The denial in the Morgantina silver is the sentence that called the purchase clean. On 21 February 2006 the Metropolitan Museum of Art signed an agreement in Rome transferring title to Italy of six antiquities, among them sixteen Hellenistic silver pieces of the third century B.C. The Museum’s statement says the agreement stipulates that the objects were acquired in good faith.
The denial in the Morgantina silver is the sentence that called the purchase clean. On 21 February 2006 the Metropolitan Museum of Art signed an agreement in Rome transferring title to Italy of six antiquities, among them sixteen Hellenistic silver pieces of the third century B.C. The Museum’s statement says the agreement stipulates that the objects were acquired in good faith. In the same statement the director, Philippe de Montebello, described the deal as redressing past improprieties in the acquisitions process. A good-faith purchase and an impropriety in how antiquities had been acquired are not the same account of the ground. The museum that now holds the silver says the pieces were dug by predators in the late 1970s and early 1980s and sold abroad illegally. This is a custody file, not a curse story.
PublishedSep 23, 2026
The Met’s accession numbers, printed in the 2006 statement, are 1981.11.15–22, 1982.11.7–13, and 1984.11.3. The agreement kept the silver on view in New York until 2010. De Montebello signed for the Museum. For Italy the release names Giuseppe Proietti and Francesco Sicilia for the Ministry of Culture, and Alessandro Pagano for Sicily. Other works in the same instrument, including the Euphronios krater, are not this hoard. The silver is the group whose title left the Met that February.
De Montebello’s statement paired the transfer with loans of works of equivalent importance, up to four years at a time, as Italian law allowed. The silver’s stay in New York until 2010 was part of that bargain, not a denial that title had moved. When the pieces reached Aidone they went into the old Capuchin convent, adapted as a museum in 1984. The museum guide still lists them in a sequence that runs from the Bronze Age settlement on the Cittadella to the Hellenistic city on Serra Orlando, and it credits the American mission of Princeton and Virginia, in the field from the 1950s, alongside the Sicilian superintendencies.
On 19 February 2010 the Museum described what the agreement had done with these objects: the sixteen pieces were to be exhibited on a rotating basis every four years, and the Italian loans then opening in New York coincided with the four-year return of the Hellenistic silver to Sicily. One of those incoming loans, the Moregine treasure from the outskirts of Pompeii, is a different service of silver, buried in 79 and excavated in 2000. It was coming to New York. The Morgantina pieces were the ones going back.
The Parco Archeologico di Morgantina and the Museo Archeologico di Aidone inaugurated them on 3 December 2010. The regional release calls that day the definitive return to Aidone, after restitution to Italy at the beginning of 2010 and a tour at Palazzo Massimo in Rome, the Museo Salinas in Palermo, and the Shanghai Expo. Sixteen pieces of gilded silver, called there the Tesoro di Eupolemos, were installed with finds from the house of Eupolemos recovered in 1990s excavations directed by Malcolm Bell. The Aidone museum dates the silver to the third century B.C., reads it as probably the city’s silver for official banquets in the prytaneion, and says the citizen Eupolemos hid it when the Romans attacked in 211 B.C. One piece, the parks release says, is inscribed “Sacri agli dei.” A Morgantina coin of about 212 B.C. and an Italian 100-lire coin of 1978 were shown as a dating pair for the ancient hiding and for the clandestine digging. The release names Bell as the archaeologist who recognised looted Sicilian works in American museums, and the magistrate Silvio Raffiotta as the person who opened the proceeding. It does not name a dealer and does not state a price.
The museum page lists the silver with other works dug by predators and sold abroad: acroliths of Demeter and Kore, a goddess statue, a terracotta head of Hades. An older Aidone guide puts the silver in sala 9 and sketches the city the hoard belongs to: a settlement on the Cittadella from the thirteenth century B.C., a Greek town, destruction in 211 B.C., and a Roman phase that fades by the early empire. Collections there come from the American mission of Princeton and Virginia, in the field from the 1950s, and from the Sicilian superintendencies. The ancient context the museum gives is a house and a banquet service hidden in 211 B.C. The modern context is the hole and the purchase the Met later put into a title transfer.
The four-year rotation did not stay the last word. On 27 September 2022 the archaeological park reported an agreement between the Museo Salinas in Palermo, directed by Caterina Greco, and the Metropolitan, directed by Max Hollein, which modifies the February 2006 term under which the silver moved from Aidone to New York every four years. The park’s headline is that the silver remains in Sicily. The same agreement sets a separate exchange of other objects, Cypriot and archaic pots toward Palermo and Selinunte material toward New York. Those pots are not the Morgantina silver. The silver, on that page, stays at Aidone.
Settled on these releases: sixteen Hellenistic silver pieces from Morgantina, title transferred in February 2006, returned to Sicily in 2010, installed at Aidone that December, and reported in 2022 as staying there rather than rotating back to New York. Settled as the dispute: the Museum’s good-faith clause, the same director’s reference to improprieties, and Aidone’s account of clandestine digging and illegal sale. Not on these pages: a dealer’s name, a price, or a curse.
Title transfer of sixteen Hellenistic silver pieces (3rd century B.C.; accession numbers as printed); good-faith stipulation; de Montebello on improprieties; silver remains until 2010. Signed de Montebello, Proietti, Francesco Sicilia, Pagano.
Sixteen Hellenistic silver pieces on a four-year rotation; loans coincide with the silver’s return to Sicily. Moregine is a different hoard coming to New York.
Definitive installation at the Museo Archeologico di Aidone; restituted to Italy at the beginning of 2010; tour Rome, Palermo, Shanghai; Tesoro di Eupolemos; clandestine digging dated in part by a 1978 coin; Bell; Raffiotta. No price.
Sala 9, gli Argenti di Morgantina; city history through the Roman phase; American mission of Princeton and Virginia from the 1950s; museum installed in the former Capuchin convent, adapted 1984.
Agreement between Caterina Greco (Museo Salinas) and Max Hollein (Met), sought by assessor Alberto Samonà, modifies the 2006 four-year transfer of the silver from Aidone to New York. Silver remains in Sicily. Other objects in the exchange are not this hoard.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some of these are sold by partners: we may earn a commission if you buy through their links, at no extra cost to you.