The claim
The Birds Aren't Real movement states its case plainly: "Birds no longer exist in the U.S. as a biological lifeform, thus, Birds Aren't Real!" Its website says the movement "has been active since 1976," and that it exists to spread awareness that the U.S. government wiped out more than 12 billion birds between 1959 and 2001 "and replaced these birds with surveillance drone replicas, which still watch us every day."
The story as the movement tells it
The movement's in-character history begins with the founding of the CIA in 1947. On "April 15th, 1956," it says, CIA director Allen Dulles met the president and proposed "cameras in the sky." The plan was "thought up one weekend in May of 1956." In this telling, B-52 bombers were refitted with "450-gallon water tanks," and the birds were cleared from the sky "between 1959 and 1971" (the movement's FAQ gives 1959 to 2001).
The founding
The real story, as 60 Minutes told it in 2022, is that "The idea was an accident." In 2017 Peter McIndoe, then a college student, found himself at a street march in Memphis and thought "it would be very interesting if someone was in this situation with a sign that had nothing to do with anything." He told The Guardian: "I should write a sign that has nothing to do with what is going on." He wrote "Birds Aren't Real."
Someone filmed him and posted the video on Facebook. "It went viral, and Memphis is still the centre," he said. "I remember seeing videos of people chanting: 'Birds aren't real,' at high-school football games."
The movement grows
Rallies followed, with chants of "If it flies, it spies!" and "Bird watching goes? Both ways!" Dazed, reporting on McIndoe's interview with The New York Times, described protests "outside Twitter's headquarters to demand removal of its bird logo," "country-wide billboards," and "over 600,000 followers on TikTok and 350,000 on Instagram." McIndoe told 60 Minutes that more than a million people have become followers.
Out of character
In 2021 McIndoe stepped out of character. "It's about holding up a mirror to America in the internet age," he said. "The idea is meant to be so preposterous, but we make sure nothing we're saying is too realistic." On 60 Minutes he described the movement as "building a little safe space to come together within it and laugh at it, rather than be scared by it." CBS concluded that the movement "is, thankfully, pure satire." On NPR's TED Radio Hour in 2023, McIndoe reflected on what the movement reveals about belief and belonging.
The believers' answer
In character, of course, the believers have an answer. McIndoe told 60 Minutes that "the mainstream media wants to sell us this lie that, 'Oh, birds are hungry,'" and the crowds reply that bird watching goes both ways. If a joke can gather this many followers, what about the theories that are not jokes?