For 40 years the Public Health Service told Black men it treated their "bad blood" while it withheld syphilis treatment. The record runs from a federal health agency's timeline and the Associated Press story of July 1972 through the advisory panel's 1973 report, the survivors' lawsuit, the 1979 Belmont Report, and a presidential apology in 1997. Each step names what was kept from the men and the words used to cover it. The reasons the records give are to learn from autopsies what the disease does and to use an untreated population as an "unusual opportunity"; the Belmont Report adds that treatment was withheld so as not to interrupt the project.
What the agency's timeline records
The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention timeline says the Public Health Service, working with the Tuskegee Institute, began the study in 1932 to record the natural history of syphilis, under the name "Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male." It involved 600 Black men, 399 with syphilis and 201 without. Their informed consent was not collected. Researchers told the men they were being treated for "bad blood," a local term for several ailments including syphilis, anemia and fatigue, and in exchange the men received free medical exams, free meals and burial insurance. By 1943 penicillin was the treatment of choice for syphilis and becoming widely available, but the participants were not offered it. After the 1972 news story, an advisory panel advised stopping the study in October 1972, and the end was announced a month later; in March 1973 the panel advised medical care for the survivors.
CDC timeline: https://web.archive.org/web/20261010114106/https://www.cdc.gov/tuskegee/about/timeline.html
The story as printed in July 1972
Jean Heller's Associated Press report, printed in The New York Times on 26 July 1972, opened: for 40 years the Public Health Service has conducted a study in which human beings with syphilis, "who were induced to serve as guinea pigs," went without treatment, and a few died of its late effects. It said the study was conducted to determine from autopsies what the disease does to the body, and that the men were promised free transportation, free hot lunches, free medicine for any disease other than syphilis, and free burial after autopsies. It quoted Dr. J. D. Millar of the Center for Disease Control that penicillin was denied them even after it became common, and that "a serious moral problem" arose then. Millar also said the study "was never clandestine," that 15 reports had been published, and that "patients were not denied drugs"; rather, they were not offered drugs. Senator William Proxmire called it "a moral and ethical nightmare."
AP report, 26 July 1972: https://pages.uoregon.edu/eherman/teaching/texts/Heller%20Syphilis%20Victims%20in%20U.S.%20Study.pdf
The advisory panel's findings
The Final Report of the Tuskegee Syphilis Study Ad Hoc Advisory Panel was sent to the Assistant Secretary for Health on 28 April 1973; its chairman, Broadus N. Butler, abstained from concurrence. The panel judged the study ethically unjustified in 1932 and found no evidence that informed consent was gained, adding that "submitting voluntarily is not informed consent." It quoted the agency's own background paper on the reason: a long-term study of untreated syphilis was considered desirable for a better control program, and Macon County's untreated population "offered an unusual opportunity." It cited letters of 1941 and 1942 in which a local draft board was given a list of 256 men under 45 from the study and asked to exclude them from draftees needing treatment, an arrangement the board accepted "to continue this study on an effective basis." The panel said it received reports both that treatment was deliberately withheld and that men seeking it were not denied it. It found the results "disproportionately meager compared with known risks," that control subjects who became syphilitic were moved into the untreated group, and that penicillin should have been made available not later than 1953. Withholding it, the panel wrote, "amplified the injustice."
Advisory Panel Final Report, 1973: https://biotech.law.lsu.edu/cphl/history/reports/tuskegee/complete%20report.pdf
The survivors' lawsuit
Pollard v. United States, Civil Action 4126-N in the Middle District of Alabama, was filed on 24 July 1973 by Charlie W. Pollard and others, with Fred D. Gray among their counsel, against the United States and Alabama health officials. In an order of 31 October 1974, Chief Judge Johnson recorded the plaintiffs' allegation that the defendants fraudulently concealed the existence of their claims, and found a genuine issue of fact over when the claims were discovered and whether any delay resulted from that alleged concealment. The CDC timeline records that the class action ended in a $10 million out-of-court settlement in 1974.
Pollard v. United States, 384 F. Supp. 304: https://case-law.vlex.com/vid/pollard-v-united-states-890608984
The Belmont Report
The National Research Act of 12 July 1974 created a national commission on human subjects, and its Belmont Report was printed in the Federal Register on 18 April 1979 for public comment. Under the principle of justice it states that in the 1940s the Tuskegee syphilis study used disadvantaged, rural black men to study the untreated course of a disease by no means confined to that population, and that these subjects "were deprived of demonstrably effective treatment in order not to interrupt the project, long after such treatment became generally available."
Belmont Report, Federal Register: https://archive.epa.gov/osa/phre/web/pdf/belmont_report_frv44n76.pdf
The apology
In the East Room on 16 May 1997, with survivors present, President Bill Clinton remembered "the hundreds of men used in research without their knowledge and consent." He said that even once a cure was discovered, "they were denied help, and they were lied to by their government," and that what the government did "was shameful, and I am sorry." He told African American citizens he was sorry the federal government "orchestrated a study so clearly racist," and announced a planning grant toward a center for bioethics at Tuskegee.
White House remarks, 16 May 1997: https://clintonwhitehouse5.archives.gov/New/Remarks/Fri/19970516-898.html
What was hidden, how, and why
What was kept from the men, in these records, was the nature of the study and of their treatment: they were told they were being treated for "bad blood," and they were not offered penicillin after it became standard. The cover was free exams, meals, rides and burial, a list of 256 names sent to a draft board so they would be left out of required treatment, and in 1972 the line that the drug was not denied but not offered. The panel, the court, the commission and the President then set down the wrong in their own words.
