AT&T said it obeyed the law, but a technician's papers showed a locked NSA room copying web traffic in San Francisco. Room 641A sat on the sixth floor of AT&T's building at 611 Folsom Street. Inside, according to the technician who wired it, was equipment fed by optical splitters that made a full copy of the internet traffic passing through the building and sent it to a room only NSA-cleared staff could enter. AT&T would not confirm or deny. The government said the program was lawful and secret. When customers sued, Congress passed a law that let the Attorney General end the lawsuits, and the courts dismissed them. What was hidden was the scale of domestic collection; the reason given for hiding it was national security.
The technician's story
Mark Klein worked at AT&T for 22 and a half years as a technician keeping network and internet systems running. In a January 2007 interview with FRONTLINE he described the Folsom Street building and how he came to understand what the secret room was for. Before he retired in May 2004, he gathered several hundred pages of documents describing the room, including instructions on how to implement the splitter, a floor plan, and photos. He called a small sample his "2004 package" and wrote in its introduction: "I am presenting this information to facilitate the dismantling of this dangerous Orwellian project." The larger set went under court seal.
FRONTLINE printed AT&T's statement of 27 June 2006, which said "the law does not permit" comment on the NSA allegations and that AT&T "would not provide customer information to any government agency except as specifically authorized under the law."
FRONTLINE, "Spying on the Home Front," interview with Mark Klein (9 January 2007): https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/homefront/interviews/klein.html
How the splitter worked
The Electronic Frontier Foundation's summary of Klein's testimony and that of expert witness J. Scott Marcus, a former senior adviser for internet technology at the FCC, sets out the mechanism. AT&T's internet traffic in San Francisco ran through fiber-optic cables at the Folsom Street facility. A "splitter" diverted a complete copy of the traffic, email, web browsing, and other communications of AT&T WorldNet customers and of people on other networks who exchanged traffic with them, onto a separate cable connected to the SG-3 room, room 641A, which EFF describes as controlled by the NSA. The original stream went on to its destination.
The room, the summary says, was built under NSA supervision and held equipment able to analyze communications at high speed and to select contents and traffic patterns by user-defined rules. Only people with NSA clearances had access. Marcus judged the evidence consistent with 15 to 20 similar sites nationwide, possibly more, implying that "probably well over half" of AT&T's purely domestic traffic was diverted.
EFF, "AT&T's Role in Dragnet Surveillance of Millions of Its Customers" (press kit summary of the Klein and Marcus declarations): https://www.eff.org/files/filenode/att/presskit/ATT_onepager.pdf
The wider program
EFF's account places the room inside a larger story. News reports in December 2005 revealed that the NSA had been intercepting Americans' phone calls and internet communications without warrants, and a USA Today story in May 2006 reported that the agency was receiving wholesale copies of telephone and other communications records. EFF says the government, with help from major carriers including AT&T, had carried out dragnet surveillance of millions of ordinary Americans since at least 2001, and that the Klein documents show AT&T copying all emails, web browsing, and other internet traffic to and from its customers and giving the copies to the NSA.
EFF, "NSA Spying": https://www.eff.org/nsa-spying
The lawsuit and the immunity
EFF filed Hepting v. AT&T on 31 January 2006 on behalf of AT&T customers, using Klein's evidence; the government quickly intervened. In spring 2006 more than 50 other suits were filed against telecom companies and combined into a single proceeding. In June 2006 the court rejected the government's bid to dismiss on state secrets grounds and AT&T's own arguments for dismissal. In July 2008, after a long fight in Congress, the carriers won what EFF calls retroactive immunity under the FISA Amendments Act. The Attorney General filed the required certification in September 2008, a federal judge dismissed Hepting and dozens of other suits in June 2009, the dismissal was affirmed on appeal, and in October 2012 the Supreme Court declined to hear the case.
EFF, "Hepting v. AT&T" case page: https://www.eff.org/cases/hepting
The law that closed the courtroom
The FISA Amendments Act of 2008, Public Law 110-261, added a title on protection of persons assisting the government. It provides that a civil action may not lie or be maintained in any court against a person for providing assistance to an element of the intelligence community, and shall be promptly dismissed, if the Attorney General certifies to the court that the assistance was given in connection with an intelligence activity authorized by the President between 11 September 2001 and 17 January 2007 and described in written requests indicating the activity was authorized and determined to be lawful. The same law rewrote the rules for targeting people outside the United States.
Public Law 110-261, FISA Amendments Act of 2008: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-110publ261/html/PLAW-110publ261.htm
The inspectors general
In July 2009 the inspectors general of the Justice Department, Defense Department, CIA, NSA, and Office of the Director of National Intelligence issued an unclassified report on the President's Surveillance Program. It described a program authorized by the President after the September 11 attacks and reauthorized roughly every 45 days, kept to a very small circle of officials, with the legal analysis resting for a time on the work of a single Justice Department lawyer. It recounted the March 2004 dispute in which senior Justice officials refused to recertify part of the program, and it found that the extraordinary secrecy hampered the program's legal review and made it hard to judge how useful it was.
Offices of Inspectors General, "Unclassified Report on the President's Surveillance Program" (10 July 2009): https://oig.justice.gov/sites/default/files/archive/special/s0907.pdf
What was hidden, and why
What was hidden was a copy of the internet, made in a locked room. AT&T's line was that it followed the law and could say no more; the government's was secrecy and lawful authority. The lawsuits ended not on the facts but on a certification Congress allowed.
