Zetetic astronomy told readers not to trust a theory they had not tested, and the video revival has not ended the fight. In 1865 a London and Bath book issued under the name Parallax defined that distrust as a method: search and examine, and do not begin by assuming the causes. A Library of Congress guide catalogs earlier and later print under the same name, including an 1849 pamphlet and an 1881 edition, without settling the figure of the earth. A 2021 article in Media Psychology reports that people interviewed at a 2017 conference said they came to the view after videos. A 2022 paper studies later public talk, including a São Paulo meeting and widely viewed videos, and does not close the question. Agency sheets print radii and two geopotential constants for an ellipsoid. The method, the videos, and the sheets sit side by side.
What the 1865 Book Calls Zetetic
The Project Gutenberg text of Zetetic Astronomy: Earth Not a Globe is the 1865 edition. The title page calls it an experimental inquiry into the true figure of the earth, proving it a plane, without axial or orbital motion, and the only material world in the universe. The author line is Parallax. The printers and publishers are S. Hayward of Green Street, Bath, and Simpkin, Marshall, and Co., Stationers' Hall Court, London. The opening defines zetetic from the Greek verb zeteo: to search or examine, to proceed only by inquiry. The book says the result of special experiments, arranged in logical order, will be more satisfactory than framing a theory and assuming causes. It compares the method to a court, where evidence for and against is arranged before a verdict, and it objects to assuming the conclusion first.
On standing water, the book states what a globe of 25,000 miles in circumference would require: the surface of all standing water must be an arc, curving from the summit at the rate of 8 inches per mile multiplied by the square of the distance. That sentence is the book's statement of the test it thinks a globe must pass. It is not a measurement taken from an agency sheet, and it is not repeated here as a finding that the test was passed or failed. The distrust the title names is distrust of received astronomy that has not been put through that kind of inquiry.
Project Gutenberg, 1865 text: https://www.gutenberg.org/files/69892/69892-h/69892-h.htm
What the Library Guide Catalogs
The Library of Congress guide to books lists, under Samuel B. Rowbotham, a work whose catalog title begins Zetetic astronomy. A description of several experiments which prove that the surface of the sea is a perfect plane, and that the earth is not a globe. The guide says it is the substance of a paper read before the Royal Astronomical Society, by Parallax, Birmingham, W. Cornish, 1849, 16 pages, call number QB638 .R87. The guide does not transcribe the experiments. A separate entry, held by Yale University Library at QB52 R68 1881, gives the 1881 title Zetetic astronomy. Earth not a globe, an experimental inquiry proving it a plane, without orbital or axial motion. The guide says an older edition is available online. Those are catalog facts. They are not a membership roll, and they are not a decision between the pamphlet and a later radius.
Library of Congress guide to books: https://guides.loc.gov/flat-earth/books
What Interviews Say About Videos
Asheley R. Landrum, Alex Olshansky, and Othello Richards, in Media Psychology, volume 24, number 1, 2021, pages 136 through 165, online 29 September 2019, write that YouTube has been monumental in the movement according to leaders and according to interviews. The vast majority of interviewees from the first International Flat Earth Conference in Raleigh, North Carolina, said they had come to believe the earth was flat only after watching videos. The article says that while people watched videos about other claims, including claims about 9/11, the service recommended Flat Earth Clues by Mark Sargent and 200 Proofs the Earth is Not a Spinning Ball by Eric Dubay. Interviewees described ignoring the recommendations, then watching in order to answer them, and then accepting the premise that people do not live on a spinning ball. The article also reports an experiment with regular users of the service. It does not print the 1865 experiments, and it is not a ruling on the people who attended.
Texas Tech repository copy: https://ttu-ir.tdl.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/90bc2757-d8ac-4da1-929f-b5dfa66264e8/content
What a 2022 Paper Studies
Cristiano Mattos, Felipe Sanches Lopez, José Luis Ortega, and André Rodrigues, in Science & Education, study public discussion. The paper says its data include transcriptions of nine seminars at FlatCon Brazil, held 10 November 2019 in São Paulo, the ten most viewed videos on the topic as the data note describes them, and interviews at that conference. The interviews were with seven participants who said they hold that the earth is flat, and with one astrophysicist who described himself as an intruder and whose view differed. The paper says the seminars take up, among other subjects, reasons scientists would have to lie to the public. It does not name Parallax, and it does not quote the 8-inch rule. It is a study of later talk. It is not a verdict on the 1865 title.
Science & Education, 2022: https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8800547/
What the Agency Sheets Print
The NASA Goddard fact sheet for Earth lists an equatorial radius of 6378.137 kilometers, a polar radius of 6356.752 kilometers, a volumetric mean radius of 6371.000 kilometers, and an ellipticity, or flattening, of 0.003353. The National Geodetic Survey's page on the geopotential surface says the earth's shape can be described as an ellipsoid, or an oblate spheroid, with a radius at the equator larger than at the poles. It prints a geopotential constant, W0, of 62,636,853.4 square meters per second squared, adopted by the International Association of Geodesy from satellite altimetry, and a second value, 62,636,856.00, agreed by the National Geodetic Survey and the Canadian Geodetic Survey for the North American-Pacific Geopotential Datum of 2022. Those figures are not a reply written to Parallax, and they are not used here as a winning vote.
NASA Earth fact sheet: https://nssdc.gsfc.nasa.gov/planetary/factsheet/earthfact.html
NOAA geopotential surface: https://geodesy.noaa.gov/research/geopotential-datums/geopotential-surface.shtml
What Sits Beside the Distrust
The distrust the 1865 book names is a refusal to start from a framed theory: inquiry first, then a deduction, with standing water offered as the test a globe must meet. The library guide shows that print continued from an 1849 pamphlet title through an 1881 edition. The 2021 article records a later path through recommended videos, including titles by Sargent and Dubay, among people who said they changed their view after watching. The 2022 paper records a São Paulo conference and a set of widely viewed videos, and it records suspicion, inside that talk, that scientists lie to the public. The radii and the two constants are the sheets' numbers for an ellipsoid. None of the six documents declares the fight over. The zetetic demand and the later videos remain beside the sheets.