Two denials sit on this gold, and neither has been settled by a return. The first is the royal name. On 31 May 1873 Heinrich Schliemann dug a hoard out of the mound at Troy and decided that the gold and the vessels could only be the treasure of Priam, the king in Homer’s Iliad. The Staatliche Museen zu Berlin say he was convinced of that while he was still lifting the pieces, and that the find has been called the Treasure of Priam ever since. The name is his claim. The Pushkin Museum’s research project says the largest of the early hoards, found in 1873, was named by him the “Treasure of King Priam,” Treasure A, and it places the Troy II horizon, the Early Bronze Age layer of that gold, at about 2550 to 2250 BC. UNESCO’s listing of the archaeological site of Troy records Schliemann’s excavations from 1870 and attaches the Homeric siege, as literature, to the 13th or 12th century BC. A name taken from the Iliad does not follow from either date. The objects are not baptized here as Priam’s.
The second denial is custody. Schliemann gave his Trojan antiquities to the Royal Museums in Berlin in 1881, “for undivided keeping,” the Berlin museum’s phrase. They were shown until 1939. In 1941 the most valuable pieces, including the Troy gold, went into the vault of the Prussian State Bank and then into the flak bunker at the zoo. The Pushkin project says that in April 1945 Wilhelm Unverzagt, director of the Museum of Prehistory, handed the Trojan collection to a Soviet officer. Berlin says the Red Army then took those holdings to the Soviet Union as war booty. Outside Russia, Berlin says, the location of the gold was not known until 1994. The Pushkin project says the objects were a “special collection” from 1949, closed to publication and display, and that specialists from several countries were allowed to examine them in the winter of 1994–95 and confirmed the pieces as Schliemann’s. An exhibition, “Treasures of Troy from Heinrich Schliemann’s Excavations,” opened at the Pushkin on 15 April 1996.
What is in Moscow is a museum collection with a nickname, not a verified royal treasury. The Pushkin’s gallery says the group of 259 items, often called “Trojan Gold” or “Priam’s Treasure,” has been held there since 1945, from hoards Schliemann excavated between 1872 and 1890. Its research page counts 259 items from thirteen of the lettered hoards, and in another passage says 260 of the most valuable gold, electrum, silver, and stone objects went to the Pushkin while 414 bronzes and ceramics went to the State Hermitage. The counts are the pages’ counts. They are not collapsed here into one inventory. A catalog entry on that project, a gold flask, is recorded by inventory number, weight, and measurements. It is not captioned as Priam’s property. Berlin still holds the silver and ceramic parts of the find in the Museum für Vor- und Frühgeschichte. The split is physical as well as legal.
Germany treats the Moscow gold as German museum property that was illegally removed. The Stiftung Preußischer Kulturbesitz says cultural assets taken to the Soviet Union at the end of the war remain German property under the Hague Convention of 1907, which forbids treating cultural property as reparations, and under treaties of 1990 and 1992 in which the Soviet and then the Russian government undertook to return war-displaced cultural assets. The foundation says Russia is blocking implementation of both treaties. It says a Russian law of 1996 declared German public-collection assets transported to Russia after the war to be Russian property, described on the Russian side as compensatory restitution, and that Germany considers that legislation a violation of international law. Berlin’s museum dates a Duma decision of 1998 that declared the treasures Russian state property, which the museum calls contrary to international law, and says they are shown in the Pushkin’s permanent galleries. Those are two institutional dates for the Russian claim. They are not a treaty, signed since, that has returned this gold. The 1990 and 1992 undertakings are real on the German page, and that page says they have not been carried out. No instrument cited here completes a transfer back to Berlin.
The Pushkin gallery notes that gold beads were strung in Schliemann’s day and sealed with wax marked S. The necklace on view is his stringing, not a jewel taken from a king. Hammer-axes in the same hall are set beside stone axes of the third millennium BC. That is an archaeological reading, not an identification of Priam.
Schliemann’s own export is part of the file and is not a defense of either later capital. Berlin records that he smuggled the hoard to Greece to avoid the division the Ottoman permit required, that the Ottoman Empire sued him in Athens, and that a settlement left the find in his hands against a payment of 10,000 gold francs. A bad export in 1873 does not decide whether the 1945 removal was lawful. It does keep the story from starting as a clean gift. Documented/L1 is the trail: his label, the Berlin gift, the 1945 removal, the Pushkin custody, and a restitution argument that has not ended in return.
Staatliche Museen zu Berlin, 31 May 2023: https://www.smb.museum/nachrichten/detail/150-jahre-auffindung-des-schatzes-des-priamos-in-troja-durch-heinrich-schliemann/.
Stiftung Preußischer Kulturbesitz, on cultural assets in Russia: https://www.preussischer-kulturbesitz.de/en/priorities/provenance-research-and-issues-of-ownership/wartime-losses/cultural-assets-relocated-to-russia-as-a-result-of-the-war.html.
Pushkin Museum, Hall 3: https://www.pushkinmuseum.art/museum/buildings/main/floor1/3_troy/index.php?lang=en.
Pushkin conservation project, The Gold of Troy: https://conservation.pushkinmuseum.art/data/specprojects/the-gold-of-troy/index-eng.html.
Catalog entry, gold flask, inventory numbers: https://conservation.pushkinmuseum.art/data/specprojects/the-gold-of-troy/items/1/en/index.html.
UNESCO, Archaeological Site of Troy, List 849: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/849/.
What Documented Settles
Documented: Schliemann’s 1873 find and his name for it; a Berlin gift in 1881; removal from Berlin in 1945 and custody at the Pushkin, with bronzes and ceramics described as at the Hermitage and silver and ceramic pieces still described as in Berlin; a Russian legal claim that Germany rejects; and no completed return of the gold. Not documented: that the gold was Priam’s, or that a restitution treaty has been carried out.

