The image that travelled
A photo shared widely online showed what looked like a giant tree "trunk" more than two miles wide. Snopes identified it in 2017 as Jugurtha's Table, the Jugurtha Tableland in Tunisia, which it describes as "a rock formation, not a vestige of forests." Snopes explains how mesas form under a hard caprock, and quotes a 2016 Inverse summary of the theory: that forests today are remnants of a world of "40-mile high trees, with trunks two miles across," and that "Flat top mountains are remnants of behemoth trees."
The adherents' reading
A 2020 post on a Tartaria Empire blog sets out the idea in its own words. It calls mesas, buttes and jagged mountains "giant petrified tree stumps," says "the pictures speak for themselves," and suggests the trees "were made from silicone and were nearly as hard as stone." It offers "a Biblical perspective": a much larger world before the flood. The post links a video titled "There are No Forests on Flat Earth Wake up."
The idea circulates in some flat earth and Biblical flood circles. Snopes ties it to "some flat earth conspiracy theorists," and a 2025 video tied it to the Book of Enoch. It is not the view of flat earth believers or religious people in general.
The fibres claim and the rock
A TikTok video of March 4, 2024 said the hexagonal columns of Devils Tower in Wyoming are "fibers of a tree that would have been 19,000 feet tall." Science Feedback reviewed the claim in May 2024. It says mesas and buttes form by deposition and by uneven erosion under a hard caprock. It adds that Devils Tower is phonolite, an igneous rock, whose minerals (anorthoclase, aegirine-augite, albite and microcline) do not match petrified wood, which is made of silica or calcite.
The geology, with its open question
The National Park Service describes the tower as phonolite porphyry and "the largest example of columnar jointing in the world." Geologists agree it began as magma, but they "cannot agree upon" how it cooled. The candidates are a stock, an eroded laccolith (Darton and O'Hara, 1907), a volcanic plug or neck, or a maar-diatreme volcano (Prokop Závada and colleagues, 2015). The tower formed about 50 million years ago, one to two miles underground, and erosion began exposing it 5 to 10 million years ago.
The park is candid about what is not known. Erosion "also erased the evidence needed to determine which theory" is correct, and scientists are "uncertain what causes the variation in shape" of the columns. No tree material has been found in the tower.
The newest wave
In September 2025 a new video tied the "stumps" to the Book of Enoch. Lead Stories reviewed it and says the photos show natural geological features. It notes that some rock textures "can resemble giant-scale bark, or growth rings," and that the photos were cropped to hide the shape of the whole landform.
On tree height, both Science Feedback and Lead Stories cite the same 2004 study in Nature by George Koch and colleagues, which estimated a maximum tree height of 122 to 130 metres, about 427 feet. That is one study, cited twice.
The first names
The tower had names long before the theory. The Park Service records a Kiowa account, written down in 1897, of seven girls lifted by a growing rock away from bears whose claws scored its sides; the girls became the Pleiades. The park notes: "The Kiowa call this rock 'Tso-aa', a tree rock, possibly because it grew tall like a tree." Lakota, Cheyenne, Crow and Arapaho accounts call it Mato Tipila, Bear Lodge, Bear's House or Bear's Tipi. The Kiowa account is a sacred story in its own right. It is not part of the tree stump claim, and this page does not use it as support for either side.
The adherents' answer
The blog post came before the fact checks, so it does not reply to them directly. Its answer is to geologists in general: "The pictures speak for themselves," and "Scientists have explained plateaus away to some volcanic miracle." In its view these great rock structures are "something much different than we've been told." Can a shape alone tell you what made it?