Adherents of the Mars session argue that a government psychic programme looked into the Martian past and saw a civilisation. On 22 May 1984, they say, a remote viewer working under the programme later known as STAR GATE was handed a sealed target and Martian coordinates, and he described pyramids, huge structures, tall thin people, and a dying world swept by storms, about a million years ago. The coordinates point to Cydonia, home of the "Face on Mars," so the session is presented as independent confirmation of ruins there. The transcript is public, and so is the programme's review. The dispute is over what a session transcript can show about another planet.
The document itself is available through the Internet Archive's copy of the CIA record CIA-RDP96-00788R001900760001-9, titled "MARS, 1 MILLION BC (TRAINING)" (https://archive.org/details/CIA-RDP96-00788R001900760001-9), stamped "Approved For Release 2000/08/08." The method was a "sealed envelope coupled with geographic coordinates," with a 3 x 5 card reading "The planet Mars. Time of interest approximately 1 million years B.C." The monitor read out "40.89 degrees north, 9.55 degrees west." The subject, called only SUB, reported "an oblique view of a ah.. pyramid or pyramid form," "severe, severe clouds, more like dust storm," "very large people. They appear thin and tall," and "shelters from storms." Adherents identify him as Joseph McMoneagle; the transcript does not name him. Monitor notes record that he was "losing his ability to move accurately" and was allowed to follow what interested him.
The programme was reviewed at the government's request. The American Institutes for Research delivered "An Evaluation of Remote Viewing: Research and Applications" by Michael Mumford, Andrew Rose and David Goslin on 29 September 1995 (https://www.alice.id.tue.nl/references/mumford-rose-goslin-1995.pdf). Its panel paired Jessica Utts, whose work viewed paranormal interpretations positively, with Ray Hyman, chosen to represent a more skeptical position. The reviewers agreed that "a statistically significant laboratory effort has been demonstrated in the sense that hits occur more often than chance," but that it was unclear the effects could be attributed to paranormal ability rather than the judges, targets or methods. On operations, the report concluded that "the utility of RV for operational intelligence collection cannot be substantiated." The Mars session is filed as training, and the transcript records no scored answer against which its descriptions could be checked.
The place named by the coordinates has been mapped by the U.S. Geological Survey. George McGill's "Geologic Map of Cydonia Mensae-Southern Acidalia Planitia, Mars," published in 2005 as I-2811 (https://pubs.usgs.gov/imap/i2811/), describes Cydonia Mensae as lying on the boundary between the highlands of western Arabia Terra and the northern lowlands, where that boundary "is gradational rather than abrupt." The region is "characterized by abundant knobs and mesas, most of which occur in well defined clusters that commonly are long and narrow." The map addresses the crustal history behind the knobs, possible shorelines, and small cones that may record water or ice. The session's first coordinates fall in this landscape of mesas.
The best-known mesa was photographed at close range. Malin Space Science Systems released Mars Global Surveyor image E03-00824 on 24 May 2001 as "Highest-Resolution View of 'Face on Mars'" (https://www.msss.com/mars_images/moc/extended_may2001/face/index.html). The spacecraft was rolled 24.8 degrees on 8 April 2001 to view the feature from about 450 kilometres, at about 2 metres per pixel, so that "objects the size of typical passenger jet airplanes would be distinguishable." The release describes the Face as "one of thousands of buttes, mesas, ridges, and knobs" in the transition zone. A stereo view from June 2000 showed its relief. The release describes a landform among thousands of others, and reports no walls or smooth megalithic surfaces of the kind the session described.
The session's date has its own record in the ice. NASA's Jet Propulsion Laboratory reported in September 2009 that radar on Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter had mapped buried layers in the north polar cap (https://www.jpl.nasa.gov/news/radar-map-of-buried-mars-layers-matches-climate-cycles/). The layers, up to 2 kilometres thick, are "consistent with theoretical models of Martian climate swings during the past few million years," driven by changes in the planet's tilt. "The most recent 300,000 years of Martian history are a period of less dramatic swings in the planet's tilt than during the preceding 600,000 years." On this record, Mars a million years ago was in a period of tilt-driven climate swings that laid down layered polar ice.
The session's storms and dying environment touch on a real loss, on a much longer timescale. NASA reported in November 2015 that its MAVEN mission had measured the solar wind stripping gas from Mars's upper atmosphere at "about 100 grams (equivalent to roughly 1/4 pound) every second" (https://www.nasa.gov/news-release/nasa-mission-reveals-speed-of-solar-wind-stripping-martian-atmosphere/). The erosion increased during solar storms in March 2015, and principal investigator Bruce Jakosky said the loss rate was likely "much higher billions of years ago when the sun was young and more active." That loss helped change Mars from "early, warm and wet" to "cold, arid." The timescale is billions of years, not one million.
On the documents, the 1984 session is a genuine training transcript describing pyramids, tall people and storms at a Martian target set a million years in the past. The programme's 1995 review found laboratory hits above chance but could not tie them to psychic ability, and said their operational utility could not be substantiated. Mapping, imaging and climate records show mesas at Cydonia and, at that date, a Mars of tilt-driven climate swings laying down polar ice.
What Stays Contested
Remote viewing's laboratory results are still argued over, as the split between Utts and Hyman shows. The Mars session cannot add to that argument, because it had no scoreable target. Its images are evocative and its coordinates are real. The orbital record at those coordinates shows a region of knobs and mesas, and no source records construction there.