The plan
The National Park Service describes "Pierre L'Enfant's city plan of 1790" as "a network of broad diagonal axes superimposed over a more traditional pattern of east-west and north-south streets." Pennsylvania Avenue is the main axis, giving "a direct link between the legislative and executive centers: the Capitol and the President's House." The park illustrates the plan with the L'Enfant and Ellicott map of Washington from 1792. Every symbolic reading of the capital starts from this documented design.
The cornerstone
Freemasonry was present at the city's founding. The Architect of the Capitol records that "The Capitol's first cornerstone was laid on September 18, 1793, by President Washington in a Masonic ceremony," with a parade before and feasting after. Allyn Cox later painted the scene in the Capitol's corridors.
The Masonic thesis
In The Secret Architecture of Our Nation's Capital (2000), author David Ovason argued that Washington was designed and built largely by Masonic architects who imprinted their beliefs on the layout. In his account George Washington wore a Masonic apron decorated with occult symbols and a zodiac at the 1793 ceremony, and Washington, Thomas Jefferson, Andrew Ellicott and others substantially changed L'Enfant's blueprint. Ovason's central claim is that the "earthly triangle" formed by the Capitol, the White House and the Washington Monument mirrors a triangle of stars in the constellation Virgo. Publishers Weekly called the book "audacious, erudite" and the Virgo link "interesting, if dubious," adding that "Ovason never establishes the significance of the link."
The Masonic answer
Some of the firmest replies come from Freemasons themselves. Speaking to National Geographic in 2009, Mark Tabbert, director of collections at the George Washington Masonic Memorial, said: "Individually, Masons had a role in building the White House, in building and designing Washington, D.C." He agreed that small-scale Masonic symbols appear around the city, but said there is no Masonic message in the street plan, and that "Pierre L'Enfant wasn't a Mason."
Freemason and historian Jay Kinney told the magazine that most Masonic symbols are not unique to Freemasonry: "I view the Masonic use of symbols as a grab bag taken from here, there, and everywhere." National Geographic adds, in its own words, that the pentagram is much older than Freemasonry and took on occult overtones only in the 19th and 20th centuries.
The pentagram
The pentagram reading uses five streets: Massachusetts Avenue, Rhode Island Avenue, Connecticut Avenue, Vermont Avenue and K Street NW. Together, as WTOP described it in 2019, they form "a sort of broken inverted pentagram that points to the White House."
WTOP put the idea to two local experts. Jason Van Dyke of the Grand Lodge of the District of Columbia rejected it. Jane Levey of the Historical Society of Washington said the plan follows the land, the views and room for the city to grow. Van Dyke said L'Enfant "was fired by Washington after working on the project for less than a year." WTOP adds that the Smithsonian says he resigned at Jefferson's urging, and that Andrew Ellicott finished the design.
The sources disagree on who was a Mason. Ovason says the men who changed the plan were "many of them Masons." WTOP says not a single street designer was a Mason, and that Jefferson was not one either.
The owl
The owl reading appears in a 2013 thread on the Metabunk forum. One member shared an aerial view of the Capitol grounds, first labelled as the White House and corrected in the thread to the Capitol, and asked why it seemed to "look like one big giant owl." Other members pointed to different shapes in the same view, such as a vase and a mushroom cloud. The thread records one person's question, not the origin of the idea.
The adherents' answer
Ovason's answer is that the original plan was not the final one. Washington, Jefferson and Ellicott, he says, changed L'Enfant's blueprint, and many of the men involved were Masons. On that reading, a missing Mason at the drawing board does not settle what the finished city became. Can a pattern seen from above be planned on the ground?