The order and its papers
The Order of the Illuminati was real, and its own internal writings survive. In 1787 the Bavarian state printed a volume titled Einige Originalschriften des Illuminatenordens, "some original writings of the Order of the Illuminati." The title says the papers were found during a house search at Landshut on October 11 and 12, 1786, at the home of the former government councillor Franz Xaver von Zwack, and printed "auf höchsten Befehl," by highest command of the Elector. A secret society's private papers were published by the state that suppressed it. That volume is still held by the Bavarian State Library.
What the order was
Vox describes the Illuminati as "a secret society that operated for only a decade, from 1776 to 1785." It was founded by Adam Weishaupt, "a German law professor who believed strongly in Enlightenment ideals," to educate members "in reason, philanthropy, and other secular" values. "In 1785, Duke of Bavaria Karl Theodor banned secret societies, including the Illuminati." Vox also quotes the Masonic author Christopher Hodapp on later groups using the name: "People have tried to revive them over the years, but it's a moneymaking scheme."
The first conspiracy reading
The claim that the order lived on began within a few years of the ban. In 1797 John Robison, a professor at Edinburgh and secretary to the Royal Society of Edinburgh, published Proofs of a Conspiracy. He wrote that Enlightenment doctrines had mixed into Freemasonry "till, at last, an Association has been formed for the express purpose of rooting out all the religious establishments, and overturning all the existing governments of Europe." He went further: "the most active leaders in the French Revolution were members of this Association." And he warned that "this Association still exists, still works in secret."
The second
The French priest Augustin Barruel made a parallel case in his Memoirs, Illustrating the History of Jacobinism. Part III, titled "The Antisocial Conspiracy" in its 1798 London translation, opens with chapters on "Spartacus-Weishaupt, Founder of the Illuminees" and the "Code of the Illuminees," grade by grade. Barruel gives the founding date: "It was on the first of May 1776, that the inauguration was celebrated." Robison and Barruel are the origin of the claim that the order survived its ban and steered the Revolution.
The modern legend
BBC Future describes the historical order as "a Bavarian secret society, founded in 1776." It traces today's world-controlling Illuminati to two later works: Principia Discordia, a 1960s "parody text for a parody faith," and The Illuminatus! Trilogy, by Robert Anton Wilson and another Playboy writer, which pinned the cover-ups of the age on the order.
Why the idea matters now
The Institute for Strategic Dialogue notes that "anti-Masonic, anti-Illuminati and other theories that similarly posited the existence of an elite, 'shadow' establishment date back to the 1800s," and that they feed today's "New World Order" narratives.
The believers' answer
Believers return to Robison. Writing only twelve years after the ban, he said the association "still exists, still works in secret," and that its members led the French Revolution. On that reading, the Bavarian ban did not end the order. It taught it to hide. Did it end in 1785?