The collision
On September 20, 1911, the White Star liner Olympic collided with the Royal Navy cruiser HMS Hawke. According to Lead Stories, the collision "tore the Olympic's hull above and below the waterline." The Olympic limped home for repairs at Harland and Wolff in Belfast, where her near-identical sister, the Titanic, was being finished. In April 1912 the Titanic sailed on her maiden voyage and sank.
The money on record
The insurance position was set out under oath. At the United States Senate inquiry in April 1912, Senator William Alden Smith asked White Star's P. A. S. Franklin: "This ship was insured for $4,000,000?" Franklin replied: "This ship was insured with outside underwriters for $5,000,000, in round figures. It was, in pounds, about a million pounds. The company carried the remainder."
The switch theory
The author Robin Gardiner argued that the ship that sank was not the Titanic at all. In his words, as quoted by the historian Mark Chirnside, the Hawke collision "may have caused more serious damage to the liner than its owners were prepared to admit," and the inquiry into it "was not entirely unbiased." White Star, he wrote, "could not recover the cost of repairs to its ship from the insurance companies." So the owners "might have decided to switch the brand new Titanic with her slightly older sister" and, judging repair "uneconomic," "dispose of the ship in such a way as to be able, this time, to collect on their insurance." Chirnside notes that the theory reached a Sky documentary in September 2004.
The historian's verdict
Chirnside studied Gardiner's case in a 2005 dissertation. He concluded "that the Olympic was not as badly damaged as Gardiner states; that Gardiner's arguments and methodology are flawed; and that the Titanic's owners would not have benefited from an insurance fraud." He credits Gardiner with finding repaired bow damage on the Olympic, but found "no evidence that this was damage caused during the collision."
The yard numbers
The two ships carried different builder's numbers. As Lead Stories explains, "Olympic's parts bore the Harland & Wolff shipyard number 400. The Titanic, built in the adjacent berth in the shipyard, was assigned number 401." That number is "still visible, on one of the ship's giant propellers" at the wreck. The Olympic "was in service the night the Titanic sank," and sailed until "it was retired and scrapped in 1935."