Benítez calls Spain's Air Force UFO release a fraud; Anomalía researchers call the same files a rational reading. The quarrel is method. In the journalist's published statements, civilian conclusions were added to expedientes that should have gone out bare. A 1997 registry notice, and answers by researchers tied to Fundación Anomalía, describe the same labor as rational study of unidentified-flying-object reports and a check for ordinary stimuli.
The foundation's registered aim
On 7 February 1997 the Boletín Oficial del Estado inscribed Fundación Anomalía para el Estudio de los Fenómenos Aéreos Anómalos. The object is to promote study, from a rational perspective based on scientific methodology, of so-called objetos volantes no identificados, of connected matters, and of their sociocultural influence; to keep archives and bibliographies; to publicize the work; and to grant research aid. The first board names Julio Ignacio Arcas Giraldi as president and, among the vocales, Vicente Juan Ballester Olmos, with Clotilde Matilde González García, José Ruesga Montiel, Matías Morey Ripoll, Luis Reinaldo González Manso, and Antonio Petit Gancedo. That sentence is a legal purpose, not a verdict on a particular light.
Boletín Oficial del Estado, 7 February 1997: https://www.boe.es/boe/dias/1997/02/07/pdfs/A04059-04060.pdf
Benítez calls the release a fraud
A 14 February 2008 EFE dispatch from Pamplona, carried on the author's site, reports that Juan José Benítez said Air Force UFO declassification since 1992 had been a "fraude." Seven civilians, six Spaniards and one American, had worked with Air Force intelligence to refute sightings, he said, headed by Vicente Juan Ballester Olmos, director of investigations of Fundación Anomalía. He named Manuel Borraz, Juan Antonio Fernández Peris, Miguel Guasp, Joan Plana, Willy Smith, and Javier Armentia, director of the Pamplona planetarium. The names, he said, sit in 58 confidential letters Willy Smith gave him in 2004. Conclusions went to the Air Force and, when the service thought fit, into the released reports. Between 1992 and 1998, he said, eighty-three expedientes came out, something over eighteen hundred folios, and they should have been released with no manipulation. The originals, he said, are bare reports; putting them in civilian hands voided the process. The letters are not printed in the dispatch.
Javier Armentia answered in the same dispatch. He told EFE that he collaborated: Ballester Olmos asked a personal opinion on some cases, with discretion, and Armentia looked for an astronomical explanation. He called that ordinary case analysis and said the contact was with him as an astrophysicist. He said Benítez mixes data with opinions. One request, two accounts.
EFE, 14 February 2008: https://planetabenitez.com/j-j-benitez-dice-que-la-desclasificacion-ovni-fue-un-fraude-en-el-que-participaron-civiles/
ENIGMAS: the charge, in his words
In ENIGMAS number 168, with David E. Sentinella, Benítez again calls the Spanish release a fraud. Official declassification processes, he says, always seem suspicious, especially after the Spanish Air Force file. Fifty-eight letters, he says, speak for themselves. He says Ballester Olmos wrote, in capitals, that the game would be up if those letters reached Benítez, and that a list received by Willy Smith on 17 May 1993 held forty-two expedientes of which twelve were not yet declassified. He attributes to the late Bastida a 1992 line, "Estamos vareando estiércol." The interview does not print the letters.
ENIGMAS no. 168: https://planetabenitez.com/los-procesos-de-desclasificacion-siempre-me-parecen-sospechosos/
Ballester Olmos in El Mundo
On 29 May 2008 El Mundo hosted Juan Ballester Olmos, introduced as an adviser on the declassification. A reader said newly published letters put him and the military in a bad light, and that files were revised before release in order to discredit them. He called that a distorted reading. The intelligence section, he wrote, asked him to help, and about fifteen people across Spain advised the Mando Operativo Aéreo, adding documentation to surveys that were often poor. He did not quote the fifty-eight letters in that answer.
He wrote that the work is collection and analysis, that he uses "phenomena" in the plural because the reports look like ordinary cases of different kinds, and that this is not the same task as studying extraterrestrial life. Around 90 to 95 percent, he wrote, can be explained conventionally; the rest are unexplained. On the Canaries, 1976 to 1979, he wrote that several important cases are explained as intercontinental-missile tests or other devices, a minority even when the echo was large.
El Mundo, 29 May 2008: https://www.elmundo.es/encuentros/invitados/2008/05/3088/
El País, 2022, and two different counts
El País Semanal of 21 July 2022 profiled him. Antonio Jiménez Barca's headline quotes the line that there can be extraterrestrials, but they cannot get here. After 57 years, the profile says, he concluded that OVNIs as crewed extraterrestrial craft do not exist, and he calls that a liberation. The profile quotes a 1979 Canaries Air Force investigator on craft of unknown origin, then says Ballester Olmos later matched U.S. Navy launch times and identified an intercontinental ballistic missile from a submarine about 1,000 kilometres out. It says Lieutenant Colonel Ángel Bastida asked him in 1992 to help release the files, and that a team analyzed 84 expedientes, about 2,000 pages, and 122 sightings, leaving two unresolved. Those figures are not EFE's eighty-three expedientes and eighteen hundred folios. The two publications do not share one count. They do put an investigator's 1979 unknown-craft sentence and a later missile reading in the same profile.
El País Semanal, 21 July 2022: https://elpais.com/eps/2022-07-21/puede-haber-extraterrestres-pero-no-pueden-llegar-hasta-aqui.html
His 1997 account of the same release
A 1997 essay by Vicente-Juan Ballester Olmos, kept on the Internet Archive from the Fundación Anomalía site, is titled "Military UFO Records Released: The Spanish Experience." A footnote places it in UFOs 1947-1997, edited by Hillary Evans and Dennis Stacy. He writes that the Ministry of Defence process began in 1992, that he took part, and that the files became an open book anyone may read. MOA, he writes, received 62 files for 1962 to 1991. Lieutenant Colonel Ángel Bastida declassified 22 before a new post; Lieutenant Colonel Enrique Rocamora declassified 53 more. The set then stood at 75 files, about 1,900 pages, and 97 events from 1962 to 1995. A team he coordinated, he writes, explained 85 percent in ordinary ways. Fifteen percent stayed unresolved, among them a 1 January 1975 Burgos report he calls a true anomaly. He also writes that one aim was to see material made public uncensored, except for witness names. That is a third count, beside the EFE dispatch's eighty-three expedientes and the 2022 profile's 84 files and 122 sightings. Benítez calls added analysis a fraud. This essay calls the analysis the work of the release, and it still leaves a remainder unsolved.
Internet Archive copy of the 1997 essay: https://web.archive.org/web/20070607220243/http://www.anomalia.org/declass.htm
