Believers in Tartaria hold that a single advanced civilization once spanned the globe, built the domed and columned halls now credited to nineteenth-century architects, and was erased by a worldwide mud flood whose traces survive as buried ground floors and half-sunk windows. Historians, map librarians and building historians answer that "Tartary" was a European name for a vast region of inner Asia, not one hidden empire, and that the buried storeys and vanished palaces have documented causes. The fight is whether old maps and old buildings record a lost empire or simply a lost vocabulary and a forgotten construction history.
The theory itself is young, and researchers have started to describe it. Andrew Ward's 2023 MA dissertation at the University of Wales Trinity Saint David (https://repository.uwtsd.ac.uk/id/eprint/2983/1/Ward%2C%20Andrew%20%282023%29%20MA%20The%20World%20That%20Was%20Thesis.pdf) summarizes what adherents say in their own terms: Tartaria was a globe-spanning civilization unified by a single language, culture and architecture, credited with Classical, Beaux-Arts and Second Empire buildings and with advanced technology, sometimes peopled by ten-foot giants, and ended by a mud flood roughly a century ago before its traces were scrubbed from the history books. Ward dates the theory's emergence to about 2016 or 2017 and traces two strands, one rooted in Russian historical revisionism and one in English-language online communities focused on architecture, free energy and the mud flood. Both strands, he notes, draw on misunderstandings of old cartography.
The maps are real, and they are where many people first meet the idea. The David Rumsey Map Collection holds Herman Moll's Great Tartary (https://www.davidrumsey.com/maps4540.html), a hand-coloured map dated 1732 and published in the 1736 third edition of his Atlas Minor in London. Its full title adds "With the tract of the Moscovite Ambassador's travels from Moscow to Pekin in China," and the catalogue places it over present-day Russia and Kazakhstan. To an adherent, a map labelling so much land "Great Tartary" proves an empire that later histories omit. To a map librarian, the same sheet shows a European geographer's name for lands he knew mostly through travellers, crossed by the route of a Russian embassy to the Chinese court.
The name lasted, and it kept splitting. The same collection holds Independent Tartary (https://www.davidrumsey.com/static/maps2588.html), drawn and engraved by John Rapkin for R. M. Martin's atlas published by J. & F. Tallis in 1851, with regions shown in outline colour and vignettes of Tartars on a journey, their tent, and a bride chase following local custom. A map of "Independent" Tartary implies other Tartaries, such as the Great Tartary of Moll's sheet a century earlier. That division is the opposite of one world empire: it is a catch-all exonym that cartographers kept subdividing as their information improved. Adherents read the shrinking label as an empire being dismantled on paper; the maps themselves show a name being narrowed to the parts of Asia that Europeans still knew only vaguely.
The architecture strand points to the great exposition halls, which seem too grand to have been built quickly and then destroyed. The University of Chicago Library's guide to its World's Columbian Exposition collection (https://www.lib.uchicago.edu/e/scrc/findingaids/view.php?eadid=ICU.SPCL.EXPO1893) answers directly. The 1893 buildings were designed in classical styles that suggested stone, but none was made to endure; their facades were "staff," a hardened mixture of plaster, cement and hemp. Most were torn down and their steel sold for scrap, and buildings whose materials would not be resold burned in planned and accidental fires in early 1894. The only building still on the fairgrounds is the Palace of Fine Arts, and three others, the Maine Building, the Dutch House and the Norway Building, survive elsewhere after being moved.
That one survivor shows why it lasted. The Chicago Architecture Center's entry on the Museum of Science and Industry (https://www.architecture.org/learn/resources/buildings-of-chicago/building/museum-of-science-and-industry) explains that the Palace of Fine Arts also wore staff outside, but lenders of priceless art insisted on a fireproof building, so it received a steel and brick structure. In the late 1920s, funded by Julius Rosenwald, the staff was removed and the exterior recreated in 28,000 tons of Indiana limestone, and the museum opened in 1933. A building that looks ancient and permanent turns out to be a temporary shell replaced in stone a generation later, and even the argument over materials is recorded: terra cotta was projected to save $300,000, and limestone won.
The mud-flood strand rests on buildings whose ground floors sit below the street. Seattle's are among the best known. HistoryLink's history of Pioneer Square (https://www.historylink.org/File/23494) records that after the Great Fire of 1889 the city required stone and brick, drawing sandstone from Wilkeson, Tenino and Bellingham and granite from Index, widened streets by up to 24 feet, and raised most streets by between 6.5 and 32 feet. Private owners built faster than the city could regrade, so many new buildings went up at the old, lower grade, and when the roads were finished their original ground floors became subterranean. Those spaces were sealed, forgotten, rediscovered in the 1960s, and became the city's underground tours.
The documented record behind Tartaria is a word, a set of buildings and a set of streets. "Tartary" was a European label for inner Asia, divided and redrawn on maps from the 1700s into the 1800s. The white palaces of 1893 were plaster shells built to be demolished, and the buried storeys of Seattle were made by raising streets after a fire. Each strand has an archive.
What Stays Contested
Adherents argue that archives can be forged and that the scale of nineteenth-century building is itself suspicious. Historians reply that the scale is documented in photographs, library collections and the surviving structures. What remains open is a question about belief: why a theory born around 2016 spread so quickly, which researchers such as Ward are only beginning to study. No source here shows a single empire called Tartaria or a global mud flood.