The first report
In 1952 Albert K. Bender of Bridgeport, Connecticut, founded the International Flying Saucer Bureau. It grew to about 600 members and published a magazine, Space Review. Then, in the autumn of 1953, it stopped.
On November 22, 1953, the Bridgeport Sunday Herald reported that the bureau "has been ordered, apparently by the government, to cease its activities." Gray Barker reprinted the story in The Saucerian Bulletin that December. Bender had told members that a "higher authority" which he was "not privileged to name" had instructed the bureau to drop all references to flying saucers. "Three men wearing dark suits" came to his home, "flashed credentials showing them to be representatives of the 'higher authority,'" took "five copies of each issue," and told him, "not roughly, but sternly and emphatically," to stop publishing. Barker added that he himself could learn no more.
Bender's account
The Bridgeport History Center at the city's public library preserves Bender's own description: "All of them were dressed in black clothes. They looked like clergymen but wore hats similar to [the] Homburg style." In his later telling, the visitors spoke to him telepathically, with the message "Stop publishing." He told the full story in his 1962 book Flying Saucers and the Three Men.
The earlier thread
There was an earlier figure in black. In the 1947 Maury Island story, Harold Dahl said that the morning after his sighting, "a man in a black suit" took him to breakfast and described his experience in detail. History.com notes that a government investigation rejected the Maury Island story after Dahl and his partner Fred Crisman "later admitted as much." Barker linked that figure to Bender's three visitors. The ufologist Nick Redfern says Bender "almost single-handedly ushered in the plague of the Men in Black."
The book
Barker turned Bender's experience into a book, They Knew Too Much About Flying Saucers, in 1956. The Clarksburg-Harrison Public Library in West Virginia, which holds Barker's papers, describes it as "a dramatization of Albert Bender's meeting with three men dressed in black," and "a phenomenal success introducing both Barker and the Men in Black to popular culture."
The skeptic's reading
Writer Benjamin Radford, in Live Science in 2012, notes that Bender "offered no evidence of his encounter, and cynics noted that the magazine was losing money and likely would shut down soon anyway." Radford describes Barker as "an accomplished prankster" who, with the publisher James Moseley, produced a forged State Department letter, and says Barker later helped publish a fictional Men in Black story presented as true.
The believers' answer
Believers point to a document from 1967. A memo signed by Lieutenant General Hewitt T. Wheless and dated March 1, 1967, titled "Impersonations of Air Force Officers," is reproduced from Jenny Randles's 1997 book The Truth Behind the Men in Black. It says that information, "not verifiable," had reached Air Force headquarters that "persons claiming to represent the Air Force or other Defense establishments have contacted citizens who have sighted unidentified flying objects." Personnel, it says, "should immediately notify their local OSI offices." If the Air Force was warning its own officers, believers ask, who were the visitors? So who were the men in black?