The episode
The City of New York vs. Homer Simpson was the first episode of the ninth season of The Simpsons, first aired in September 1997. Writing for Far Out in February 2024, Scott Campbell noted that it was celebrated by critics and audiences at the time, and that its song "You're Checkin' In" won a Primetime Emmy. Huge swathes of the episode are set in and around the World Trade Center. Almost four years to the day after its premiere, it was removed from reruns and syndication, and it did not return until 2006, with several pointed references to the towers cut, among them a line that "they stick all the jerks in Tower 1." The frame at the center of the claim shows a brochure advertising a $9 bus fare against the Twin Towers, "combining to form an image that looks something like a 9/11."
Source: Scott Campbell, Far Out, 10 February 2024: https://faroutmagazine.co.uk/the-simpsons-episode-that-was-banned-after-9-11/
The adherents' reading
For adherents, the frame is a marker hidden in plain sight. Reviewing the claim in September 2025, the fact checker Black Dot Research summed up their view: screenshots of the moment began circulating after the attacks, and "for conspiracy theorists, this image was too precise to be mere coincidence." It became part of "a larger theory of predictive programming," which Black Dot describes as "the belief that governments and corporations seed hidden warnings about future events in popular culture." Black Dot's own analysis found that the still is a genuine frame from the 1997 episode, not a doctored image.
Source: Joel Skadiang, Black Dot Research, 17 September 2025: https://blackdotresearch.sg/did-the-simpsons-predict-the-9-11-attacks-on-the-world-trade-center/
The reading spread online over many years. Snopes found through reverse image searches that the claim had been circulating since at least 2008, usually as a screenshot described as a magazine cover with the numbers 9 and 11 beside the Twin Towers.
Source: Aleksandra Wrona, Snopes, 11 September 2023: https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/simpsons-predicted-wtc/
The mainstream reading
Snopes rated the claim false. It found that the episode makes "no explicit reference to the events of Sept. 11" and that the scene "lacked any narrative elements that could be seen as a prediction," and it described the reading as an example of confirmation bias, in which viewers "retroactively assign significance to random details."
The people who made the episode give the same account. In January 2023, Vulture reported that Josh Weinstein, a co-showrunner on the episode, answered fans on Twitter: "I can tell you the unfortunate 9/11 one was strictly because 9 dollars seemed like the funniest low bus fare and we wanted the World Trade Center buildings in the ad because that's where the story took place. Totally, totally a coincidence." Vulture added that the other co-showrunner, Bill Oakley, had told the New York Observer in 2010 that the fare was picked because it was "comically cheap," and that the skyline was included to represent New York: "I signed off on the design. It's pretty self-explanatory."
Source: Jennifer Zhan, Vulture, 6 January 2023: https://www.vulture.com/2023/01/former-simpsons-showrunner-denies-9-11-prediction.html
Al Jean, one of the show's original writers and its longtime showrunner, told NME in November 2021: "The 9/11 one is so bizarre. In the World Trade Center episode, there was a brochure reading $9 a day with an 11 styled up like the towers. That was in '96, which was crazy, like this insane coincidence. But mostly it's just educated guesses." He passed on a line from a fellow writer: "If you write 700 episodes, and you don't predict anything, then you're pretty bad. If you throw enough darts, you're going to get some bullseyes."
Source: James McMahon, NME, 16 November 2021: https://www.nme.com/news/tv/the-simpsons-al-jean-predictions-911-3096871
The researchers' view
Researchers see the same pattern from the outside. Reporting for The New York Times in February 2018, Maya Salam quoted Jean calling the frame "a completely bizarre, strange thing," and pointed to "the law of truly large numbers," set out by the Harvard mathematicians Frederick Mosteller and Persi Diaconis in their 1989 paper Methods for Studying Coincidences: "With a large enough sample, any outrageous thing is apt to happen." The Simpsons, she noted, is the longest running scripted series in television history.
Source: Maya Salam, The New York Times (as republished by WRAL), 4 February 2018: https://www.wral.com/archive/17313531/
The adherents' answer
Adherents reply that darts and large numbers explain a lucky guess about a sports result, not this. In their reading, the alignment did not land on a random episode. It landed on the one episode built around the World Trade Center. Even Oakley, as quoted by The New York Times, granted that "it's eerie, given that it's on the only episode of any series ever that had an entire act of World Trade Center jokes." For adherents, an episode so bound up with the towers that it had to be pulled from the air after the attacks is exactly where a marker would be placed.




