Kathleen Kenyon’s excavations at Tell es-Sultan denied the reading John Garstang had offered the public: that the fallen walls of Jericho were the walls of Joshua’s attack. Digging from 1952 to 1958, she dated the last fortified Bronze Age city to the end of the Middle Bronze Age, around 1550 BCE, and treated what came after as too thin to be that city still standing in the Late Bronze Age. Bryant Wood’s answer, laid out in Biblical Archaeology Review in 1990 and pressed again in his reply to Piotr Bienkowski, is that Kenyon misread her own pottery, scarabs, and a radiocarbon sample, and that the destruction sits near 1400 BCE, where he sets Joshua 3–6. Radiocarbon is the third voice, not a gavel. Hendrik Bruins and Johannes van der Plicht, in Radiocarbon in 1995, published short-lived grain and charcoal from the end of that Middle Bronze destruction and a calibration they placed in the late seventeenth or sixteenth century BCE, against a 1400 date. The trench, the rebuttal, and the calibration fight are all on paper. A Joshua conquest is not a laboratory result, and not a target to sneer off the page.
The Mound Kenyon Actually Dug
Tell es-Sultan, northwest of modern Jericho in the Jordan Valley, is a mound beside the spring ‘Ain es-Sultan. UNESCO inscribed Ancient Jericho/Tell es-Sultan in 2023 (List 1687) for two long stories: Neolithic settlement, including a wall, ditch, and tower of the ninth to eighth millennium BCE, and Bronze Age urbanism, including Middle Bronze ramparts. The committee decision 45 COM 8B.36 adopts that statement of value. Neither text mentions Joshua. The famous stone tower is a Neolithic monument. It is not the Bronze Age rampart, and it is not a stand-in for a biblical siege.
UNESCO List 1687: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/1687/.
UNESCO Decision 45 COM 8B.36: https://whc.unesco.org/en/decisions/8417/.
The Council for British Research in the Levant’s project note records Kenyon’s 1952–58 seasons, with the British School of Archaeology in Jerusalem, the Palestine Exploration Fund, and other partners. Those seasons fixed the Pre-Pottery Neolithic sequence into A and B and carried the stratigraphy forward through the Bronze Age. Kenyon’s published view of the end of City IV was a destruction at the close of the Middle Bronze Age, then a gap before any modest later use. That is the denial: not “there are no walls,” but “these walls are not a Late Bronze fortress falling to Israel.” Garstang’s earlier expedition had linked collapse and fire to the biblical account. Kenyon’s smaller, deeper trenches were designed to test that link, and she rejected it.
CBRL, Excavations at Jericho: https://www.cbrl.ac.uk/project-library/excavations-at-jericho/.
Wood’s Counter, Left Intact
Wood did not answer with a slogan. In the March/April 1990 BAR article, and in the reply BAR published when Bienkowski defended Kenyon’s date, he argued from local pottery rather than from the absence of imported Cypriot wares, from scarabs including a Hatshepsut piece he treats as a fifteenth-century marker, and from the stratigraphic place of the destruction debris. He says Bienkowski misunderstood him if the claim was only Judges; the correlation he drew was with Joshua 3–6. He dates the fall near 1400 BCE and says that, once Kenyon’s 1550 date moves, a connection to that narrative becomes feasible. Bienkowski’s critique and Wood’s answer are the debate, not a nuisance in front of the debate. A documentary page can report that Wood thinks the archaeology and the biblical text can be set side by side without announcing that the identification is finished science.
Wood, reply to Bienkowski (BAR 1990; ABR posting): https://biblearchaeology.org/research-articles/dating-jerichos-destruction-bienkowski-is-wrong-on-all-counts/.
What the Radiocarbon Papers Did
Bruins and van der Plicht went back to samples tied to the final Middle Bronze destruction: short-lived cereal and multiyear charcoal. Short-lived grain is the point of the method. Charcoal can be older than the fire that buried it. Their 1995 paper in Radiocarbon is the calibration fight in journal form. The dates they published, once calibrated, fell in the late seventeenth or sixteenth century BCE. They presented that range as incompatible with Wood’s date around 1400. Wood’s side has answered that sample choice, old wood, and the calibration curve can all move a century, and that pottery still carries the argument. Later curves have shifted numbers across the Levant without erasing the disagreement. A radiocarbon mean is not a verse, and a verse is not a lab number. Reporting both is the job. Collapsing them into “science has disproved Joshua” or “the Bible has dated the ash” is the move this file refuses.
Bruins and van der Plicht, Radiocarbon (PDF): https://www.cambridge.org/core/services/aop-cambridge-core/content/view/49BF732173E7890A2B0EC1B21CB6A817/S0033822200030666a.pdf.
The Mound Since Kenyon
An Italian–Palestinian expedition from Sapienza University of Rome and the Palestinian Ministry of Tourism and Antiquities has worked at the tell since 1997, with Italian foreign-ministry support, and its own pages note the 2023 World Heritage inscription. That project reopens stratigraphy Kenyon published. It does not hand the conquest question to a press release. The spring, the Neolithic tower, the Bronze Age rampart, and the arguments about the destruction layer are all on the same mound. They are not the same event.
Sapienza expedition to Tell es-Sultan: https://sites.google.com/uniroma1.it/sapienzatojericho/home-page.
What Documented Means Here
Documented, at L1: the tell and its UNESCO inscription; Kenyon’s 1952–58 stratigraphic campaign and her rejection of a Joshua-era fortified city; Wood’s published counter-date near 1400 BCE and his explicit correlation with Joshua 3–6; Bruins and van der Plicht’s 1995 radiocarbon challenge to that date; ongoing excavation by Sapienza and the Palestinian ministry. Not documented as settled science: the identification of any destruction with the book of Joshua. Not erased: the biblical chronology as a real position in the literature. Jericho’s walls are a dig and a dating argument. The Neolithic tower is not the Middle Bronze rampart. The rampart’s date is still fought. The conquest is not a result this archive will stamp.