A September 2000 Justice release and a December 2000 IITRI review describe Carnivore as court-ordered packet collection, with stated limits and a pen-trap length risk. Congressional reports for fiscal years 2002 and 2003 say DCS 1000, formerly Carnivore, was not used, and that commercial software was, while quoting a duty to report any subsequent version they do not name. A 2005 FBI guide says Data Collection System (DCS) 3000. A 2007 article says Digital Collection System Network and calls one component classified. Data and Digital are not one name, and no unnamed follow-on is added.
FBI records document Carnivore and later collection systems, and do not name a secret successor. A 2000 release describes Carnivore as a court-ordered collection tool. A December 2000 review prints the limits of that software. Reports for fiscal years 2002 and 2003 say DCS 1000, formerly Carnivore, was not used, and that commercial software was. A 2005 guide says Data Collection System. A 2007 article says Digital Collection System Network. Those two adjectives are not merged here.
PublishedSep 23, 2026
What the Department said the review would examine
On 26 September 2000 the Department of Justice announced a contract with the IIT Research Institute, associated with the Illinois Institute of Technology, to review Carnivore. The release quotes Assistant Attorney General for Administration Stephen R. Colgate. The team includes Chicago-Kent faculty, starts at once, and is to finish in December 2000, with a draft in late November. It describes Carnivore as a computer-based tool that, with an internet service provider, lets the FBI comply with court orders, from "to/from" information to full content of emails or other electronic communications to or from a user named in an investigation. The estimated cost is nearly $175,000, on time and materials. Eleven proposals are listed, two unnamed at the bidders' request. The Attorney General approved the selection, and the contract was signed that day. The release describes a system and a review. It does not describe a later network.
The final report, contract 00-C-0328, IITRI CR-030-216, is dated 8 December 2000 Prepared-by lines name Stephen P. Smith, Henry H. Perritt, Jr., Harold Krent, Stephen Mencik, J. Allen Crider, Mengfen Shyong, and Larry L. Reynolds. It calls Carnivore software that examines Internet Protocol packets and records only those meeting set parameters. On four questions, the reviewers conclude: under a Title III order, investigators get no more than the order permits; under a pen-trap order, the software also records message and field lengths, possibly past what the court allowed; it adds network risk only if the provider must alter the network to fit it; it lowers but does not remove the risk of unauthorized acquisition by FBI personnel; and its audits do not match the risks. The same summary says that, wrongly configured, Carnivore can record any traffic it monitors, and that it keeps no data except what passes its filters. A later answer ties the Title III limit to version 1.3.4. Those lines are about that version. They are not a description of a system built afterward.
A report to the Judiciary Committees, cover date 24 February 2003, recites section 305 of Public Law 107-273: a duty to report, for fiscal years 2002 and 2003, on use of DCS 1000 (formerly known as Carnivore), or any subsequent version, for court orders under 18 U.S.C. §§ 3123 and 2518. For fiscal year 2002 it says the FBI ran court-ordered surveillance of authorized accounts with commercially available software the FBI owned, on five occasions: three under section 3123 and two under section 2518. It says the FBI made no use of DCS 1000 that year, and used the commercial software instead. For the three section 3123 instances, the authorizing official is the Unit Chief, Data Intercept Technology Unit, Investigative Technology Division. The two section 2518 deployments are called pending sensitive investigations and are not set out. The signature block names Thomas W. Richardson, Assistant Director of that division, dated 24 February 2003.
A second report, cover date 18 December 2003, recites the same duty. For fiscal year 2003 it says the same class of commercial software was deployed eight times: six under section 3123 and two under section 2518. It says the FBI made no use of DCS 1000 in that period. The six section 3123 orders are printed as sixty-day periods, one extended. The two section 2518 matters are again withheld as pending. The authorizing official is again that Unit Chief. Both reports quote a duty to cover "any subsequent version." Both then say DCS 1000 was not used, and both name commercial software rather than a named follow-on program.
An FBI file released under FOIA, cover subjects DCS-3000 and RED HOOK, holds a System Security Plan for DCS 3000 dated 28 April 2006, owner the Operational Technology Division, and a user guide titled Data Collection System (DCS) 3000, with a July 2005 table of contents. The guide says the suite was built to help agencies collect and process data for court-ordered electronic surveillance. It defines a pen register as collection of call-related data, and Title 3 as collection of call-related data and content. A cooperative warrant, it says, collects both for numbers on a CW list. The guide's name is Data Collection System. The basics chapter does not print the phrase Digital Collection System Network.
On 29 August 2007 Wired published Ryan Singel's article "Point, Click ... Eavesdrop: How the FBI Wiretap Net Operates." It says the FBI built a system called DCSNet, for Digital Collection System Network, linking FBI wiretap rooms to switches at land-line, internet-telephony, and cellular companies. Many details, it says, were redacted in documents the Electronic Frontier Foundation obtained. It says DCSNet has at least three Windows components. The DCS-3000 client, also known as Red Hook, handles pen registers and trap-and-traces, signaling rather than content, and the article gives that client a $10 million figure. DCS-6000, Digital Storm, captures call and text content for full wiretap orders. A third component, DCS-5000, is called classified and is described as used for wiretaps aimed at spies or terrorists. In the same article a sentence about Matt Blaze calls Carnivore the FBI's now-retired internet-wiretapping application, which he had helped assess in 2000. The article's Digital and the guide's Data are both on the page that prints them. The congressional phrase "subsequent version" is not, in those reports, filled in with the name DCSNet.
The 2000 release and the IITRI report describe Carnivore. The congressional reports say DCS 1000, formerly Carnivore, was not used in fiscal years 2002 and 2003, and that commercial software was. The 2005 guide names a Data Collection System, DCS 3000. The 2007 article names a Digital Collection System Network and three components, one of which it calls classified. No sentence in the reports equates that network with "any subsequent version." The names stay where they are printed.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some of these are sold by partners: we may earn a commission if you buy through their links, at no extra cost to you.