The denial is about a layer, not about whether a mound exists. Hisarlik is the place excavators have treated as Troy. What was refused is the further claim that one burnt level in that mound is the city in the Iliad. UNESCO's World Heritage page for the Archaeological Site of Troy puts the mound at Hisarlık, 4.8 kilometres from the southern entrance to the straits, and says Schliemann undertook the first excavations in 1870. It says the visible remains date for the most part from Troy II and Troy VI, including defensive walls, gates, a paved ramp, and bastions, with a stretch of the earliest wall, Troy I, near the south gate. It also says that in the last fifteen years a lower city south of the mound has become clear, present in all prehistoric periods and about 30 hectares in the Late Bronze Age. On the same page the siege of Troy by Mycenaean warriors in the 13th century B.C., immortalized by Homer in the Iliad, is stated as the story the site carries. A second sentence on that page dates the siege by Spartan and Achaean warriors to the 13th or 12th century B.C. The inscription tells both a layer list and a poem. It does not say which of Troy II or VI, or any later phase, is the poem's city.
The nomination file is a different sentence. The World Heritage documentation dates the inscription 5 / 12 / 1998, at the committee's 22nd session, on criteria (ii), (iii), and (vi). The decision text calls the site of immense significance for early European civilization and of exceptional cultural importance because of the influence of Homer's Iliad on the creative arts over more than two millennia. The file's brief description says the first excavations were started in 1871 by Schliemann, not 1870, and it dates the siege to the 13th or 12th century B.C. Two official texts, one year apart on the start of the dig, agree that Homer is why the place was inscribed. Agreement on a poem is not a stratum. Schliemann's name on the dig is a historical fact in both texts. His choice of layer is not confirmed by either of them.
Cincinnati's archive states the identification as a working name. The department's finding aid and its archives page say Carl W. Blegen led the excavation of the site identified as Troy (Hisarlık) from 1932 to 1938, under the university. William T. Semple obtained the concession in 1931 from the Turkish Ministry of Culture. Wilhelm Dörpfeld, who had excavated there after Schliemann, was among the team. The archives page is the department saying the mound was dug as Troy. It is not a finding that a particular burn layer is the Iliad.
The finding aid's inventory shows where the later work actually spent its labels. Under the excavation records, contexts are filed as Troy VIIa: houses, Main Street, a south gate, and a line that reads Houses in Squares J-K6, Earthquake Area, VIIa. That is a folder label for a stratum. It is not a published claim that an earthquake was the war. In the studies series, one folder is an original typed manuscript titled Troy of the Homeric Poems. A title in a box is the project talking about Homer. It is not a verdict that the poem has been matched to VIIa.
The department's own history of the dig is where the layer claim is stated as a suggestion. In the parts of the mound left undisturbed by Schliemann and Dörpfeld, the Cincinnati team differentiated some 46 strata and divided them into nine major layers. Troy I through V corresponded, on that reading, to the Early Helladic in Greece. Troy VI corresponded to the Middle Helladic and the earlier Late Helladic. Troy VIIa and VIIb corresponded to the very end of Mycenaean times. Blegen suggested that the events resulting in the destruction of Troy VIIa were remembered in historical times as the Trojan War of epic poetry. Suggested is the verb on the page. Troy II, inside the Early Helladic group on this account, is centuries away from that suggestion. The page does not say the suggestion has been proved, and it does not say later scholars are bound by it.
The joint project that followed did not close the question on its public repository page. Tübingen's library record of the Troia Projekt says excavation and other fieldwork ran at Troy from 1987 to 2012, an international team, Tübingen for prehistory and Cincinnati for classical archaeology, with a growing set of online publications beside the printed ones. The page does not name a Homeric stratum. It does not award the war to VIIa, and it does not give it back to Troy II. Fieldwork after Blegen is on that page. A winner is not.
Hisarlik is the place the excavators have called Troy, from Schliemann's campaigns through Dörpfeld, Blegen, and the Tübingen-Cincinnati years. The fight that remains is which layer, if any, is Homer's city. UNESCO states a 13th-century, or 13th- or 12th-century, siege and also says the standing remains are mostly Troy II and VI. Cincinnati's history puts I-V, the group that includes Troy II, in the Early Helladic, and records only a suggestion that VIIa's destruction was what later poetry remembered. The 1987-2012 project page does not pick. Schliemann's identification is a claim. It is not a baptism, and neither is Blegen's suggestion.
UNESCO, Archaeological Site of Troy: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/849.
UNESCO nomination file: https://whc.unesco.org/uploads/nominations/849.pdf.
University of Cincinnati Classics archives, Troy excavation: https://classics.uc.edu/humanities/classics/archives?id=17&view=category.
Troy (Blegen) excavation records finding aid: https://classics.uc.edu/images/archives/troyfinding-aidweb.pdf.
University of Cincinnati, archaeology in the department: https://classics.uc.edu/humanities/classics/about/archinclassics.
Tübingen, Troia Projekt publications: https://tobias-lib.uni-tuebingen.de/xmlui/handle/10900/73269.
What Stays Contested
On these pages: Hisarlik inscribed as Troy; Schliemann's start given as 1870 on the list page and 1871 in the nomination file; visible remains dated mostly to Troy II and VI, with a Late Bronze Age lower town of about 30 hectares; Blegen's 1932-1938 excavation of the site identified as Troy; an archive label for a VIIa earthquake area and a manuscript title on the Homeric poems; a departmental account that puts Troy I-V in the Early Helladic and only suggests that VIIa's destruction was remembered as the war; a 1987-2012 Tübingen and Cincinnati project that does not name the layer. Left contested: which stratum, if any, is the city in the Iliad. No layer is baptized here.