For years the VA denied that Agent Orange made Vietnam veterans sick, until Congress wrote the link into law in 1991. The fight over Agent Orange was a fight over proof. The United States sprayed millions of gallons of herbicide over Vietnam, and one of its two ingredients carried a dioxin contaminant called TCDD. When veterans came home with cancers, nerve damage, and children with birth defects, the government said the science did not show a connection and denied their claims. The study meant to settle the question was run by the same service that did the spraying. It took a law in 1991, and another in 2019 for sailors offshore, to turn denial into benefits.
The spraying, and the first claims
The Department of Veterans Affairs' own historian tells the origin story plainly. Agent Orange was the most common of the "Rainbow Herbicides" used during Operation Ranch Hand, a 50:50 mix of 2,4-D and 2,4,5-T, the latter contaminated with TCDD. It cleared jungle cover and destroyed farmland the enemy relied on. Ranch Hand ran from 1962 until 1971, and by its end Agent Orange alone accounted for 11.22 million of the more than 18 million gallons of herbicide sprayed in Southeast Asia.
By the late 1970s veterans were blaming herbicides for chronic fatigue, vision loss, numbness, cancer, and birth defects in their children. The VA was receiving claims at least as early as 1977. At the time only chloracne, a rare skin condition, had been scientifically linked to dioxin, so when veterans tied any other illness to herbicides, the VA denied their medical claims, citing a lack of scientific evidence. The department set up an Agent Orange Registry in 1978, an advisory committee in 1979, and a series of task forces, but most studies in the 1980s maintained there was no link. In 1990 studies by the CDC and the VA's advisory committee found non-Hodgkin's lymphoma and soft tissue sarcomas "at least as likely as not" connected to herbicide exposure, and Secretary Edward Derwinski classified each as service-connected the day after its release.
VA History, "The Origins of the Agent Orange Act of 1991": https://department.va.gov/history/the-origins-of-the-agent-orange-act-of-1991/
A study run by the sprayers
The government's main long-term study was the Air Force's Ranch Hand study, begun in 1982, which compared the men who flew the spray missions with Air Force personnel who served in Southeast Asia but did not spray. In 2000 the General Accounting Office told Congress the study "has been controversial" since its start: reviewers worried the public would not find it credible "because the Air Force, which conducted the spraying of herbicides in Vietnam, would also conduct the study." The GAO found delays in the dissemination of some results, limited public access to detailed data, inadequate communication of the study's limitations, failure to implement some measures meant to ensure rigor and independence, and insufficient outreach to veterans. Those problems, it said, led critics to question the study's openness and credibility. It also found that, partly because of statistical limits, the study had had little impact on compensation decisions.
GAO testimony T-NSIAD-00-117, "Agent Orange: Persisting Problems With Communication of Ranch Hand Study Data and Results" (2000): https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/GAOREPORTS-T-NSIAD-00-117/html/GAOREPORTS-T-NSIAD-00-117.htm
The 1991 law
On 6 February 1991 the Agent Orange Act became Public Law 102-4. It created a presumption of service connection: a veteran who served in the Republic of Vietnam during the Vietnam era and developed non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, a soft-tissue sarcoma (other than osteosarcoma, chondrosarcoma, Kaposi's sarcoma, or mesothelioma), or chloracne to a degree of disability of 10 percent or more would be treated as having incurred it in service, "notwithstanding that there is no record of evidence of such disease during the period of such service." The law also directed the Secretary to obtain independent scientific review of the evidence on diseases and exposure to dioxin and other herbicide compounds, the reviews the National Academy of Sciences has done since.
Public Law 102-4, Agent Orange Act of 1991 (105 Stat. 11): https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/STATUTE-105/pdf/STATUTE-105-Pg11.pdf
The sailors left out
The 1991 presumption covered service "in the Republic of Vietnam," and sailors on ships offshore pressed for decades to be counted. Congress closed the gap with the Blue Water Navy Vietnam Veterans Act of 2019, which extended the presumption to veterans who served on vessels within a defined distance of the coast of Vietnam and Cambodia during the war, and set rules for retroactive claims and benefits for survivors.
Public Law 116-23, Blue Water Navy Vietnam Veterans Act of 2019: https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/PLAW-116publ23/html/PLAW-116publ23.htm
Where exposure is now presumed
The VA's current list of exposure locations shows how far the presumption has moved. It presumes exposure for service on land in Vietnam, on inland waterways, or on vessels not more than 12 nautical miles seaward of the demarcation line, between 9 January 1962 and 7 May 1975, as defined by the 2019 act. It presumes exposure for units along the Korean demilitarized zone from 1 September 1967 to 31 August 1971 and for service on any US or Royal Thai military base in Thailand from 9 January 1962 through 30 June 1976. It also lists possible exposure for C-123 aircraft crews and for herbicide tests and storage sites, including locations added by the PACT Act.
VA Public Health, "Agent Orange Exposure Locations": https://www.publichealth.va.gov/exposures/agentorange/locations/index.asp
The conditions on the list
The VA's eligibility page now lists presumptive cancers including bladder cancer, chronic B-cell leukemia, Hodgkin's disease, multiple myeloma, non-Hodgkin's lymphoma, prostate cancer, respiratory cancers, and some soft tissue sarcomas. Other presumptive illnesses include AL amyloidosis, chloracne, type 2 diabetes, high blood pressure, hypothyroidism, ischemic heart disease, MGUS, Parkinsonism, Parkinson's disease, early-onset peripheral neuropathy, and porphyria cutanea tarda. Veterans with these conditions, it says, "don't need to prove" the illness began in service.
VA, "Agent Orange exposure and disability compensation": https://www.va.gov/disability/eligibility/hazardous-materials-exposure/agent-orange/
What was denied, and why
What was denied was a link between herbicide and illness. The VA's stated reason was a lack of scientific evidence, and the chief study of that evidence was run by the Air Force, which had done the spraying. The list of three diseases in 1991 has since grown to more than a dozen.
