The first account
The story first reached the public in 1917, in a profile of the banker Paul Warburg by the financial journalist B.C. Forbes. "After a journey hedged with the utmost secrecy, the party were landed in a small boat at the deserted Jekyl Island, off Georgia." Senator Nelson Aldrich "was to keep them on Jekyl Island, cut off from the rest of the world, until they had evolved and compiled a scientific currency system for the United States." Then, "as quietly as they had left, the authors of the epochal Aldrich report disappeared from Jekyl Island and slipped into New York undetected."
The documented record
The Federal Reserve's own history site confirms the core of the story. "In November 1910, six men," Senator Aldrich and five companions, "met at the Jekyll Island Club ... to write a plan to reform the nation's banking system. The meeting and its purpose were closely guarded secrets, and participants did not admit that the meeting occurred until the 1930s." On the train "the men used only first names," and "for decades after, the group referred to themselves as the 'First Name Club.'"
The denial
According to the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond, few people noticed Forbes's account, and those who did "dismissed it as 'a mere yarn,'" as Aldrich's biographer put it. "The participants themselves denied the meeting had occurred for 20 years." In 1930 three of them, A. Piatt Andrew, Frank Vanderlip and Paul Warburg, finally told the story to Aldrich's biographer. The likely spur was Carter Glass's 1927 memoir, which claimed credit for the Federal Reserve Act.
Why the secrecy
Georgia Trend, writing about the Atlanta Fed in 2006, gave the reason: "Jekyll was chosen because it offered complete privacy and there wasn't a reporter within 50 miles. The senator wanted to keep it quiet because if the U.S. Congress found out that the Wall Street crowd was involved, the plan wouldn't have a chance." The magazine adds: "The Aldrich plan was eventually scrapped, but the central bank concept was not."
The economist's reading
The economist Murray Rothbard told the story in sharper terms in 1999. Aldrich and "a handful of companions" left Hoboken on November 22, 1910, in "a privately chartered railroad car." "The cover story released to the press was that this was a simple duck-hunting expedition," and "the attendees addressed each other only by first name." Rothbard calls the group "the financial power elite." He argues that "there was very little substantive difference between the Aldrich and Glass bills," and concludes that the Fed was "a governmentally created and sanctioned cartel device."
What became law
The Aldrich Plan itself did not pass. The Democrats made "repudiating the Aldrich plan a part of their platform." But the Federal Reserve History essay notes that the final 1913 law's features "closely resembled those of the Aldrich Plan," and that "the major differences were the political and decision-making structures, which was a compromise."
The modern legend
G. Edward Griffin's 1994 book The Creature from Jekyll Island retold the 1910 meeting and argued that the Fed should be abolished. Reason editor Jesse Walker told The Daily Beast: "The meeting happened, there was a meeting at Jekyll Island, and it did play a formative role," but stories like Griffin's "try to reduce it to a single incident." Griffin's answer, in 2004: "There is nothing about my work that merits being classified as a conspiracy theory."
The believers' answer
Believers say the plan lived on in the Fed. The bill that failed in Congress, they argue, came back under another name with most of its features intact, and the men who wrote it hid the trip for twenty years. Why hide a duck hunt?