In the statements Yale published while the dispute was still open, the Machu Picchu collection was not described as a loan that had come due. It was described as a scientific holding. On 26 August 2008 the university said the pieces at the Peabody Museum of Natural History had been legally excavated and exported by Hiram Bingham in the early twentieth century, and that Yale’s interest was the continued ability of scholars to study and exhibit them. A memorandum with Peru was under discussion. Upon a definitive agreement, Yale said, it would acknowledge Peruvian title. Title, in that sentence, was something the signature would confer, not a duty the university already accepted. The same statement said that if Peru litigated, Yale would defend, and that litigation was not warranted. That is the denial this page has to name. Material dug from Peruvian ground could stay in New Haven, on Yale’s account, because the dig and the export had been lawful, unless a deal said otherwise.
A joint statement of 14 September 2007 had sketched one such deal and had not closed it. Peru and Yale announced a framework covering the Bingham material and wider research. Yale would acknowledge Peru’s title to all the excavated objects, including fragments, bones, and specimens. Peru would share research rights, and part of the research collection would remain at Yale. An international exhibition would be co-curated with Peru’s National Institute of Culture. The statement tied a new museum in Cusco to the centennial of what it called Bingham’s rediscovery of Machu Picchu. By August 2008 that framework was still not definitive. Yale said a Peruvian draft of April 2008 had departed from it. The objects stayed where they were.
The return that moved them was an accord, not a judgment set out on Yale’s pages. On 21 November 2010 the university announced an agreement with the government of Peru, then being formalized, under which Yale would return, over two years, the archaeological materials Bingham excavated at Machu Picchu. It called the return good will, and a recognition of what the site had come to mean for modern Peru. Pieces fit for display would go in time for the centennial of what that 2010 text calls the scientific discovery of Machu Picchu by the Yale-Peruvian Scientific Expedition of 1911. The noun shifts, from “rediscovery” in 2007 to “scientific discovery” in 2010. UNESCO’s text on the Historic Sanctuary draws the limit of either word: the complex was made known to the outside world in 1911, and a later section speaks of the rediscovery in 1911 and of the excavations and conservation that followed. “Outside world” is not “a city no one knew.” This page does not claim that Bingham found an unknown city empty of local knowledge, and it does not invent a court decree the accord notices do not contain.
Where the pieces went is in the 2011 papers. On 11 February 2011 Yale and the Universidad Nacional de San Antonio Abad del Cusco signed for the UNSAAC-Yale International Center for the Study of Machu Picchu and Inca Culture, after President Alan García asked that UNSAAC house the collection. The center was to stand in the Casa Concha, an Inca palace in Cusco, with a public exhibit on the Yale-Peruvian expeditions of 1911 and 1912 and on later work by both universities. Yale said a small number of objects would be loaned back for display at the Peabody. On 6 October 2011 the center opened. Provost Peter Salovey and Richard Burger were there with Peru’s minister of culture, Susana Baca, and the UNSAAC rector, Victor Raúl Aguilar. Yale’s account says the museum-quality artifacts kept at Yale since Bingham’s expeditions had been sent to Cusco, with some fragments, and that human and animal remains and ceramic fragments would follow in December 2011 and December 2012. Casa Concha is the address of the return. It is not a caption from a verdict.
Yale University, statement of 26 August 2008: https://news.yale.edu/2008/08/26/statement-yale-university.
Yale University and the Government of Peru, joint statement, 14 September 2007: https://news.yale.edu/2007/09/14/joint-statement-government-peru-and-yale-university.
Yale University, accord announced 21 November 2010: https://news.yale.edu/2010/11/21/statement-yale-university-regarding-machu-picchu-archaeological-materials.
Yale and UNSAAC, center agreed 11 February 2011: https://news.yale.edu/2011/02/11/yale-and-unsaac-create-center-promote-study-machu-picchu-and-inca-culture.
Opening of the center at Casa Concha, 6 October 2011: https://news.yale.edu/2011/10/06/peru-yale-center-study-machu-picchu-and-inca-culture-opens.
UNESCO World Heritage Centre, Historic Sanctuary of Machu Picchu: https://whc.unesco.org/en/list/274/.
The 2007 framework had already offered an acknowledgment of Peruvian title, with a share of the study collection staying at Yale for research. It did not, on the 2008 statement, become the signed end of the dispute. The 2010 accord is the paper Yale presents as the return, and the 2011 opening is the paper that says which objects had by then reached Cusco and which were still scheduled. A loan back to the Peabody, of a small number for display, is part of that arrangement. It is not the old claim that the whole collection could remain because export had been lawful. The site those objects came from is, on UNESCO’s wording, an Inca center made known to the outside world in 1911, built in the fifteenth century and abandoned after the Spanish conquest of the empire in the sixteenth. The return does not rest on calling Bingham the first human being to see it.
What Documented Settles
Settled on Yale’s notices and on UNESCO’s site text: Bingham’s expeditions supplied a collection long held at the Peabody; Yale’s 2008 position treated that holding as legally excavated and exported, with Peruvian title to be acknowledged only in a definitive deal; a 2010 accord, not a judgment published on these pages, promised return over two years; by October 2011 museum-quality pieces were at the Casa Concha center run with UNSAAC, with further material due in December 2011 and December 2012. Still not a fact of these papers is a court order compelling the boxes, or a claim that the city was unknown to everyone but the expedition.

