The founding and the Tomb
Skull and Bones was founded at Yale in 1832. Writing in the Yale Alumni Magazine in 2015, David Richards, whom the editors list as a member of the Class of 1967, traces it to "the 1833 valedictorian, class orator, and secretary of Phi Beta Kappa, William Huntington Russell," joined by Alphonso Taft, father of a future president. The editors note that his article draws entirely on publicly available sources.
The society's building on High Street in New Haven, known as the Tomb, "was built in 1856, and a tomb is what it resembled": "a single forbidding, windowless block in Egypto-Doric style." To make the society permanent, the founders incorporated it "in the State of Connecticut as a trust; they called it the Russell Trust Association."
The claims and the symbols
Theories about the society run wide. As the New England Historical Society puts it, "Some people believe Skull and Bones controls the CIA, while others think it's a branch of the Illuminati." The number 322 on its insignia "is said to refer to 322 B.C., when Athens lost the Lamian War." The society also owns Deer Island in the St. Lawrence River. In 2009, the society reports, descendants of Geronimo sued Skull and Bones over his remains, and "the court dismissed the case."
The believers' reading
The fullest case comes from Antony C. Sutton's book America's Secret Establishment: An Introduction to the Order of Skull & Bones. A 2024 review from his publisher, TrineDay, says the book, "breaking 170 years of secrecy," shows how members "influenced American education and politics by introducing influential philosophical ideas," among them Wilhelm Wundt's psychology and "the dialectical philosophy of Georg Wilhelm Friedrich Hegel."
Business professor Mitchell Langbert, reviewing Sutton in 2012, found the book useful but wrote that "he overstates its importance."
The 1991 fight
The best documented story about the society is a quieter one. According to the Yale Daily News, "The Skull and Bones Class of 1991 circumvented the organization's leadership and tapped seven female members. They returned to the tomb soon after to discover the locks on the building had been changed." A mail vote by most living members "resulted in a 368-320 majority in favor of going co-ed," and in October "the society voted 387-327 to accept the tap class of 1992."
The Los Angeles Times reported in October 1991 that the society had decided to accept women. It wrote that "Members ratified the decision on a 368-320 vote," and that the initiation included "six women and nine men." The two papers place the 368 to 320 vote at different stages.
The believers' answer
Believers answer in the words of Sutton's publisher: the society is "far from being a campus fraternity" and is "primarily concerned with securing the success of its members in the post-collegiate world." A lifelong network of members, they say, is exactly what a windowless building on a college street would be built to protect. Is the Tomb a clubhouse or a crossroads of power?