The record
John Wilkes Booth shot President Abraham Lincoln at Ford's Theatre on April 14, 1865. Twelve days later, soldiers cornered him in a barn on the Virginia farm of Richard Garrett. They set the barn on fire, and a soldier shot him through the neck.
A Maryland appeals court retold what followed in its 1996 decision in Kline v. Green Mount Cemetery. The body was taken "to the USS Montauk in Washington," where "an inquiry was held by Army Judge Advocate General Joseph Holt. Several witnesses identified the body as that of Booth." One witness identified him by "the India-ink letters 'J.W.B.' on his wrist ... and then by a scar on the neck." Dr. John Frederick May had earlier "removed a tumor from Booth's neck, which may well have caused the scar."
The confession
In 1907 a Memphis lawyer, Finis L. Bates, published The Escape and Suicide of John Wilkes Booth. Its title page promises "a complete confession by Booth many years after the crime," "written for the correction of history." Bates said a man he knew in Texas as John St. Helen had confessed to being Booth.
History.com describes the scene, set in Granbury, Texas, in 1877. Believing he was dying, St. Helen "whispered, 'I am dying. My name is John Wilkes Booth.'" He recovered and left town.
The Enid mummy
A quarter of a century later, Bates read in a Memphis paper about the death of a drifter. The man, known as David E. George, had died in a hotel in Enid, Oklahoma, in 1903. As the Oklahoma Historical Society records, "Bates identified the body as his old friend John St. Helen," and therefore as Booth.
The embalmed body became a touring exhibit. In 1920, the society notes, "the body was stolen after the train wrecked." Bates recovered it, and after his death "his widow sold the mummy. It may today be stored in someone's basement or closet."
The sealed grave
Booth's descendants and researchers later asked a court to open the grave in Baltimore's Green Mount Cemetery believed to hold Booth's remains. The trial judge found "no compelling reason for exhumation." He cited possible water damage, the lack of dental records, and "Petitioners' less than convincing escape/cover up theory." The petitioners had argued that Bates's account had survived "with its credibility and persuasiveness intact." In 1996 the appeals court upheld the refusal.
The DNA push
In 2013 the researcher Nate Orlowek, who had studied the case for some 40 years, joined Booth descendants in a new request, as The Verge reported. They hoped to compare "three vertebrae taken from that man shot through the neck," held by the Army, with the remains of Booth's brother Edwin. In March 2013 the National Museum of Health and Medicine refused, saying testing "would significantly deplete the material and destroy both the physical integrity of the object and the evidence of the trauma suffered at the time of injury." Orlowek's view: "Any quote-unquote 'fact' is always subject to finding new information."
The believers' answer
The Army's letter, as The Philadelphia Inquirer reported, said "the need to preserve these bones for future generations compels us to decline the destructive test," and that DNA testing "may or may not yield the information desired." A Booth descendant who backed the test said she would take the question to her grave, "but I will take it kicking and screaming." Believers ask why one DNA test cannot settle it. Who really died in that barn?