For a quarter of a century the Spanish Air Force kept its UFO reports locked away, and when it finally opened them in the 1990s, the man who had done most to make UFOs a public story in Spain called the release a fraud. That is the conspiracy at the heart of this file. What had been hidden was the Air Force's archive of sightings, radar contacts and pilot reports from 1962 onward. What had been denied was public access and, for years, any admission of interest. How it was released is documented: a review begun in 1991, a decision by the Joint Chiefs in 1992 and file-by-file declassification through the decade. Why J. J. Benítez rejects the result is the second half of the story. He says the files came out cut and wrapped in official explanations written with the help of civilian ufologists, led by Vicente-Juan Ballester Olmos, whom he accuses of working to bury the phenomenon.
The official version is on the Defence Ministry's own library site. The Biblioteca Virtual de Defensa's "Expedientes OVNI" portal (https://bibliotecavirtual.defensa.gob.es/BVMDefensa/exp_ovni/es/inicio/inicio.do) says that in 1991 the ministry decided to analyse the files on "avistamientos de fenómenos extraños" and, where appropriate, lower their classification for a public that wanted to read them. In 1992 a physical copy was deposited in the Air Force's central library at its Madrid headquarters. The digitised collection runs to 80 files and 1,900 pages, from the first sighting at San Javier in Murcia in 1962 to the last at Morón in Seville in 1995. The names of witnesses and reporting officers are removed. Each file opens with a summary page giving place, date, facts, considerations, conclusions and a proposal to classify or declassify, followed by witness statements, incident logs and weather reports.
Ballester Olmos, who sat inside the process, tells it in "Declassification! Military UFO Records Released: The Spanish Experience" (https://web.archive.org/web/20060929191708/http://www.anomalia.org/declass.htm). In 1990 and 1991 he began pressing the Air Force to review the classified-matter policy applied to UFOs since 1979. In May 1991 the Air Safety Section, custodian of the files, proposed declassification. In March 1992 the Joint Chiefs of Staff lowered the classification and left full release to the Air Force Chief of Staff. The work went to the intelligence section of the Mando Operativo Aéreo, the Air Operations Command, and to Lieutenant Colonel Ángel Bastida, who released 22 files before moving on. His successor, Lieutenant Colonel Enrique Rocamora, released 53 more. The first files, from 1962, 1967 and 1968, came out in September 1992; the last proposal crossed Torrejón on 8 November 1996. Ballester describes cases that still puzzle him, such as a light seen by an Iberia crew over the Canaries in November 1974 while radar showed only their own aircraft, and writes that most cases turned out to be misidentifications.
Benítez's side is laid out in Víctor Martínez's 2011 review of his book Materia reservada for Informe OVNI (https://www.informeovni.net/bibliografia/materiareservada.html). The book, published in 1993, analyses the first stages of the release and "denuncia una mutilación y tergiversación" of many documents, a mutilation and distortion. Case by case, Benítez takes apart the explanations the MOA attached to each file, explanations that, the review says, were added specifically for the declassification and supplied by a small group of civilian ufologists, headed by Ballester Olmos. Using official weather-balloon launch records and the original reports, Benítez argues that those explanations are wrong. Many of the cases are military and airline sightings from the air, some with radar.
The bitterness runs both ways, and Benítez puts the quarrel in his own words in "1976: El primer gran ataque del 'Lado Oscuro'" (https://planetabenitez.com/1976-el-primer-gran-ataque-del-lado-oscuro/). He reproduces passages in which Ballester and his colleagues blame Benítez's 1977 book of twelve Air Force files for the decision of 3 March 1979 to make UFOs "materia reservada," citing its "tono sensacionalista y sesgado." Benítez answers that the archive was closed because the ministry was flooded with requests after his book, including requests from his critics, and, citing a letter from General Galarza, that the Air Force chief did not share his critics' view. He calls his opponents the "lado oscuro," the dark side of Spanish ufology, and accuses them of a campaign of slander. Each man, in short, says the other made the secrecy worse.
The files did not reach the open internet until 2016. 20minutos reported in "Defensa desclasifica hasta 1.900 páginas de 'Expedientes ovni' en toda España" (https://www.20minutos.es/noticia/2869393/0/defensa-documentos-desclasificados-expedientes-ovni-espana/) that until then they could be consulted only in person at Air Force headquarters. The story gives four Galician cases from 1966 to 1993, among them a witness who described an object "redondo, de un diámetro más o menos de dos metros con una punta terminada en forma de obús," lit by "una luz fantástica," that had gone by the time he stopped his car.
Europa Press, in a wire story carried by Público on 24 October 2016 (https://www.publico.es/ciencias/ejercito-publica-80-expedientes-avistamientos-fenomenos-extranos-1962-1995-toda-espana.html), set out the official version: the ministry had decided in 1991 to analyse the files and lower their classification, a physical copy went to the Air Force's central library in Madrid in 1992, and the 80 digitised files ran from a 1962 sighting at San Javier in Murcia to a 1995 case at Morón de la Frontera. Each file, the story said, ends with a proposal to classify or declassify it. For Benítez's readers, that last line is the point: someone still decided, case by case, what the public got to see.
Spain's Air Force UFO files were declassified file by file from 1992 through the late 1990s and put online in 2016: 80 files, 1,900 pages, 1962 to 1995. Ballester Olmos, who helped drive the release, calls it a full opening; Benítez calls it a fraud, saying the files were cut and wrapped in explanations supplied by Ballester's group.
What Stays Contested
Whether anything was held back is unproven either way: the ministry presents its 80 files as the declassified archive, while Benítez says files were mutilated. Even the counts differ, with Ballester's article crediting two officers with 22 and 53 releases against the 80 files now online. The explanations attached to individual cases remain the battleground.
