Trailblazer was carried as the future; oversight later called it a failure; ThinThread privacy was not built. The Department of Defense Inspector General’s December 2004 audit of requirements for Trailblazer and ThinThread was opened from a Defense Hotline complaint alleging fraud, waste, and abuse in how NSA developed the two systems. Senator Ron Wyden later told the Senate that Trailblazer had been one of Michael Hayden’s signature NSA management initiatives and that Hayden, looking back, had said “we overachieved,” while press reporting then described the program as belly-up. A former NSA employee’s 2012 court declaration states that ThinThread was designed with encryption of domestic-side data until a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court warrant could be obtained, and that the NSA chose not to implement ThinThread.
The DoD IG Audit
Report No. 05-INTEL-03, “Requirements for the TRAILBLAZER and THINTHREAD Systems,” dated 15 December 2004, from the Office of the Inspector General of the Department of Defense, Deputy Inspector General for Intelligence, states that the audit was initiated from a Hotline complaint. The complaint alleged that NSA actions in the development of ThinThread and Trailblazer resulted in fraud, waste, and abuse, including that Trailblazer development wasted dollars and that NSA disregarded solutions to urgent U.S. national security needs. The memorandum to the Director, NSA, records management noncurrence or partial concurrence with recommendations and requests additional comments. Trailblazer is described in the report as an acquisition-category program intended, through spiral developments, to transform cryptologic exploitation of the global network. Large portions of the released text remain redacted; what is public is the Hotline origin, the dual-program scope, and the contested recommendations track.
DoD OIG — Requirements for the TRAILBLAZER and THINTHREAD Systems (05-INTEL-03, 15 Dec. 2004; redacted): https://archive.org/download/206129-redacted-dod-oig-audit-requirements-for-the/206129-redacted-dod-oig-audit-requirements-for-the.pdf
Congressional Record: Trailblazer as Future, Then Failure Language
In Senate floor debate on 25 May 2006 on the nomination of General Michael V. Hayden to be Director of Central Intelligence, Senator Ron Wyden recounted asking Hayden, at the 2005 hearing on Hayden’s nomination as Principal Deputy Director of National Intelligence, about the NSA Trailblazer Program — “one of the General’s signature NSA management initiatives” reported as designed to modernize the Agency’s information technology infrastructure. Wyden quoted Hayden from page 44 of that 2005 transcript: “A personal view, now—looking back—we overachieved.” Wyden then said that, while classified detail could not be given on the floor, “today the press is reporting that the program is belly-up and the press is reporting that it is a billion dollars worth of junk software.” That is the oversight record’s public failure language set beside Trailblazer’s earlier status as a signature future-system initiative. It is not a criminal finding.
Congressional Record reprint — Senate floor statements on Hayden nomination (25 May 2006): https://irp.fas.org/congress/2006_cr/s052506.html
ThinThread’s Privacy Build, Employee Declaration
In Jewel v. National Security Agency, No. CV-08-04373-JSW (N.D. Cal.), William E. Binney filed a declaration on 21 June 2012 (Document 88) identifying himself as a former NSA employee. He states that he supervised and participated in development of ThinThread; that where one side of an international communication was domestic, ThinThread was designed so “the data would be encrypted (and the privacy of U.S. citizens protected) until such time as a warrant could be obtained from the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court”; that after September 11, members of his ThinThread team tasked on aspects of the President’s Surveillance Program told him the PSP involved collection of domestic electronic communications traffic “without any of the privacy protections built into ThinThread”; and that “The NSA chose not to implement ThinThread.” He also states that he was involved in reporting government waste on Trailblazer to the DoD Inspector General and that he was formally cleared of criminal wrongdoing in January 2010. Those are employee-declaration verbs in a filed court paper, not a jury verdict against NSA managers.
U.S. District Court (N.D. Cal.) — Declaration of William E. Binney, Jewel v. NSA, Doc. 88 (2 July 2012 filing): https://www.eff.org/files/filenode/binneydeclaration.pdf
The Drake Case: Indictment and Misdemeanor Plea
A 14 April 2010 indictment in the District of Maryland charged former NSA senior executive Thomas Andrews Drake with willful retention of national defense information, obstruction of justice, and making false statements. The indictment describes Drake as an NSA employee from 2001 through 2008 with access to classified systems and alleges retention and transmission of classified and unclassified information to a newspaper reporter. Those are the counts charged in April 2010. The indictment is the charging paper. The plea is in the June 2011 release.
Indictment — United States v. Thomas Andrews Drake (D. Md., Apr. 2010): https://s3.documentcloud.org/documents/323707/drake-indictment.pdf
A Department of Justice Office of Public Affairs release dated 15 April 2010 announced that ten-count indictment. A later DOJ release dated 10 June 2011 states that Drake pleaded guilty to a one-count criminal information charging unauthorized access of an NSA computer, a misdemeanor, and that the government moved to dismiss the felony indictment at sentencing. The June 2011 release records that plea and that dismissal motion. It does not record a conviction on the felony counts in the April 2010 indictment.
DOJ OPA reprint — Former NSA Senior Executive Charged (15 Apr. 2010): https://sgp.fas.org/news/2010/04/doj041510.html
DOJ OPA reprint — Former NSA Senior Executive Pleads Guilty to Unauthorized Access (10 Jun. 2011): https://irp.fas.org/news/2011/06/doj061011.html
What the Paper Trail Settles
Trailblazer was carried as a major NSA modernization path. The DoD Inspector General audited Trailblazer and ThinThread requirements after a Hotline complaint. Senate floor language later described Trailblazer in failure terms. A former employee’s court declaration states that ThinThread’s privacy design — encryption until a Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Court warrant — was not what NSA implemented. Drake was charged, then resolved on a misdemeanor computer-access plea, with the felony indictment dismissed.
