From 1975 through 1989 Rockwell International ran Rocky Flats for the Department of Energy, and the largest part of its pay was a semiannual award fee based on DOE’s rating of performance, including environmental, safety, and health. The search-warrant affidavit later alleged those fees rested on “excellent” management while pondcrete was insolid and statements to regulators were false. On 6 June 1989 the FBI and EPA raided the plant. In 1992 Rockwell pleaded guilty to ten environmental violations and paid $18.5 million. A special grand jury wanted a public report naming people who were not indicted. Career supervisors barred that report. The plea closed the case without those indictments. This page does not turn site measurements into a plutonium cloud over downtown Denver.
What the Fee and the Warrant Said
The 2007 opinion in Rockwell International Corp. v. United States recounts the contract in a False Claims Act case. Engineer James Stone worked there from November 1980 through March 1986 and in June 1987 told the FBI of environmental crimes: a ban on discussing controversies in front of a DOE employee, an incinerator left on line, groundwater he believed contaminated, lagoons that overflowed. On 6 June 1989, the opinion states, 75 FBI and EPA agents raided on a warrant based in part on that information. The affidavit alleged insolid pondcrete, award fees for “excellent” management, and false statements under RCRA and 18 U.S.C. § 1001. In March 1992 Rockwell pleaded guilty to ten environmental violations, including knowing storage of insolid pondcrete, and agreed to pay $18.5 million. Rockwell knew of a substantial number of insolid blocks by October 1986. DOE learned in May 1988, when blocks leaked. They are recitals about an original source, not a city release.
Supreme Court — Rockwell Int’l Corp. v. United States, 549 U.S. 457 (2007): https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/USREPORTS-549/pdf/USREPORTS-549-457.pdf
Why the Jurors’ Report Stayed Sealed
On 21 April 1994 Justice published an internal review, summarized in the United States Attorneys’ Bulletin. It found no basis for charges that the prosecutions were mishandled, and it found that barring a grand-jury report condemning certain employees was appropriate and in good faith. The 88-page review, supervised by Mark Dubester, Acting Chief of Public Corruption and Government Fraud in the District of Columbia, was requested by then-Associate Attorney General Webster Hubbell on 21 July 1993 after a House subcommittee criticized prosecutors for the size of the fine, for not charging workers, and for not letting jurors accuse people who were not indicted. The Bulletin records ten hazardous-waste and clean-water violations and an $18.5 million penalty, called there the largest hazardous-waste fine in history. Counts include sludge storage, unpermitted transfers, an improper discharge, and other 1987 and 1988 violations. Rockwell had offered no contest and a $1 million fine. The plea taken was reviewed by the Department, the U.S. Attorney’s office, EPA, and the Colorado Department of Health. Not charging individuals was called sound discretion: no conspiratorial meetings, no document destruction, no personal financial motive. Possible defendants were low-level workers a jury might see as scapegoats for DOE, and managers who may not specifically have intended the violations. The plant manager had died in 1990. One DOE official’s 1985 statement that groundwater monitoring was in full compliance was not charged, because EPA did not rely on it. Rockwell agreed not to bill the fine back to DOE. The chance a taxpayer would repay a fine was, the Bulletin says, perhaps the main reason to settle. A judge later released substantial portions of the proposed report. The version that would have named uncharged people is the one supervisors barred.
DOJ — United States Attorneys’ Bulletin, 15 May 1994, Rocky Flats review: https://www.justice.gov/sites/default/files/usao/legacy/2010/10/12/usab4205.pdf
What the Measurements on the Site Actually Say
EPA’s July 2002 five-year review dates the raid the same day and counts it differently: some 80 FBI and EPA agents, a warrant in the District of Colorado, alleging criminal violations of RCRA and the Federal Water Pollution Control Act. This page does not average 75 and 80. The plant went on the National Priorities List on 21 September 1989. The review’s releases stay on the site. A fire on 11 September 1957 in building 771 released some plutonium to the environment. In 1967, leaking drums on the 903 Pad contaminated soil with plutonium, lubricants, and solvents. In 1968–1970 soil became wind-borne and settled near the lip, and an asphalt cap covered the most contaminated area. A glovebox fire in buildings 776/777 followed in May 1969. In September 1973 an EPA report said 50 to 100 curies of tritium reached Great Western Reservoir via Woman Creek. That is the measurement. It is not a plutonium cloud over downtown Denver.
EPA — Rocky Flats five-year review, July 2002: https://semspub.epa.gov/work/08/61084.pdf
How DOE Described the Contract and the Raid
DOE’s Legacy Management history places the site about 16 miles northwest of downtown Denver. Contracts were cost-reimbursable, with profit on subjective ratings, and contractors protected from most financial risks. Dow ran the plant from 1951 to 1975; Rockwell from 1975 to 1989. The 6 June 1989 entry records some 80 FBI and EPA agents until 26 June. Nuclear operations stopped and Rockwell was replaced by EG&G. After more than two years of grand-jury investigation, the page states, Rockwell pleaded guilty and paid $18.5 million.
DOE — Rocky Flats site history: https://www.energy.gov/lm/articles/rocky-flats-site-colorado-history-documents
The Congressional Request, and the Review’s Later FOIA Status
GAO’s page for RCED-89-53BR says that, answering a congressional request, GAO summarized the major environmental, safety, and health problems at DOE’s Rocky Flats plant, the focal point for DOE plutonium operations. The highlights do not list the problems. This file does not invent the list.
The Justice Department’s FOIA Post for January–March 2001 summarizes Rockwell International Corp. v. Department of Justice, 235 F.3d 598 (D.C. Cir. 2001). The internal review of the prosecution was held not to be a FOIA “final opinion,” because propriety of the prosecution was neither a case nor an adjudication. Exemption 5 was not waived when attachments went to a subcommittee, nor when the Department quoted them in a dispute with Congress.
GAO — RCED-89-53BR, Rocky Flats environmental, safety, and health problems: https://www.gao.gov/products/rced-89-53br
DOJ OIP — FOIA Post, January–March 2001 (Rockwell v. Department of Justice): https://www.justice.gov/archive/oip/foiapost/2001foiapost6.htm
What the Paper Trail Settles
Documented: an award fee tied to environmental performance; a 6 June 1989 warrant alleging insolid pondcrete, “excellent” management, and false statements; a 1992 plea to ten counts and $18.5 million without the individual indictments the grand jury wanted; a 1994 review that defended sealing the jurors’ accusations; site measurements of a 1957 plutonium release, wind-borne soil near the 903 lip, and 50 to 100 curies of tritium to Great Western Reservoir. Not on these doors: a downtown Denver plutonium cloud. Institutions are Rockwell and DOE. People appear by office. The Archive files the raid, the sealed report, and the plea as documented / L1.