Bourbon digging at Pompeii, begun in 1748 under Charles III, treated the buried city as a mine. Tunnels and open pits pulled frescoes, statues, and furniture toward the royal collections and often left the houses broken, backfilled, or stripped of the floors and walls that made a room readable. What those digs hid was not a curse. It was context: which painting had belonged to which wall, and which body-shaped hollow in the ash was cut through before anyone thought to fill it. Giuseppe Fiorelli’s method tried to get that context back. The archaeological park’s guide credits him with dividing the city into regiones and insulae in 1858. The National Archaeological Museum in Naples dates his direction of the excavations from 1861, and his curatorship of the museum from 1863 to 1875. From 1863, plaster poured into the voids turned empty cavities into casts of people and objects that a treasure tunnel could destroy without ever drawing. Bourbon engineers found the city. Extraction without a standing plan hid the city as a city. Fiorelli’s recorded clearing and casts gave back bodies and room-plans the hunt had no reason to keep.
Mines, Tunnels, and the Road to Naples
The park guide is blunt about the start: the city was noticed at the end of the sixteenth century, and explorations began in 1748 under the King of Naples. Roque Joaquín de Alcubierre, and after him Karl Weber and the La Vega brothers, ran a royal works whose success was measured in objects fit for a palace museum. Fine painting was cut from walls. Sculpture and metal left for Portici and, later, Naples. Explored rooms were often packed back in. Weber’s plans were better than a pure loot list — Fiorelli would later print those daybooks — but the habit was still removal. A visitor who wanted the house had to imagine it from crates.
The same Bourbon campaign, by tunnel, found the Villa of the Papyri at Herculaneum and the villas at Stabiae. UNESCO later inscribed Pompeii, Herculaneum, and Torre Annunziata together (List 829, 1997) and described the plaster experiment at Pompeii as an early archaeological trial: gypsum poured into voids so that bodies, animals, and other organic forms could be cast. The listing also says the casts hold skeletal remains and the trace of nineteenth- and twentieth-century practice. That is an official way of saying the method is itself an artifact.
UNESCO List 829: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/829/.
Park guide (PDF): https://pompeiisites.org/wp-content/uploads/A-Guide-to-the-Pompeii-Excavations-2.pdf.
Italian UNESCO desk, same property: https://unesco.cultura.gov.it/en/projects/pompeii-herculaneum-and-torre-annunziata/.
What Fiorelli Changed
Fiorelli did not discover Pompeii. He changed the question from “what can be carried out” to “what was this block.” The regiones and insulae are still how every address in the city is cited. He also compiled the Bourbon daybooks into the Pompeianarum antiquitatum historia, so the older hunt became a source instead of only a loss. The park’s cast page dates the perfected plaster method to 1863 and counts a little over a hundred human casts against more than a thousand sets of victims’ remains. Most of the dead left bones only, from the pumice phase of the eruption. Casts record people killed in the later hot surge, whose shapes survived in hardened ash after the flesh was gone. The first museum of those casts opened under Fiorelli in 1873–74. Many casts were bombed in 1943; Amedeo Maiuri’s team saved part of them. The Garden of the Fugitives still shows a group where they fell.
Pompeii Sites, the casts: https://pompeiisites.org/en/pompeii-map/analysis/the-casts/.
The cork model of the city in Naples, first shown in 1879, is the other Fiorelli instrument. He assigned it to Felice Padiglione. At 1:100 it maps the excavated town, with walls, paintings, and floors, and the museum now calls it a record of what the digs had exposed by then and of decoration since lost on the real walls. A model is not a trench section in the later scientific sense. It is evidence that the director wanted the city legible as a whole, not as a sequence of trophies.
MANN, scale model of Pompeii: https://www.museoarcheologiconapoli.it/en/portfolio-item/scale-model-of-pompeii/.
The site’s management plan files the same turn as heritage: Bourbon tunnels and remains beside Fiorelli’s and Maiuri’s diaries, the regio system, and the casts. “Stratigraphic” here means ordered clearing from the top, with a journal, against tunneling that hit pay dirt and moved on. It does not mean a modern single-context sheet. Claiming more than that inflates a real reform into a laboratory that 1863 did not have.
Management plan (PDF): https://pompeiisites.org/wp-content/uploads/Piano-di-Gestione-EN.pdf.
What Not to Lead With
Curse lore and outsider-builder stories attach easily to a city of casts. They are not why the voids were filled, and they are not what the Bourbon crates lack. The documentary problem is destruction and recovery of context. Painting cut out and shipped is a real loss of walls. A cast is a real recovery of a body the ash had saved and a pick could erase. UNESCO’s plaster paragraph and the park’s 1863 date are the doors for that recovery. Alien ledes and curse epidemiology are not excavation history.
What the Bourbon crews denied was context. Tunnels chased frescoes, statues, and metal, then backfilled, so a room could be emptied without a plan of the house it belonged to. Fiorelli’s answer was to stop treating the city as a mine. Regions and insulae made an address. Plaster poured into the voids left by bodies kept the dead where the ash had held them, instead of lifting only what would survive a cart to Naples. The fight is not whether Vesuvius buried Pompeii. It is whether the dig kept the city or only the trophies.
What the Dig History Settles
Settled, on the park’s and the museum’s pages: explorations from 1748 under Charles III; a long Bourbon priority on portable finds; Fiorelli’s regiones and insulae; plaster casts from 1863; a city model tied to his directorship; UNESCO inscription of the three Vesuvian sites, with the casts named as evidence of both the dead and the diggers. Still open, as any long excavation is: how much Bourbon backfill still covers, and how conservation treats original casts versus copies. Pompeii’s argument is treasure hunting versus a method that kept the plan and the dead in place. The city was never a curse story that happened to have a director.
