3.26 billion and cash and cash equivalents by about R13.73 billion; for 2015, operating profit by about R3.24 billion and cash by about R31.38 billion, plus Steinhoff UK goodwill inflation near R3.93 billion; for 2016 (euro figures in the NV accounts), operating profit overstated by about EUR 271 million and cash by about EUR 2.18 billion, with Steinhoff UK goodwill inflation near EUR 253 million; and for the 2017 half-year, Mattress Firm reported operating profit of EUR 21 million when the Authority’s adjusted figure was an operating loss near EUR 54 million absent EUR 80 million contribution transactions. The Regulatory Actions Report restates the R475 million record fine and notes a roughly 61.42% share-price drop on 6 December 2017 after the irregularity announcement and resignation. Those are administrative and appellate record figures. They do not become a criminal conviction by being printed here, and they do not extend L1 clearance to every other noticee or accused outside these doors.
What the Paper Trail Settles — and Holds
Documented: December 2017 irregularity announcement and CEO resignation; PwC overview of fictitious and irregular inflation of profits and assets; FSCA section 81 administrative penalty of R475 million against Jooste; FSCA section 78 administrative penalty of R20 million; SCA order compelling the forensic report’s release. The documented core is the accounting-irregularity record; wider guilt-by-association and unfinished criminal dockets stay outside L1. The Archive files those doors as contested / L2 HOLD.
