The Metropolitan Museum treated the Lydian tomb goods as a legitimate purchase. The ground, and then the case, said something else. Tumuli near Güre, in the Uşak region of western Turkey, had been dug illicitly in the 1960s, and the objects had left those tombs. In 1993 the museum agreed to send them back. Turkey’s Ministry of Culture records 363 pieces brought into the country in October 1993. This is a repatriation file.
The Metropolitan Museum treated the Lydian tomb goods as a legitimate purchase. The ground, and then the case, said something else. Tumuli near Güre, in the Uşak region of western Turkey, had been dug illicitly in the 1960s, and the objects had left those tombs. In 1993 the museum agreed to send them back. Turkey’s Ministry of Culture records 363 pieces brought into the country in October 1993. This is a repatriation file. It is not a curse story, and it is not a tale that needs a purchase price nobody’s ministry page has to invent.
PublishedSep 23, 2026
The English page of the ministry calls the group the Lydia (Karun) Treasures and places them at the Museum of Uşak. It says they are pieces smuggled to the Metropolitan Museum by people who dug the Toptepe tumulus near Güre in 1965, the İkiztepe tumulus in 1966, and the Aktepe I tumulus in 1968. It calls them among the best examples of sixth-century B.C. Lydian art, given back to Türkiye in 1993 after a long legal negotiation by the ministry. The Directorate General’s Turkish page on the same return says illicit digging around Uşak in 1960–1965 and in 1968 looted Lydian tumuli, damaged tomb chambers and finds, and put objects into traffickers’ hands. It says the ministry asked the Metropolitan in writing, received a refusal, and sued. After what that page calls a decision in Turkey’s favor, museum officials in early 1993 proposed to return the objects in the case. Negotiations ended with the 363-piece Lydian Treasure handed over when the suit was dropped, and brought to Turkey in October 1993. The same page also dates protection at the Uşak Museum to 28 June 1996. The return it narrates is October 1993. Those two dates should not be collapsed into one day.
The Uşak governor’s office tells the same acquisition as a purchase that the tombs do not support. Its page on the Karun treasures says Lydian and Greco-Persian tumuli of the sixth century B.C. stand near Güre, by the Hermos (Gediz). It dates the start of the robberies to the illicit dig at Toptepe in 1965, and describes a tomb chamber in which a silver jug and marble alabastra were broken by a fallen beam while most of the treasure still lay on the funerary couch with hair and powdered bone. The Uşak municipality page lists the same kind of tomb goods from Toptepe, a silver jug among them, and adds that wall paintings at Aktepe were cut out and sent toward Izmir. A second robbery, at İkiztepe in 1966, included blowing the chamber roof with gunpowder. The governor’s page says the pieces moved through Izmir merchant Ali Bayırlar and Istanbul dealers to John Klejman in New York. No price is stated on these pages, and none is stated here.
The purchase caption is in the same account. The governor’s page says a Metropolitan minute of 7 November 1968, under Greek and Roman Art, spoke of 96 pieces as East Greek, of the second half of the sixth century B.C., from the same region as the “East Greek Treasure” acquired in 1966 and 1967. That is the legitimate-purchase label. The illicit digs, the pieces seized by police, and the lawsuit said looted tombs. In 1984, while preparing a display, the museum issued a catalogue that Özgen Acar passed to the Ministry of Culture. The governor’s page says it included some of the Lydian objects taken from the Uşak tumuli. A letter of 10 June 1986 to the museum’s director, comparing those pieces with objects seized in the trafficking cases, was refused.
The court step that matters is not a final order to hand the gold over. In May 1987 Turkey sued the Metropolitan in federal court in New York, through Harry I. Rand and Lawrence M. Kaye. The governor’s page says the complaint put the objects in Turkey, taken by illicit excavation and first entered into the United States in 1966–1967. In July 1990 the court rejected the museum’s argument that Turkey had not looked hard enough and that the claim was time-barred. The University of Geneva’s Art-Law Centre case note records the same sequence: clandestine excavation of a sixth-century B.C. gold and silver collection from tumuli at Güre; purchase by the Metropolitan; a 1986 demand that was rejected; a 1987 lawsuit; denial of the motion to dismiss in 1990, cited as Republic of Turkey v. Metropolitan Museum of Art, 762 F. Supp. 44; and a 1993 settlement to return the collection. The note lists marble sphinxes, tomb paintings, jewellery, and gold and silver, and the nickname Croesus Gold. A nickname is not an identification of these tombs as Croesus’s, and it is not a curse.
The governor’s page says museum lawyers then asked to talk outside court. Offers to leave the objects in New York for money, or to return a few under shared title, were refused. In October 1993 the 363 objects were returned. The Geneva note calls that return unconditional and out of court. What the ministry’s pages show now is the Museum of Uşak, not a vitrine in New York and not a king’s curse.
Settled on the ministry, the governorate, and the Geneva case note: East Greek and Lydian tomb material from the Uşak tumuli was acquired by the Metropolitan Museum and returned to Turkey in 1993, counted as 363 pieces, after a lawsuit that survived a limitations challenge and ended in a settlement rather than a merits judgment ordering the return. Still not on these pages, and not invented here, is a purchase price. Whose tomb each vessel came from, object by object, stays an archaeological question inside the Uşak holding. It does not reopen a curse.
Illicit digs, written demand, refusal, suit; 363-piece return when the case was dropped; brought to Turkey in October 1993. Same page also dates Uşak Museum protection to 28 June 1996.
Tomb narrative, East Greek Treasure caption, Klejman, 10 June 1986 letter, July 1990 limitations rejection, refused shared-title offers, October 1993 return of 363 pieces.
Summary: sixth-century B.C. gold and silver, clandestine excavation in Turkey in the 1960s, purchased by the Met, 1986 demand, suit, 1993 out-of-court return.
Geneva case note (Chechi, Bandle, Renold, February 2012)
Chronology through the 1990 denial of the motion to dismiss, cited as 762 F. Supp. 44, and the 1993 settlement. Nickname Croesus Gold is recorded there as a nickname.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some of these are sold by partners: we may earn a commission if you buy through their links, at no extra cost to you.