Adherents say Artemis continues a staged Apollo story; NASA records print an uncrewed 2022 flight and a crewed 2026 one.
The argument runs through three adherent pages: a 2015 essay on radiation data from Orion's first test flight, a revised essay on heat shields and re-entry, and a filmmaker's biography that sets modern capability against 1969. Beside them stand three NASA pages: the Artemis I mission record, a report on radiation measured inside Orion, and an October 2026 release of lunar science data from Artemis II. The adherent pages say NASA's present difficulties expose the Apollo record; the NASA pages print dates, distances, dose results and crew observations, and do not take up the staging claim.
Radiation on Orion's first flight, as Aulis read it
Mary Bennett's essay "Orion, the Van Allen Belts & Space Radiation Challenges," signed Aulis Online, October 2015, says the December 2014 Orion test flight climbed to about 3,600 miles (5,800 km) on a highly elliptical orbit into the region of the inner Van Allen belt. She writes that the Battery-operated Independent Radiation Detector (BIRD) report, dated 01-06-2015, first had to be sought through a Freedom of Information Act request before it appeared on a NASA site. She quotes its maximum absorbed dose rate of about 1 mGy per minute, "20 times the alarm level for the ISS-TEPC," and a total under 20 mGy over nearly 4.5 hours. She sets Apollo dosimetry from a 1998 NCRP table, such as an Apollo 11 daily dose of 0.22 mGy, beside those readings and argues that the Apollo figures sit closer to low-Earth-orbit values. Her conclusion is that the report "seemingly confirms" Apollo's lunar dosimetry was collected in low Earth orbit, and that NASA's own data "has blown apart the notion" that an Apollo crew went to the Moon.
Aulis Online, October 2015: https://www.aulis.com/orion_vanallens.htm
Heat shields and re-entry, in a revised Aulis essay
Phil Kouts's essay "The Apollo Myth: A Hindrance to Human Space Exploration," marked second edition, says NASA planned an uncrewed Exploration Mission-1 on the SLS to fly beyond the Moon and test high-speed re-entry and the thermal protection system, followed by a crewed EM-2. Quoting a 2016 GAO assessment, it says the Orion program was redesigning its heat shield after the December 2014 flight test, moving from a monolithic design to about 300 blocks. It argues that Apollo's direct re-entry would most likely have been disastrous for the module and that NASA now has to adopt skip re-entry. Its stated conclusion is that "NASA is still totally incapable of safely returning crews from deep space, and consequently the record of Apollo falls apart," and its subtitle says the Apollo story is "increasingly revealing itself to be pure fabrication."
Aulis Online, Kouts: https://www.aulis.com/moonbase2017.htm
A filmmaker's case from capability
The biography page on Sibrel.com says Bart Sibrel, a filmmaker and writer, came to regard the landings as falsified largely because of his professional familiarity with film-studio lighting. It says the claim that astronauts walked on the Moon at the first attempt with "antiquated untried 1960's technology" defies logic when, "today with six decades of more advanced technology," NASA "can only accomplish 20% as much." It says his memoir names the military base where the first staged landing was filmed, on information from that base's chief of security on his deathbed, and that he has appeared as a guest commentator on the subject on The Joe Rogan Experience, 60 Minutes, CNN and other programmes.
Sibrel.com biography: https://www.sibrel.com/about-bart-sibrel
The Artemis I record
NASA's Artemis I mission page calls the flight the first integrated test of the SLS rocket, the Orion spacecraft and Exploration Ground Systems. It says the uncrewed mission launched from Launch Pad 39B at Kennedy Space Center at 1:47 a.m. EST on 16 November 2022, flew beyond and around the Moon, and splashed down off San Diego at 12:40 p.m. EST on 11 December 2022, after 25 days, 10 hours and 53 minutes. It says Orion traveled 268,563 miles from Earth and 43,471 miles beyond the far side of the Moon and met 161 test objectives. It says the European-built service module generated 20% more power than expected, and that analysis of "unexpected char loss on the heat shield" fed forward to Artemis II, with enhancements under way for future shields. It describes radiation sensors on an instrumented manikin, Commander Moonikin Campos, and on two manikin torsos, Helga and Zohar, in an experiment with the German Aerospace Center.
NASA, Artemis I: https://www.nasa.gov/mission/artemis-i/
Radiation inside Orion
NASA's report "Artemis I Radiation Measurements Validate Orion Safety for Astronauts" says 5,600 passive sensors and 34 active detectors measured radiation inside Orion over the 25.5-day mission, including exposure within the Van Allen belt, in findings published by NASA's Space Radiation Analysis Group, the German Aerospace Center (DLR) and ESA. It says the spacecraft can protect its crew from potentially hazardous radiation levels during lunar missions, though exposure varies by location in the cabin and by orientation; when Orion changed attitude during an Interim Cryogenic Propulsion Stage burn, radiation levels dropped nearly in half. It quotes Stuart George, the lead author, as saying that "key challenges remain, especially for long-duration spaceflights and the protection of astronauts on spacewalks." It says the same hardware would fly on Artemis II.
NASA, Artemis I radiation: https://www.nasa.gov/missions/artemis/artemis-1/artemis-i-radiation-measurements-validate-orion-safety-for-astronauts/
Artemis II and its data
A NASA mission blog post of 7 October 2026 says the Artemis II crew, NASA astronauts Reid Wiseman, Victor Glover and Christina Koch and CSA astronaut Jeremy Hansen, traveled around the Moon and back, and that the full lunar science dataset was being released. It says the release, placed in NASA's Planetary Data System, holds more than 11,000 full-resolution images and video of the Moon from handheld and spacecraft cameras, 8.5 hours of audio of crew observations, and crew-annotated images, among them a tablet screenshot marked with impact flashes during the lunar flyby of 6 April 2026. It calls this the first planetary science dataset captured primarily by humans in more than half a century.
NASA, Artemis II data release: https://www.nasa.gov/blogs/missions/2026/10/07/nasa-releases-artemis-ii-lunar-science-data-images/
Beside the claims
Bennett's case rests on setting Orion's 2014 readings beside Apollo dosimetry; NASA's Artemis I report prints doses that vary with shielding and attitude, and does not mention Apollo. Kouts's case rests on heat-shield trouble; NASA's own Artemis I page records unexpected char loss and changes for later shields. Sibrel's case rests on capability; NASA's pages record an uncrewed lunar flight in 2022 and a crewed flyby whose images and audio were released in 2026. The NASA pages do not answer the claim that Apollo was staged, and the adherent pages do not take up the Artemis II data.