Browse all theories tagged with this keyword
On 5 December 1872 the British brig Dei Gratia found the American brigantine Mary Celeste between the Azores and Portugal, sound, provisioned and under sail, with no one aboard. Captain Benjamin Briggs, his wife Sarah, their two-year-old daughter Sophia and seven crewmen were gone, along with the ship's boat and papers. The 1873 press reported a bloodstained sword and cuts on the bows, and the U.S. Treasury wrote of "grave suspicions" of murder. No body, boat or survivor was ever found.
The Fox sisters' spirit-rapping story contains both an accusation of coordinated performance and a later repudiation of that confession. An early witness pamphlet, Leah's memoir, Davenport's exposure narrative and an 1889 newspaper reprint preserve different stages; modern accounts disagree over their weight. Allegations about hidden tricks or pressure must remain attributed. A demonstration can show that a sound is reproducible without proving every earlier sitting used it, or deciding the truth of an entire religion.
The Mahatma Letters controversy concerns alleged human manufacture of communications attributed to hidden teachers, and counterclaims that Helena Blavatsky was unfairly framed. The letters, Emma Coulomb’s accusation, the 1885 investigation and contemporary protest have different evidentiary roles. Vernon Harrison’s later criticism challenges methods without proving supernatural authorship. Neither a hostile report nor a sympathetic reassessment can substitute for establishing a document’s provenance.
William Carpenter’s 1885 Baltimore pamphlet *One Hundred Proofs that the Earth is Not a Globe* packages zetetic anti-globe arguments adherents still cite. LOC/Internet Archive/Gutenberg preserve the text; Proctor-era reception refused it as cosmology. Contested/L2 documents the pamphlet and reception without baptizing Flat Earth as true.
Zetetic astronomy told readers not to trust a theory they had not tested, and the video revival has not ended the fight. In 1865 a London and Bath book issued under the name Parallax defined that distrust as a method: search and examine, and do not begin by assuming the causes. A Library of Congress guide catalogs earlier and later print under the same name, including an 1849 pamphlet and an 1881 edition, without settling the figure of the earth.
The Old Bedford canal is read as a measured curve of about five feet in Wallace's Field letters and in Walsh's decision, and as level water in Parallax's 1865 book, Carpenter's report, Parallax's April 1870 pamphlet, and Lady Blount's 1904 photograph. Contested/L2.
Wilbur Glenn Voliva, General Overseer of Zion, Illinois’s Christian Catholic community, preached a flat Earth in *Leaves of Healing*, directed church schools against globular astronomy, and broadcast on station WCBD beginning in 1923. Commerce Department and Federal Radio Commission monitoring treated WCBD as a sectarian specialty station. Digitized Zion serials and radio-history research doors document that institutional reception under contested clearance; the page refuses science-dismiss baptism.
The Dos Palmas serpent rests on a single unsigned item in the Los Angeles Daily Times of 18 January 1882, headlined as a snake story and ending "given for what it is worth." It names no witness, sits beside the paper's own jokes about Western snake stories, and has no follow-up in the sources checked. A search of the paper's later January, February and March 1882 issues on the same archive turned up no sequel, letter or correction, with the same caveat about scanned text. The desert stop, the stage route and the railroad were real.