The accepted account
Historians say Adolf Hitler killed himself in his Berlin bunker on April 30, 1945. Some people have never accepted it. In their view, he escaped to South America, as other senior Nazis did.
Why the idea took hold
Smithsonian Magazine explains the appeal. Theorists "wanted to argue that Hitler did not die in the bunker, but rather managed, somehow, to escape like other high-ranking Nazi officials, including Adolf Eichmann and Josef Mengele, who were able to slink off to South America." Eichmann and Mengele did reach South America. The question is whether their leader did too.
The memo
In 2017 a CIA memo from 1955 appeared among the newly released JFK assassination records. As CBS News reported, a CIA operative codenamed "CIMELODY-3" passed on a claim from a trusted contact that Hitler was alive among Nazi expatriates in Colombia. "It appears CIMELODY-3 never met the actual source," CBS wrote. That source was a former SS trooper "identified by the CIA as Phillip Citroen," who "allegedly told the CIA agent's source he met 'Hitler' in Tunja, Colombia, in 1954, a place he described as 'overly populated with former German Nazis.'"
The believers' reading
Sky HISTORY, in its series Hunting Hitler, presents the memo as a lead worth following. "The supervisor took the information seriously. So seriously, in fact, that he passed it on the CIA directly." The page describes "a grainy image of Citroen with Schuttlemayer who clearly resembles the former Nazi leader," and the claim that "Schuttlemayer had fled to Argentina." Former CIA officer Bob Baer "has been leading a team of investigators on a manhunt that asks the question, did Hitler survive the Second World War?"
The memo read in full
Snopes went through the memo in 2025. It notes that the documents "relied on thirdhand reporting," and that the photograph was shown to the informant "for purposes of getting his reaction to the possible veracity of this fantastic story." The memo itself says that neither the agent nor the CIA station could give "an intelligent evaluation" of the tip.
The skull
In 2009 the case took a turn. As The Guardian's Uki Goñi reported, tests on a bullet-pierced skull fragment held by the Russian State Archive, long said to be Hitler's, found that it "came from an unknown woman, not the German leader." Archaeologist Nick Bellantoni explained: "The bone seemed very thin; male bone tends to be more robust," and "the sutures where the skull plates come together seemed to correspond to someone under 40."
The teeth
In 2018 French scientists led by Philippe Charlier examined teeth held in Moscow. Smithsonian reported that they appear to match X rays from 1944 and descriptions from Hitler's dentist and dental assistant. Charlier told the news agency AFP: "The teeth are authentic, there is no possible doubt. Our study proves that Hitler died in 1945." He added, as NPR reported: "We can stop all the conspiracy theories about Hitler. He did not flee to Argentina in a submarine, he is not in a hidden base in Antarctica or on the dark side of the moon."
The believers' answer
Believers answer with the skull. If the fragment the Soviets kept as Hitler's came from a woman under 40, they ask, what else about the Soviet remains is not what it seems? If the teeth settle it, why did the skull not match?