How the Grail became the cup
The Holy Grail did not start as the cup of the Last Supper. As Alan Lupack of the University of Rochester's Camelot Project explains, the early poet Chrétien de Troyes "speaks of 'un graal,' a grail or platter and thus not a unique item." Wolfram von Eschenbach's Parzival "presents the grail as a stone." The link to the Last Supper and to Joseph of Arimathea "was introduced into the Arthurian legends by Robert de Boron in his verse romance Joseph d'Arimathie," "probably written in the last decade of the twelfth century or the first couple of years of the thirteenth." In medieval romance, Lupack adds, the Grail was said to have travelled to Glastonbury.
Glastonbury
Glastonbury Abbey in Somerset tells the story in its own words. Joseph "receives the Grail ... from an apparition of Jesus and sends it with his followers to Britain." Later legends have him "burying it in a secret place, said to have been just below the Tor at the entrance to the underworld. The spring at what is known as Chalice Well is believed to flow from there." His staff took root on Wearyall Hill, and he founded "the first wattle church." Under Abbot Chinnock, from 1375 to 1420, Joseph "seems to have become a major object of pilgrimage."
Valencia
In Spain, Valencia Cathedral venerates an "Agate cup, oriental art from the 1st century BC. Medieval handles and base." The cathedral says: "Tradition reveals that it is the same cup that the Lord used at the Last Supper." As The Irish Times noted, "a commonly held view in Spain until now had been that it is in the cathedral of Valencia and, in 2006, Pope Benedict gave Mass with the purported relic."
León
In March 2014 two historians, Margarita Torres and José Miguel Ortega del Río, announced a rival claim. The cup in question, held at the Basilica of San Isidoro in León, is "formed by two goblets joined together" and known as "the goblet of the Infanta Doña Urraca, daughter of Fernando I, King of León from 1037 to 1065." According to the news agency AFP, "Two Egyptian parchments they found in 2011 at Cairo's University of al-Azhar set them on a three-year investigation." The upper agate part is "missing a fragment as described in the parchments." Crowds came, and curators moved the cup off display. "In Europe alone there are 200 supposed holy grails, the Spanish researchers admitted."
The historians' view
History.com reported that "Many historians are skeptical of the latest claim of the Holy Grail's discovery, and there's no evidence that the Holy Grail even exists. The cup received only a passing mention in the Bible." "More than 200 goblets in Europe alone have been posited." Earlier candidates included a Glastonbury find in the early 1900s, the Antioch Chalice, which scholars date "to the early sixth century," and a cup shown at the Toledo Museum in 1927. The León authors report dating their cup "between 200 B.C. and 100 A.D."
The believers' answer
The León historians make a careful claim. As The Irish Times reported, they "cannot say for sure whether this chalice ever actually touched Christ's lips. However, they insist there is no doubt that this is the cup that the early Christians revered as the chalice used at the last supper." Torres put it this way: "The only chalice that could be considered the chalice of Christ is that which made the journey to Cairo and then from Cairo to León, and that is this chalice." Which cup, if any, held the wine?