Heribert Illig says 297 early medieval years were invented; eclipse records, tree rings and calendar history answer him. His thesis reaches the record through an essay by his collaborator Hans-Ulrich Niemitz and through long quotation in his critics' work. Two astronomical studies, a historian's paper on the calendar, a medievalist's lecture, and the Aachen cathedral works office set out the answer.
The claim, in an adherent's essay
Niemitz's essay "Did the Early Middle Ages Really Exist?" (versions of 1995 and 1997, revised in 2000) says he has worked on the question since 1990 with a group of friends that includes Illig. Its thesis is that historians count about 300 years too many between Antiquity and the Renaissance, and that a phantom period was inserted between 600 and 900 AD, by accident, by misreading of documents, or by deliberate falsification, citing Illig (1991). Buildings and objects given to that period, it says, belong to other periods; its first example is the chapel at Aachen, which it says should be regarded as a building of the second part of the eleventh century, because its arch construction has no predecessor and its "best copy" is a church consecrated in 1049. On the calendar it argues that Pope Gregory's ten-day correction of 1582 points to 325, not to Caesar. It says radiocarbon dating depends on tree-ring dating, and that tree-ring dating of the period rests on few samples and is open to error. As a motive it offers the hypothesis that Otto III and Gerbert of Aurillac, later Pope Sylvester II, fixed their own time as the year 1000, so chroniclers had to invent 300 years of history.
Niemitz, Did the Early Middle Ages Really Exist?: https://www.cl.cam.ac.uk/~mgk25/volatile/Niemitz-1997.pdf
Eclipses, 1999
Dieter B. Herrmann of Berlin-Treptow, in a paper printed in Beiträge zur Astronomiegeschichte, volume 2 (Acta Historica Astronomiae 5, 1999, pages 7 to 10), takes up Illig's thesis that the chronology holds an error of about 300 years. His abstract says that calculation of historical eclipses shows the thesis to be obviously wrong, although further investigations are needed.
Herrmann, Gab es eine Phantomzeit in unserer Chronologie?: https://astro.uni-bonn.de/~pbrosche/aa/acta/vol05/herrmann.html
Astronomy at book length, 2003
Franz Krojer's Die Präzision der Präzession (Munich, 2003), subtitled Illigs mittelalterliche Phantomzeit aus astronomischer Sicht, opens with an open letter to Illig. Krojer writes that he has studied the claim since 1999: that 614 to 911 are fictitious, so that nearly 300 years of Byzantine, Islamic-Arab and other European history, Charlemagne included, were invented in the High Middle Ages. His test is to take a well-dated ancient astronomical record and compare its distance from today with astronomical back-calculation; if 300 years had been inserted, the two should not agree. He warns that records could themselves be later forgeries, so their authenticity must be checked first, and that the number of reliable records then shrinks considerably. The rest, he writes, including Arab-Islamic eclipse reports from the supposedly fictitious ninth century, speak against the phantom time. He writes that Illig sets Chinese records aside by calling them poorly kept, and that Illig does not present and weigh them one by one. Krojer calls the European and Chinese agreement on Halley's comet in 837 impressive at first, and mixed on closer look.
Krojer, Die Präzision der Präzession: https://www.differenz-verlag.de/PDF-kostenlos/Krojer-Franz%20--%20Die%20Praezision%20der%20Praezession.pdf
The calendar question, 2004
Jörg Dendl's paper in the Zeitschrift für Anomalistik, volume 4 (2004), quotes Illig's 1997 book at length. In that passage Illig writes that the Julian calendar's drift had reached 12.7 days by 1582, which would have called for a 13-day correction, and asks why only 10 days were skipped; he says the surviving acts of the council of Nicaea in 325 show no calendar adjustment and that later computists invented one. Dendl, citing Illig, calls the calendar argument the basis of the whole thesis. His answer is that the Gregorian reform aimed to restore the conditions at the time of Nicaea, not of Caesar, so ten days were enough and fictitious centuries need not be assumed. Citing Ginzel's handbook, he gives the true spring equinox of 325 as 20 March, within hours of the 21 March date. He grants Illig one point: whether Nicaea itself fixed the Easter reckoning.
Dendl, Karl den Großen gab es doch!: https://www.anomalistik.de/images/pdf/zfa/zfa2004_123_193_dendl.pdf
The book and the medievalists, 2004
Christian Rohr's lecture of 22 November 2004, in a series on crime in the Middle Ages, says Illig's 1996 book Das erfundene Mittelalter, published by Econ after a self-published 1994 version, called September 614 to August 911 an invented time. Rohr writes that Illig extended the gap to Islamic lands, India and China, treating the Tang dynasty (618 to 907) as a later forgery, and that he left open how Islam came to rule from Central Asia to Spain by 911. He summarizes Rudolf Schieffer's review: counting years from Christ's birth and the Easter rule arose only in late antiquity, and with that the calendar gap closes. He traces Illig's start to a 1986 Monumenta Germaniae Historica congress on medieval forgeries.
Rohr, Ein gefälschtes Mittelalter?: https://www.plus.ac.at/wp-content/uploads/2021/02/543247.pdf
Tree rings in the Aachen chapel
The Aachen cathedral works office reported in 2009 that an oak timber from the pile foundation of the northeast octagon pillar was dated to 798, plus or minus five years, and an oak from the wooden ring anchor of the octagon dome to 803, plus or minus ten. The dating was done by the dendroarchaeology laboratory of the University of Cologne. The ring-anchor timber, taken in 2003, held 95 rings, the youngest dated to 753; the pile timber held 57, the youngest dated to 781. The office's timeline places the setting of the octagon's columns in 798.
Aachen cathedral works office, Sanierungsarbeiten: https://dombauhuette-aachen.de/sanierungsarbeiten-4/
Where the dispute stands
Illig and Niemitz cite the Gregorian ten days, the style of the Aachen chapel, and doubts about tree-ring and radiocarbon dating. Herrmann and Krojer answer with eclipse and comet records, Dendl and Schieffer with the council of Nicaea, and the Aachen office with timbers dated to 798 and 803. Krojer also finds the comet evidence for 837 mixed.