Case zero
The theory began with a comment on Reddit. On December 27, 2014, in an AskReddit thread asking what people's parents had taught them that turned out not to be normal, a user called Raregan wrote: "My parents never believed in Finland, I grew up to never believe in Finland until I researched it further." The comment went on to set out the whole idea. In the version Skeptoid later reproduced, it adds: "World maps are altered as it's a U.N conspiracy to keep people believing in Finland."
The theory
Vice laid out the theory in 2016. "The notion goes that the two nations," Japan and Russia, "created Finland so that Japan could fish the sea that truly exists there without any environmental complaints or repercussions." The fish are shipped by rail "from the Eastern Russian coast to Japan under the disguise of 'Nokia' products." People who call themselves Finns are really "from small towns on either the Eastern part of Sweden, the Western part of Russia, or the Northern part of Estonia." And the name is a clue: "What do fish have? Fins. Thus Finland." A forum devoted to the theory took the tagline "The Truth is Finnly Veiled."
The details shift with the teller. In a version reported by Metro in 2018, "Finland is in fact an open expanse of ocean and 'Finns' actually live in Sweden. The country was dreamt up by Russia and Japan in World War 2 so that Japan could secretly fish there." Raregan's comment placed the invention after the Cold War instead.
The poster speaks
Vice tracked down the Reddit user, identified only as Jack. He was the one who posted the theory, not its inventor: he said he had learned it from his parents as a child. "I would say 90 percent of people view it as a parody and joke," he said, and Vice reported that he himself believes Finland is real.
The Finnish reaction
Finland's largest newspaper, Helsingin Sanomat, reported the story the day after Vice. It described how Jack's parents had convinced him as a child that Finland was an invented country, and said that the theory was absurd, but true to a child.
The skeptics' answer
Brian Dunning of Skeptoid answered in 2017 with history and geography. The name Finland appears on old runestones, including U 582 and the "13th century runestone G 319." Finland's south coast is "about 60 kilometers" from Estonia, and "the Tallinn to Helsinki ferry ... takes about two hours." The Guardian, in 2018, listed Finland among "bizarre geographic conspiracies," alongside claims that Australia and the Italian region of Molise do not exist.
The believers' answer
Believers have an answer to that too. As Skeptoid summarizes it: "Maps, aerial and space photography, and GPS systems worldwide have been altered." And the theory, as Vice quotes it, ends with a compliment: "No real country could so consistently place first in Education, Healthcare, Gender Equality, Literacy Rates, National Stability, the least corrupt government in the world, Freedom of the press." Finland, in this telling, is "a concept for countries and people to aspire to." Is Finland a nation, or an ideal painted onto the sea?