The text
Every search for Atlantis starts with Plato. In the Timaeus, the character Critias repeats a story Solon heard from Egyptian priests. A great power advanced "from a distant point in the Atlantic ocean," and in front of "the pillars of Heracles" lay an island "larger than Libya and Asia together." Then "one grievous day and night" came, and the island "was swallowed up by the sea and vanished," leaving the sea "blocked up by the shoal mud."
In the Critias, nine thousand years have passed since that war. Poseidon's island has a plain bordering the sea, with "a mountain that was low on all sides" about fifty stades from its centre. Around it the god made "circular belts of sea and land enclosing one another alternately," two of land and three of sea.
This is Plato's story, told by one of his characters. Scholars disagree on whether he meant it as history. For the wider tradition of lost continents, see Atlantis, Lemuria, and Mu.
Bimini
The Association for Research and Enlightenment (A.R.E.), founded around the readings of the psychic Edgar Cayce, says Cayce placed Atlantis "from the Gulf of Mexico to Gibraltar" and "referred to Bimini as one of the mountaintops of ancient Atlantis."
One reading is central. In Reading 958-3, given in Virginia Beach on June 28, 1940, Cayce said, as transcribed at archive.edgarcayce.ch: "And Poseidia will be among the first portions of Atlantis to rise again. Expect it in sixty-eight and sixty-nine ('68 and '69); not so far away!" The reading names Poseidia, not Bimini. Linking it to Bimini was the work of the A.R.E. and later authors.
Bimini, the geology
Off North Bimini, rows of flat limestone blocks lie in about fifteen feet of water. Geologist Eugene Shinn of the U.S. Geological Survey writes that they were found "in the early 1960s" by someone familiar with Cayce's predictions, and that the author J. Manson Valentine made the Cayce link in 1976.
Shinn's team took oriented cores from separate stones lying side by side. The layers in each stone dipped the same way, toward deep water, and bands of pebbles could be traced from one stone to the next, as in a single sheet of beachrock broken where it lay. The team found "no artifacts, no wheel ruts." Shinn records that believers continue to be drawn to the site, and names their published work, by Valentine, William Donato and Edgar Evans Cayce.
Spartel and southern Spain
A second candidate lies near the mouth of the Mediterranean. Physicist Rainer Kühne, in a 2004 note in the journal Antiquity, reports that the geologist Jacques Collina-Girard identified Atlantis with Spartel Island, 50 km west of the present Strait of Gibraltar and now 56 m under water. Plato's text places the sinking about 9,000 years before the dialogue.
Kühne questions the match. Even at the Late Glacial Maximum, he writes, Spartel was "only 14 by 5 kilometres," far smaller than Plato's plain of 3,000 by 2,000 stades. He proposes instead that Plato's story echoes the Sea Peoples of about 1200 BC and a place in southwest Spain. He points to two rectangular structures seen on satellite photos in the Marisma de Hinojos, in Doñana National Park, as possible remnants.
Other candidates
The search has ranged widely. The Richat Structure in Mauritania, with its rings, has its own page. Santorini and its Bronze Age eruption are covered on the Thera page; Robin McKie writes that the "serious money" is on Santorini. The drowned land of Doggerland in the North Sea, the underwater terraces of Yonaguni off Japan, and the wider flood traditions of The Great Deluge are all covered elsewhere in the Archive.
The modern revival
Writing for The Observer in 2022, science editor Robin McKie reported that Graham Hancock's series Ancient Apocalypse argues a sophisticated culture was destroyed by comet-triggered floods, "a disaster that inspired the legend of Atlantis," and that survivors spread their knowledge around the world. Archaeologists objected. McKie quotes archaeologist Flint Dibble: "It is simply that we strongly believe he is wrong." McKie also writes that Plato meant his tale as an allegory, and notes that suggested sites have "ranged from the Sahara to the Antarctic."
The adherents' answer
The A.R.E. holds to Cayce's reading. Before the end of the last Ice Age, it says, ocean levels "were at least 300 feet below their current levels," and "a vast 'island' was in the area in those remote times rather than chains of islands." Kühne, meanwhile, argues for his own site in Spain. Each seeker finds a different match. Which site, if any, fits all of Plato's text?