The denial was in the classification. Line costs that were operating expenses were booked as capital assets so the earnings held. Line costs were the fees WorldCom paid other carriers for the right to use their networks. Under the generally accepted accounting principles the Securities and Exchange Commission later invoked, those fees are expenses. They are not assets. Beginning at least in the first quarter of 2001, the Commission’s civil complaint alleged, senior management directed that line costs be transferred into capital accounts in amounts large enough to keep reported earnings in line with analysts’ consensus and to support the stock. The 2001 Form 10-K reported line costs of $14.739 billion and earnings before income taxes and minority interests of $2.393 billion. The complaint says the line costs were about $17.794 billion and the result was a loss of about $662 million. The first-quarter 2002 Form 10-Q reported line costs of $3.479 billion and pretax income of $240 million. The complaint says the line costs were about $4.276 billion and the loss about $557 million. The filings did not say the treatment had changed. The why, on the face of the complaint, was the growth story: as the economy cooled in 2001, real results would not meet the quarterly estimates, and the entries were built to make it look as if they had. A claim that telecommunications as a whole was a fraud is not what this complaint charges. It charges WorldCom’s books.
The 2002 Civil Case
On 26 June 2002 the Commission sued WorldCom in the Southern District of New York. Litigation Release 17588, the next day, called it a fraud of more than $3.8 billion: income before taxes and minority interests overstated by about $3.055 billion in 2001 and $797 million in the first quarter of 2002, by capitalizing costs that should have been expensed. The release states the purpose as misleading investors and keeping earnings in line with Wall Street estimates. The complaint charges Exchange Act sections 10(b) and 13(a) and the related reporting rules. The Commission asked for an injunction, a penalty, a bar on destroying documents, a bar on extraordinary payments to officers and employees, and a corporate monitor. It also ordered a sworn report of the circumstances by 1 July. Those are allegations and a filing, not yet a judgment.
SEC — complaint, SEC v. WorldCom, Inc., 26 June 2002: https://www.sec.gov/litigation/complaints/complr17588.htm
SEC — Litigation Release 17588, 27 June 2002: https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/litigation-releases/lr-17588
The Entries the Government Later Described
The Solicitor General’s brief opposing certiorari in Ebbers v. United States describes what the trial record showed. Line costs, fees for leased network facilities, were WorldCom’s largest expense. To hide deteriorating results and missed analyst expectations, then-chief executive Bernard J. Ebbers and chief financial officer Scott Sullivan agreed to report false numbers and instructed subordinates to book general-ledger entries that increased reported revenue and decreased reported line costs. In the third quarter of 2000 line costs ran almost $1 billion over expectation. Sullivan first drained reserve accounts. When the reserves were gone, he had line costs reclassified as capital expenditures, with Ebbers’s knowledge and approval. From the first quarter of 2001 through the first quarter of 2002, about $3.8 billion moved from line-cost expense accounts to capital-expenditure accounts.The brief says a jury in the Southern District of New York convicted Ebbers of conspiracy to commit securities fraud, securities fraud, and making false filings with the Commission. He was sentenced to 25 years’ imprisonment and three years’ supervised release. The court of appeals affirmed. The brief calls him president and chief executive officer. It does not call the rest of the industry a defendant.
Department of Justice, Office of the Solicitor General — brief in opposition, Ebbers v. United States: https://www.justice.gov/osg/brief/ebbers-v-united-states-opposition
What the CEO Complaint Added
The Commission’s 2005 civil complaint against Ebbers alleges a wider set of books than the June 2002 company case. It says that from at least September 2000 until late June 2002, Ebbers, Sullivan, and other senior executives concealed poor performance with false adjustments, often in the hundreds of millions of dollars, so quarterly results would meet Wall Street expectations, some of them targets Ebbers had set and knew could not be met legitimately. It alleges the undisclosed adjustments overstated reported income by at least $9 billion. It alleges line-cost reductions against reserve accounts in 2000, and then, from the quarter ended March 2001 through March 2002, reductions of line-cost expense and matching increases to capital-asset accounts, after the quarter closed, without business justification, lowering reported line costs by about $3.8 billion. It alleges that, told there was no legitimate accounting that would hit the number, he replied in substance, “We have to hit our numbers.” Those are allegations. The $9 billion figure is the Commission’s allegation about WorldCom’s income, not a finding that every carrier’s books were false. The line-cost capitalization of about $3.8 billion is the entry this page treats as the core, because the company complaint, the release, the CEO complaint, and the government’s brief all describe it.
SEC — complaint, SEC v. Bernard J. Ebbers: https://www.sec.gov/files/litigation/complaints/comp19301.pdf
The Civil Settlement and the Sentence
Litigation Release 19301, 13 July 2005, says Ebbers agreed to settle the civil case without admitting or denying the allegations: an injunction against the antifraud and related provisions, and a permanent bar on serving as an officer or director of a public company, subject to court approval. The Commission called it the sixth civil action tied to the fraud. It noted a 15 March conviction and that Judge Barbara Jones would sentence him that day. The Southern District of New York’s case page records the sentence that followed: on 13 July 2005 defendant Bernard J. Ebbers was sentenced to 25 years’ imprisonment. He is named here as chief executive, as defendant, and as the person that sentence names. The release does not convert the civil consent, which was without admission, into the criminal judgment. The criminal judgment is the conviction and the sentence.
SEC — Litigation Release 19301, 13 July 2005: https://www.sec.gov/enforcement-litigation/litigation-releases/lr-19301
U.S. Attorney’s Office, Southern District of New York — United States v. Bernard Ebbers: https://www.justice.gov/usao-sdny/united-states-v-bernard-ebbers
What Stays Inside the Record
The documented core is the line-cost entries and the cases: operating fees moved to capital accounts, the 2001 and early-2002 Commission filings, a civil suit against the company, a civil suit against the chief executive settled without an admission, and a jury conviction and a 25-year sentence. The $3.8 billion transfer is the figure the government’s brief and the Ebbers complaint both use for that reclassification. The $9 billion is a broader income allegation in the CEO complaint, still about this company. A wider claim that all of telecommunications was a fraud is outside what these doors establish. The Archive holds the page at contested / L2 and does not file it as documented.