International telegrams were copied for the government, and the public was not told. The Senate staff report dates the copies from August 1945 until May 1975. Book II calls the arrangement secret and dates its tally from 1947 to 1975. On 6 November 1975 the chairman read a statement the committee had voted to release. NSA's version in the Ford Library calls the same turnover national-security support and says the companies were not designing access to private citizen traffic. Only the figures those doors print are used here.
The Staff Report's Account
The supplementary staff report says SHAMROCK is the codename for a program in which NSA received copies of most international telegrams leaving the United States between August 1945 and May 1975. RCA Global and ITT World Communications provided virtually all their international message traffic. Western Union International provided copies of certain foreign traffic from 1945 until 1972. The report calls the program probably the largest governmental interception program affecting Americans ever undertaken. The total number of telegrams read across the whole span is not available. NSA estimated that in the last two or three years about 150,000 telegrams a month were reviewed by analysts.
The report says the program did not require special technology. Copies were turned over at the offices of three cable companies. NSA obtained no search warrant before obtaining a telegram. Company attorneys advised against participation. A March 1946 Army letter quoted there says Western Union and RCA had put themselves in precarious positions because legality was not established, and that only two or three people in each company knew of the operation.
On the Attorney General the report is narrower than the story the companies were told. New documents did not reveal that Attorney General Tom C. Clark actually gave the 1945 assurances the companies wanted, even though ITT and Western Union had begun by 1 September 1945 and RCA by 9 October 1945. On 16 December 1947 Secretary of Defense James Forrestal, speaking for the President, assured ITT and RCA they would not be prosecuted, and warned he could not bind successors. In 1949 Secretary Louis Johnson told the companies the President and the Attorney General had been consulted and had approved.
Book II's opening tally uses different dates. It says millions of private telegrams sent from, to, or through the United States were obtained by NSA from 1947 to 1975 under a secret arrangement with three United States telegraph companies.
Senate Select Committee, Book III, supplementary staff reports: https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/sites-default-files-94755-iii.pdf
Senate Select Committee, Book II, Intelligence Activities and the Rights of Americans: https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/sites-default-files-94755-ii.pdf
The Hearing of 6 November 1975
Chairman Frank Church told the public session that the committee had voted on 3 November, seven to three, to disclose the program, after a check that the statement would not reveal a sensitive method. He said no particular technology was involved. It was a turnover of telegraph traffic. The statement Church then read says the government persuaded RCA Global, ITT World Communications, and Western Union International to make traffic available. For almost 30 years, copies of most international telegrams originating in or forwarded through the United States went to NSA and its predecessors. The companies knew they were turning over most international telegrams, including those of citizens and organizations. The statement says the government did not tell the companies it was selecting citizens. There is no evidence they asked what was done with the material.
In 1947 Forrestal assured the companies there would be no criminal liability and no public exposure while that administration held office, and that the work was in the highest interests of national security. They were told President Truman and Attorney General Clark approved. No authorizing legislation was introduced. The 1949 renewal under Louis Johnson is in the statement, and so is the conclusion that assurances were not sought again after 1949. The statement estimates that in recent years NSA selected about 150,000 messages a month for analysts, that about 90 percent of collected messages came from New York, and that NSA never received domestic telegrams from these companies. Tordella's testimony, as read there, is that no president since Truman had been informed, so far as he knew. SHAMROCK was terminated by order of the Secretary of Defense on 15 May 1975.
Hearings, Volume 5, NSA and Fourth Amendment rights, 6 November 1975: https://www.intelligence.senate.gov/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/sites-default-files-94intelligence-activities-v.pdf
The Ford Library Files
One Ford Library folder preserves a text headed as NSA's version. It says private companies provided substantial telegraphed information from World War II through the Korean period, the Cold War, and the Southeast Asian wars, asked for at the highest levels and freely given. The firms did not know the use, and had an assurance the use was national security. Nothing the companies did, it says, was designed to give NSA private citizen communications. The same folder says NSA was prepared to testify about one method of collecting international commercial traffic discontinued in May 1975, called Shamrock, and about watch lists from 1967 to 1973 that contained names of United States citizens. The letter says the Department of Justice joined that statement.
A second folder distinguishes a cable from a telex. The transcript says the Church committee's Shamrock report addressed cable interception and did not mention telex. It repeats the termination date of 15 May 1975. It then records a suggestion, offered as circumstantial, that collection under another name might have continued by means that did not use the cable companies. That is a suggestion in the transcript. The committee statement records a termination order. The suggestion is not a finding that a successor program existed.
A third folder notes that the Senate Select Committee released its Shamrock report on 6 November 1975 and that the report confirmed the three major international carriers had turned over copies of most international telegrams with a United States terminal, with about 150,000 messages a month selected for review.
Ford Library, Loen and Leppert files, General (1): https://www.fordlibrarymuseum.gov/sites/default/files/pdf_documents/library/document/0014/1075847.pdf
Ford Library, hearings transcripts (1): https://www.fordlibrarymuseum.gov/sites/default/files/pdf_documents/library/document/0014/1075848.pdf
Ford Library, General (4): https://www.fordlibrarymuseum.gov/sites/default/files/pdf_documents/library/document/0014/21619432.pdf
What the Paper Trail Settles
Documented: copies of international telegrams moved from the named carriers to NSA and its predecessors; the public was not told, and the 1947 assurance included no public exposure; the hearing dates termination by the Secretary of Defense to 15 May 1975; the later-year analyst figure in the staff report, the hearing, and the Ford Library note of the report is about 150,000 a month. Book II's summary window is 1947 to 1975. The staff report's window is August 1945 to May 1975.