A girl named only as Nayirah told a caucus of babies taken from incubators; she was the Kuwaiti ambassador's daughter.
The record runs from Amnesty International's report of December 1990, through Middle East Watch's investigation of February 1992 and press reports that year, to Human Rights Watch's world report for 1993 and a Senate debate of June 1994 in which Amnesty's later position and Middle East Watch's comments on the Kroll report were entered. What was hidden was her identity and the campaign behind the hearing; the means was a first name and a volunteer's story; the reasons these doors print are the push toward war and, in the account given for the hearing, her family's safety.
The testimony as Amnesty printed it, December 1990
Amnesty's report "Iraq/Occupied Kuwait: Human Rights Violations since 2 August," embargoed for 19 December 1990 (AI Index MDE 14/16/90), says over 300 premature babies were reported to have died after Iraqi soldiers removed them from incubators, which were then looted, at al-Razi and al-'Addan hospitals and the Maternity Hospital. It quotes a Red Crescent doctor giving 312 deaths, and an eyewitness account at al-'Addan "provided by a 15-year-old Kuwaiti girl, who testified before the United State Congressional Human Rights Caucus on 10 October": "I saw the Iraqi soldiers come into the hospital with guns, and go into the room where 15 babies were in incubators. They took the babies out of the incubators, took the incubators and left the babies on the cold floor to die."
Amnesty International, December 1990: https://www.amnesty.org/en/wp-content/uploads/2021/05/MDE140161990ENGLISH.pdf
Middle East Watch, February 1992
Middle East Watch's report "Kuwait's 'Stolen' Incubators: The Widespread Repercussions of a Murky Incident" says that at the caucus hearing of 10 October 1990 a 15-year-old girl "identified only as Nayirah" testified that she had volunteered at al-Addan hospital. It says Citizens for a Free Kuwait was set up in Washington within weeks of the invasion, drew almost all its funds from the Kuwaiti government, about 95 percent according to its filings with the Justice Department, and hired Hill & Knowlton, which according to press reports was paid $5.6 million between August and December 1990. It says the hearing was "organized from the Kuwaiti side by Hill & Knowlton," and that Nayirah, "it was recently confirmed, is the daughter of Kuwait's Ambassador to the United States, Shaikh Saud al-Nasser al-Sabah." It cites John R. MacArthur's op-ed "Remember Nayirah, Witness for Kuwait?" in the New York Times of 6 January 1992. Doctors at al-Addan told the group no baby was thrown out of any incubator there, and after checking hospital and cemetery records it found "no basis" to the allegation. It writes that the story "served the interest of those attempting to tip the balance toward war."
Middle East Watch, February 1992: https://www.hrw.org/reports/pdfs/k/kuwait/kuwait922.pdf
Kuwait City, March 1992
The Los Angeles Times reported on 6 March 1992 that the incubator account was still official Kuwaiti writ, while human rights groups said their investigations did not support it; it quotes Amnesty's April 1991 finding of "no reliable evidence." It says the January disclosure showed that the girl identified at the time only as Nayirah was the daughter of Sheik Saud al Nasser al Sabah, and that she had claimed to be a volunteer at Al Addan. It reports that Kroll Associates had been retained to verify her testimony, and that the US envoy to Kuwait, Edward W. Gnehm Jr., cabled in February that embassy officers were convinced babies died when Iraqis removed life support systems.
Los Angeles Times, 6 March 1992: https://www.latimes.com/archives/la-xpm-1992-03-06-mn-3337-story.html
MERIP, July 1992
A MERIP column of July 1992 says Hill and Knowlton ran a $10 million campaign to build support for the war, paid for by Citizens for a Free Kuwait, "a front for Kuwait's ruling family," and that its most dramatic moment was the appearance of "a young woman identified only as 'Nayirah'" before a Congressional committee, an incident President Bush cited. It says stories starting with MacArthur's op-ed revealed she was the ambassador's daughter, that the firm apparently chose the incubator story after testing reactions in focus groups, and that it coached Nayirah and other witnesses. It says Hill and Knowlton denied wrongdoing and sued the German programme "Monitor," and that the court did not grant the retraction it wanted.
MERIP, July 1992: https://www.merip.org/1992/07/the-news-industry/
Human Rights Watch, 1993
The Middle East Watch chapter of Human Rights Watch's World Report 1993 records that the February report answered "resurrected claims by the Kuwaiti and U.S. governments" about babies taken from incubators, and that in May 1992 Middle East Watch filed a brief in the Frankfurt District Court in support of a German television network sued by Hill and Knowlton over its conclusions on the incubator allegation.
Human Rights Watch World Report 1993: https://www.hrw.org/reports/1993/WR93/Mew-06.htm
The Senate record, June 1994
The Congressional Record of 16 June 1994, in a Senate debate on a nomination, carries the statement of Senator Hollings of South Carolina that there was no public disclosure that the witness sent by Hill & Knowlton to the caucus, chaired by Congressman Tom Lantos, was the ambassador's daughter, with the nominee's account that Lantos knew and "for safety reasons" chose not to disclose it. Senator Faircloth of North Carolina said the girl was identified at the time only as "Nayira" and that the stated reason was to protect her family in Kuwait. The Record prints Amnesty International USA's letter of 10 June 1994 quoting its April 1991 release: "once we were actually in Kuwait and had visited hospitals and cemeteries and spoken to doctors at work, we found that the story did not stand up." It also prints Middle East Watch's comments of 16 July 1992 on the report by Kroll Associates, hired by the Kuwaiti government: Kroll found no support for large-scale incubator raids, confirmed seven baby deaths tied to looted incubators and ventilators, of which only one fit the charge, and now said Nayirah never volunteered at al-Addan, was there only for "moments," and saw one baby.
Congressional Record, 16 June 1994: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/CREC-1994-06-16/html/CREC-1994-06-16-pt1-PgS6.htm
What was hidden
As these doors print it, the witness was the daughter of Kuwait's ambassador, and the hearing was organised for a campaign that the Kuwaiti government funded through Citizens for a Free Kuwait and Hill & Knowlton. She appeared under her first name only, as a hospital volunteer. Middle East Watch and MERIP tie the story to building support for war; the reason given for withholding her name was her family's safety. Middle East Watch and Amnesty later found no reliable evidence for the incubator story, and the Kroll report, paid for by Kuwait, kept a narrower version that Middle East Watch disputed.
