Exxon scientist James Black told the company's Management Committee in 1977 that carbon dioxide from fossil fuels was warming the climate and that decisions might be needed within a decade. Exxon funded its own research and models, which by 1982 agreed with the scientific consensus. By 1988 an internal memo urged the company to emphasize scientific uncertainty. InsideClimate News published the documents in 2015, and a 2023 Science study found Exxon's private warming projections had been largely accurate.
Exxon's scientists warned bosses in 1977 that fossil fuels would warm the planet, then Exxon sold the public doubt. That is the cover-up in one line. Inside the company, researchers briefed top management on carbon dioxide, built climate models, and reached answers that matched the scientific consensus. Outside, the company's public message moved toward doubt, and by 1988 an internal memo recommended that Exxon "emphasize the uncertainty." The documents surfaced in 2015 through reporting by InsideClimate News, and a 2023 study in Science measured how accurate the company's private projections had been. Why the gap? InsideClimate News, which first published the files, described the problem Exxon studied as one that "posed an existential threat to the oil business."
PublishedSep 23, 2026
The warning to management
In July 1977 James Black, a senior scientist in Exxon's research and engineering division, briefed the company's Management Committee using slides and no prepared text. A year later he gave an updated talk to a wider group and dictated a written version. The surviving package, dated 6 June 1978, says the first slide showed "general scientific agreement" that mankind's most likely influence on climate was carbon dioxide released by burning fossil fuels. It estimates that CO2 in the atmosphere had already risen 10 to 15 percent, that slightly more than half of the CO2 from fossil fuels stayed in the air, and that on one projection close to the company's own planning forecast, CO2 could peak around twice the normal level in 2075. Black's summary held that "man has a time window of five to ten years before the need for hard decisions regarding changes in energy strategies might become critical."
In September 2015 InsideClimate News began publishing a series built on Exxon's internal documents and interviews with former employees. Its first installment quoted Black telling management that "there is general scientific agreement" on the fossil fuel link and warning in 1978 that doubling CO2 would raise average global temperatures by 2 to 3 degrees Celsius and as much as 10 degrees at the poles. "Some countries would benefit but others would have their agricultural output reduced or destroyed," Black wrote. The series reported that Exxon responded within months with its own research program, including CO2 sampling at sea and climate modeling, that it curtailed the work toward the end of the 1980s, and that in the decades that followed it "worked instead at the forefront of climate denial."
In 1982 Exxon's environmental affairs staff circulated a technical review titled "CO2 'Greenhouse' Effect" to management. The primer summarizes the science of rising CO2, compares estimates of warming from a doubling of CO2 made with radiative-convective models, energy balance models, and general circulation models, and tabulates fossil fuel emissions out to the middle of the next century. It says that along with a temperature increase, other climate changes were expected, including an uneven global distribution of increased rainfall and increased evaporation, disturbances to the existing global water balance. It calls for research, including ice-core work, to pin down past CO2 levels and test the models.
A second InsideClimate News installment reported that by 1982 Exxon's own climate modeling had confirmed the mainstream science. It described company researchers who built and ran models in-house and reported that the head of the research effort wrote to colleagues that the results were in accord with the scientific consensus on the effect of more CO2 on climate. The question the series raised was not whether Exxon knew, but what it did with what it knew.
By August 1988, the year climate change became headline news, an internal memo by Exxon public affairs manager Joseph Carlson set out the company's position. Climate Files' summary says Carlson wrote that the greenhouse effect might be one of the most significant environmental issues of the 1990s and that the main greenhouse gases were by-products of fossil fuels, but that he described current climate models and data as unable to predict future effects. The memo's stated position was to "emphasize the uncertainty in scientific conclusions regarding the potential enhanced Greenhouse effect." The memo also lists the company's research partnerships, including Columbia University, the American Petroleum Institute, and the EPA.
In January 2023 Geoffrey Supran, Stefan Rahmstorf, and Naomi Oreskes published "Assessing ExxonMobil's global warming projections" in Science. The journal's summary says ExxonMobil had internal models that projected warming trajectories consistent with independent academic and government models, so that "what they understood about climate models thus contradicted what they led the public to believe." The study's background notes that 2015 reporting had found internal memos showing Exxon knew since the late 1970s that its products could lead to global warming with "dramatic environmental effects before the year 2050." The authors found most of the company's projections from 1977 to 2003 accurately forecast the warming that followed.
What was hidden was how much Exxon knew: briefings, a primer for managers, and models that agreed with the consensus. It was hidden by a public message that leaned on uncertainty, as the 1988 memo urged. The reason the documents themselves suggest is plain: the science pointed at the product the company sold.
As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. Some of these are sold by partners: we may earn a commission if you buy through their links, at no extra cost to you.