Browse and search the complete archive of documented theories and reports
For decades, people in Florida have reported a large, hairy, upright animal with a strong smell, most often in the Everglades. Smithsonian dates one of the earliest well-publicised claims to two hunters in 1957 and the name "skunk ape" to the 1960s; Mental Floss says sightings peaked in the 1960s and 1970s. In 1977 Representative Paul Nuckolls of Fort Myers introduced House Bill 1664 to make it a misdemeanor to "take, possess, harm or molest anthropoid or humanoid animals"; Mental Floss says it passed committee and was withdrawn before a House vote, but the Florida Department of State says it "failed to pass." His House Bill 58, "The Florida Skunk Ape Protection Act," passed the House Criminal Justice Committee on 13 October 1977 and died without passing (Florida Department of State; the State Archives of Florida dates its record to 1978). In January 2001 the Sarasota County Sheriff's Office logged an anonymous letter with two photographs of an animal that had taken apples from a porch; the writer asked, "Is someone missing an orangutan?" Adherents read the reports as a real primate: Dave Shealy says he first saw one in 1974, has seen them three other times, and filmed one in July 2000. A National Park Service officer said there has never been "a substantiated sighting" verified by its wildlife staff, Sharon Hill called the evidence "extremely weak," and Smithsonian writes that there is no fossil evidence that the extinct mega-apes some believers cite ever lived in the Americas. Adherents answer that the swamp covers 2.2 million acres, most of it rarely visited, where remains decompose quickly, and Shealy says, "I know what I've seen." Loren Coleman told the Sarasota Herald-Tribune, "Maybe it's a breeding population of unknown apes."
Traditions of Himalayan peoples speak of large wild beings in the high country. Atlas Obscura, drawing on Desmond Doig in the 1962 book High in the Thin Cold Air, records a Sherpa classification of dzu-teh, mih-teh and thelma, and says belief can be traced to pre-Buddhist religions. In 1951 Eric Shipton photographed a footprint found by Michael Ward on the Menlung glacier. A 1947 Nepali memo, republished by the United States embassy in 1959, required a permit for a yeti hunt. Edmund Hillary's Silver Hut expedition of 1960 to 1961 examined tracks, a "yeti hand" at Pangboche, skins, and one of three monastery scalps. Adherents read such tracks and relics as signs of an unknown animal; the Nature Conservancy notes the wilderness seemed vast enough for that to be plausible. Hillary's party judged the prints distended by the sun, the hand most likely human, the skins Tibetan blue bear and the scalp probably serow skin. In 2014 Sykes and colleagues matched two Himalayan hair samples, from Ladakh and Bhutan, most closely to a Palaeolithic polar bear, and a Nepal sample to a serow. In 2017 Lan and colleagues, with Charlotte Lindqvist as senior author, found that eight of nine purported yeti samples came from native bears and one from a dog; Lindqvist said the results "refute" the polar-bear finding. Adherents answer that the 2017 study tested only nine samples.
Skeptoid traces the story to 1955, when an unnamed businessman reportedly saw three figures three to four feet tall by a road in Loveland, standing upright, with leathery skin and frog-like faces; Cincinnati Magazine says "several three-foot-tall creatures." At 1 a.m. on 3 March 1972 a Loveland police officer reported a creature three to four feet tall crossing Riverside Drive, which stood erect and climbed over the guardrail toward the Little Miami River. Two weeks later a second officer reported a similar creature and fired at it (Skeptoid). Skeptoid reports it could not find any articles from the time in the Loveland Herald or Cincinnati Enquirer online archives, or anything in the police department's report archives, and notes such records may not have been digitised. Every source cited here was published decades after the sightings. Adherents read the sightings as an amphibious creature living along the river. In August 2016 the second officer told WCPO it was a large iguana about 3 or 3.5 feet long, missing its tail; WCPO reports that it crawled under the guardrail instead of walking upright. He said he shot it and put the body in his trunk to show the first officer. Skeptoid also points to the film Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954), released the year before the first sighting. Adherents answer that the iguana account came more than 40 years later, and that the first officer described a creature that stood erect and climbed the guardrail.
In the forests of Sumatra, especially around Kerinci Seblat National Park, people report a ground-dwelling ape that walks upright, 80 to 150 cm tall (detik, 2023), powerfully built, with black or honey-coloured hair (Guardian, 2011). It has many local names, among them gugu, sedapa and sebaba, and in 1918 the Dutch colonial official L.C. Westenenk recorded a 1910 encounter. Debbie Martyr began searching in the late 1980s; with photographer Jeremy Holden she ran a search funded by Fauna and Flora International from 1995, which the Guardian calls 15 years long and detik calls a 3-year project. A National Geographic-funded camera-trap project from 2005 to 2009 found nothing (detik). Adherents read the reports as an unknown ape: the expedition leader Richard Freeman wrote in the Guardian in 2011, "I believe the orang pendek is a great ape closely related to the orang-utan." A 2014 genetic study in Proceedings of the Royal Society B (Sykes and colleagues) identified a hair sample submitted as orang pendek from Sumatra as Malayan tapir. A review for the International Institute for Asian Studies of anthropologist Gregory Forth's 2008 book says he argues the claims may partly or entirely relate to sightings of orangutans, gibbons, sun bears or Kubu hunter-gatherers, while keeping an open mind about an unknown primate. Adherents answer that a hair expert judged earlier hairs to be from an undocumented primate, as Freeman reports, and that Holden says he saw an upright animal 7 metres away in October 1994.
About 10:30 p.m. on 21 April 1977 a 17-year-old driving on Farm Street in Dover saw a creature by a stone wall: "It looked like a baby's body with long arms and legs," with a melon-shaped head and glowing orange eyes (Cellar Walls, summarising Joseph Nyman's 1978 investigation report). About two hours later a 15-year-old walking home on Miller Hill Road saw a small figure with a large head, and the next night another 15-year-old reported one crouched by a bridge, with bright green eyes. Loren Coleman named it the Dover Demon and investigated with Joseph Nyman, Ed Fogg and Walter Webb; Boston television, the Associated Press and UPI covered it (MetroWest Daily News, 2021). Adherents read it as an unknown creature: Coleman told MetroWest that the eyewitnesses were credible and the three sightings followed a meandering stream. A retired Dover police sergeant said the department thought it a prank and that, if the teens saw something, it could have been "a raccoon with mange"; MetroWest calls a young moose "the most popular theory" (MetroWest). Joe Nickell (Skeptical Inquirer, July/August 2023) argues it was a snowy owl, though he grants the reported height is too great for one. Adherents answer, with Coleman, that a yearling moose would weigh 500 to 600 pounds, far more than described, and that the creature walked on two feet; and the first witness, now an adult, still says, "What I saw, it did happen."
In summer 1988 a 17-year-old driver said that, as he changed a flat tire at about 2 a.m. near Scape Ore Swamp, four miles south of Bishopville, a creature "green, wet-like, about 7 feet tall" with red eyes and "skin like a lizard" chased and damaged his car (UPI, 19 July 1988). The city of Bishopville says he passed a polygraph and that the sheriff and deputies took it seriously. A deputy heard talk of the creature for about three weeks; two men said it chased them from a spring, and a couple found their car battered. Deputies found three-toed prints and the sheriff had plaster casts made. By mid-August the story had been on the CBS Evening News (Charleston City Paper), and the sheriff's office was answering hundreds of calls from as far away as Japan and New Zealand (City of Bishopville). Adherents read it as a large unknown animal: Erik Beckjord of the National Cryptozoological Society told UPI, "You can call it anything you want to, but it's a Bigfoot." Sheriff Liston Truesdale said he thought the tracks were a prankster's work, and that the teenager saw something that was probably a bear; in August he said there was "no such thing" as a Lizard Man, and also "We've had too many reliable people telling us they've seen something" (UPI, 27 July and 12 August 1988). Adherents answer that the first witness passed a polygraph, and that other residents kept reporting the creature and damaged cars.
In the summer of 1995, livestock found dead in rural Puerto Rico, with throat wounds and seemingly drained of blood, were blamed on a "goat sucker," the chupacabra. That August a Canóvanas woman described a spiny-backed, large-eyed creature in her mother's yard, and over 200 reports followed on the island (Texas Observer). In 2000 a hairless canine carcass in Nicaragua was tied to the name, and carcasses turned up in Texas in 2004, 2007 and 2009. In July 2007 a Texas rancher and her neighbours found three carcasses near her ranch in Cuero (BBC). Adherents read the drained livestock as the work of a blood-drinking predator, which early reports described as an escaped genetics experiment or an alien. Biologist Mike Forstner at Texas State University said "the DNA sequence is a virtually identical match to DNA from the coyote" (BBC, 3 November 2007). Benjamin Radford traces the first description to the film Species, released on 7 July 1995, which he says the first witness had seen, and told Live Science that necropsies of the attacked chickens and goats "all had normal blood levels." Adherents answer with the rancher's words, "I have now done DNA at five different universities... They do not match any animal in the archive," and with the then mayor of Canóvanas, who said in 2011 that a church pastor and a police officer were among other witnesses.
On Sunday 4 August 1577 a violent storm struck the Suffolk churches at Bungay and Blythburgh. Abraham Fleming's pamphlet A straunge and terrible Wunder (1577) reports that "a dog as they might discerne it, of a black colour" appeared in the Bungay church, passed between two kneeling people and "wrung the necks of them bothe," leaving "the marks as it were of his clawes or talans" in the stones and the church door. Fleming says the same shape entered the church at "Blibery" (Blythburgh) that day and "slew two men and a lad." The Blythburgh church's history says lightning "cleft the door," leaving scorch marks on the north door called the fingerprints of the Devil. A Suffolk County Council parish record lists the storm killing 2 and burning about 18. Adherents read the two church visits as the work of one black dog, a hell hound of a kind reported across England. Holinshed's chronicle, quoted in Hone's Every-Day Book (1827), records the same storm as lightning and thunder, with a man over forty and a boy of fifteen found dead at Blythburgh and two men slain in the Bungay belfry, and names no dog. The name Shuck appears in none of Fleming's pamphlet, Hone's entry or the Blythburgh church history; BBC News records Black Shuck as the name later tradition gives the dog. Adherents answer that Fleming says his report came "by the mouthes of them that were eye witnesses," and that the Blythburgh door is still marked.
By tradition, the creature was born at Leeds Point on a stormy night in 1735 to a woman known as Mother Leeds who, pregnant for the 13th time, cried out, "Let this one be a devil" (National Geographic; other versions exist). From 16 January 1909, for about a week, newspapers across South Jersey and Philadelphia carried reports of hoof-like tracks in snow and of a winged creature with a horse-like head. The Sun (New York) reported on 21 January that "all south Jersey had posses out" hunting the "Leed's devil," and The Inquirer's front page that day showed "actual proof-prints of the strange creature." The Atlantic County Library counts thirty sightings in one week, and says the Philadelphia Zoo's superintendent offered a $10,000 reward. Adherents read the week as sightings of a creature long known in the Pine Barrens as the Leeds Devil. The Academy of Natural Sciences in Philadelphia could not find any record of a living or dead species resembling it (Atlantic County). Historians Brian Regal and Frank Esposito, in National Geographic, trace the Leeds name to the 17th-century colonist Daniel Leeds and find no 17th-century source calling any of his wives Mother Leeds. The Inquirer (2019) calls the publicist Norman Jeffries "the prime suspect in a case of fake news," and the Atlantic County Library says animal trainers at a Philadelphia museum made a Devil from a kangaroo with false wings. Adherents answer that businessmen, postal officials and policemen were among those who reported tracks and sightings, on both banks of the Delaware.
On 21 August 1955 a family on a farm near Kelly said that small, silvery figures with large heads, yellow glowing eyes and clawed hands had approached the house after a bright object came down behind it. Two men fired a shotgun and a .22 rifle. About 11 p.m., eight adults and three children arrived at the Hopkinsville police station (History.com). State police, military police from Fort Campbell and local officers went to the farm. The Kentucky New Era ran the first story on 22 August: "Story of Space-Ship, 12 Little Men Probed Today ... Bullets Failed To Affect Visitors." Officers stayed until after 2 a.m. "without seeing anything either to prove or disprove the story." According to the case site that hosts the New Era text, its reporter later noted that national media added the colour green two or three days afterwards. Adherents read it as a visit by small beings over several hours, one of the most detailed close encounters on record. Joe Nickell (2006, as reported by History.com) matched the light to a small meteor and the figures to great horned owls. Blue Book logged the case as number 10073 but did not officially investigate it. Adherents answer that the police chief said the family "reach for their guns" rather than run to the police, that the figures returned after the officers left, and that, as PBS records, none of the witnesses changed their story.
On 12 September 1952 (History.com), children playing after supper at the elementary school in Flatwoods saw something streak overhead and crash into a nearby hill (West Virginia Public Broadcasting). Nickell describes them as boys playing football on the school playground, a group of seven. A local mother went up the hill with them (West Virginia Public Broadcasting). West Virginia Public Broadcasting, quoting the visitors bureau director, describes a green and red figure about 10 feet tall, with a red face and a spade-shaped form around the head. The 15 September 1952 United Press story in the Washington Daily News gives the height as 11 or 12 feet, a "very sickening, hot, stuffy smelling odor," an area "all trampled down," and two tracks like skid marks about a foot wide the next morning. Nickell records a metallic, "sickening, irritating" odour, drape-like folds, two parallel "skid marks," trampled grass, and a pair of shining eyes. The group ran. Gray Barker wrote it up for FATE, and the Air Force opened a Project Blue Book inquiry. Adherents read the light, the odour, the marks and the figure as one visit by a landed craft and its pilot. The Blue Book record card at the National Archives concludes the object was "astronomical," the "well known Washington area meteor of 12 Sep." Joe Nickell (Skeptical Inquirer, November/December 2000) argues that the fireball was a meteor visible in at least three states, that the pulsing light matched a nearby aircraft beacon, and that the figure was a barn owl on a branch. Adherents answer that a meteor does not account for the marks and the odour found at the site, or for the figure the group described.
On 15 November 1966 two young couples reported a large winged figure with red eyes near the abandoned wartime munitions site known as the TNT area, outside Point Pleasant. The Point Pleasant Register ran "Couples See Man-Sized Bird...Creature...Something" on 16 November: the two men described it as about six or seven feet tall, with a 10-foot wingspan and red eyes about two inches across, and one said, "It was like a man with wings." Mary Hyre wrote 10 columns on it by year's end for the Athens Messenger, where History.com says an editor coined "Mothman" after Batman's foe Killer Moth. Keel's own timeline, as summarised by Hasken, lists 21 sightings before 1967 and 5 after the new year; the sources disagree on the total, so no single count is given as fact. WVPB says UFO reports began on 22 January 1967. On 15 December 1967 the Silver Bridge at Point Pleasant collapsed, killing 46; the National Transportation Safety Board determined that the collapse began with a cleavage fracture in the lower limb of the eye of eyebar 330, and that 31 of the 37 vehicles on the bridge fell with it. Adherents, following John Keel's The Mothman Prophecies (1975), read the figure as a harbinger linked to the collapse; Audubon lists other partisan readings: an alien or an extra-dimensional spirit. Joe Nickell of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry, in Audubon, says the original Mothman was likely a barred owl, whose eyeshine can glow red. Adherents answer that four people saw the figure together, and that the reports ended after the bridge fell.
From June 1764, attacks in the Gévaudan (modern Lozère) killed mostly women and children. Smithsonian Magazine says the beast killed around 100 people and injured nearly 300, and names the first victim as a 14-year-old girl watching her sheep; France Culture says about 80 recorded deaths. The Courrier d'Avignon, under editor François Morénas, turned it into national news. Captain Duhamel led hunts with up to 30,000 volunteers, the d'Ennevals announced in February 1765 that they would come, and François Antoine shot a large wolf in September 1765 that was sent to Versailles. Killings resumed, and Jean Chastel shot an animal on 19 June 1767, after which the attacks ended. The regional delegate Lafont wrote that "it is much bigger than a wolf," and Duhamel thought it a hybrid whose father was a lion. Adherents read these descriptions as an animal that no ordinary wolf could explain. Jay M. Smith, author of Monsters of the Gévaudan (Harvard University Press, 2011), told Smithsonian that "the best and most likely explanation is Gévaudan had a serious wolf infestation." An anatomical analysis reported by France Culture (5 December 2024) finds that the animal called Ténazeyre was a large-toothed wolf, with the other two suspects also canids and possibly wolves. Adherents answer that the killings went on after Antoine's wolf was presented as the beast; Smithsonian reports 30 to 35 deaths over the following 18 months.
On 15 May 1989, KLAS-TV in Las Vegas aired a live interview with a man called "Dennis," who described a place called S-4, built into the side of a mountain; seven months later the public learned his name, Bob Lazar. In that interview he said: "The propulsion system is a gravity propulsion system and the power source is an antimatter reactor." By his account, the craft used a stable form of element 115, which no laboratory had then made. The National Security Archive notes that the CIA's U-2 history, declassified in 2013, named Area 51 as the U-2 test site. Adherents read the account as a firsthand description of recovered craft. Physics Today reports that a Dubna and Livermore team led by Yuri Oganessian made element 115 in the summer of 2003; Scientific American reports four atoms that decayed after about 90 milliseconds. IUPAC approved the name moscovium (Mc) on 28 November 2016. VICE reports that only four isotopes have been produced, each lasting fractions of a second, and that scientists have not made a stable isotope like the one he described. Adherents answer that the account named element 115 in 1989, fourteen years before any laboratory made it.
Tesla came to Colorado Springs in 1899 and kept notes at his laboratory there, almost daily, for about eight months; the last journal entry is dated 7 January 1900. In "The Problem of Increasing Human Energy" (Century Magazine, June 1900) he wrote that an electrical movement could be made "perceptible on some of our nearer planets, as Venus and Mars," that "interplanetary communication has entered the stage of probability," and that "man is not the only being in the Infinite gifted with a mind." In "Talking with the Planets" (Collier's Weekly, February 1901) he described changes "with such a clear suggestion of number and order" and wrote: "The feeling is constantly growing on me that I had been the first to hear the greeting of one planet to another." Adherents read this as the first reception of an alien signal. In ARRL's QST ("Ghost," October 2018), Allison McLellan writes that biographer Marc Seifer suggests Tesla may have picked up Marconi's transmissions, citing the three-dot Morse "S." Adherents answer with Tesla's own words: he knew the disturbances caused by the sun, the aurora and earth currents, and these were "not traceable to any cause then known to me."
On 9 December 1965, witnesses about 30 miles southeast of Pittsburgh described a fireball and a metallic, acorn-shaped object about 12 to 15 feet high that landed in the woods; some said military personnel cordoned off the site and that the object left on a truck under a tarp (AP, 2009). Leslie Kean, who directs the Coalition for Freedom of Information, sued NASA in 2003; in March 2007 a federal judge found NASA had not yet shown an adequate search, and the case settled in October 2007 with $50,000 in fees and a new search, which ended in August 2009 with no record of the object. The Black Vault reports that NASA's transmittal slip listed fragment-study records sent to the National Archives in 1967 or 1968, that the Archives told NASA in 1996 they were lost, and that a later letter appears to say they were never received. Adherents read the cordon and the missing records as signs that something was recovered and kept quiet. A 1965 NASA press release, quoted by VICE, said the fireball was "more likely a meteor"; in 2005 NASA spokesman David Steitz told the AP the object appeared to be a Russian satellite, with fragment records lost in the 1990s. Adherents answer, as Space.com reports Kean's view, that data from U.S. Space Command and the Russian Space Agency show it was not a Russian satellite.
At a House Oversight subcommittee hearing on 26 July 2023, David Grusch, listed in the hearing record as "Former National Reconnaissance Office Representative, Unidentified Aerial Phenomena Task Force," testified: "I was informed in the course of my official duties of a multi-decade UAP crash retrieval and reverse engineering program to which I was denied access to those additional read-ons when I requested it." Asked, "do you believe that our government is in possession of UAPs?", he answered: "Absolutely, based on interviewing over 40 witnesses over 4 years." Adherents read the testimony as evidence that recovered craft exist and are being studied in secret. The All-domain Anomaly Resolution Office's Historical Record Report, Volume I (February 2024), reviewed U.S. government efforts from 1945. In a statement on 8 March 2024, Pentagon Press Secretary Maj. Gen. Pat Ryder said: "To date, AARO has found no verifiable evidence for claims that the U.S. government and private companies have access to or have been reverse-engineering extraterrestrial technology." The report says AARO concluded that one sample alleged to come from a crashed spacecraft is "a manufactured, terrestrial alloy," and that the KONA BLUE proposal was "never approved by DHS." Adherents answer that Grusch said the locations were provided to the Inspector General, and note that AARO's second volume was still to come.
In Intelligent Life in the Universe (1966), Shklovskii and Sagan wrote that if the 1945 orbital data for Phobos were right, its decay implied a density so low that "a natural satellite cannot be a hollow object," leading them to "the possibility" that it was an artificial satellite of Mars; they added that the data "may contain substantial errors." In Mars Global Surveyor images from 12 September 1998, NASA describes a very large boulder about 85 m across on Phobos; it came to be called the Phobos monolith, a name Buzz Aldrin used in a 2009 C-SPAN appearance, as IFLScience reports. Adherents read the hollow-moon calculation and the monolith as signs that Phobos is a made object. Parts and Wright (Research Notes of the AAS, 2026) note that later observations found a slower decay, explained by tidal friction, and that a Phobos hollow enough to match the 1966 rate would have about 2.1 x 10^-5 of its actual mass, a difference detectable within a year. Science News (2010), reporting on Mars Express data, gives a density of about 1.87 g per cubic cm and as much as 30 percent empty space, a possible rubble pile. JAXA's Martian Moons eXploration spacecraft launched on 20 October 2026 and is scheduled to return more than 10 g of material from Phobos in 2031. Adherents answer that no sample of Phobos has yet been examined.
Shortly after radio SETI began, Ronald Bracewell (Nature, 1960) raised the question of whether extraterrestrials might try observing us, as Haqq-Misra and Kopparapu recount. Their Bayesian study (Acta Astronautica, 2012) says extraterrestrial technology may exist in the Solar System without our knowledge, because unpiloted probes would likely remain unnoticed. Benford (AJ, 2019) proposes nearby co-orbital objects as places where a probe could watch Earth while not being easily seen. Villarroel and colleagues (Acta Astronautica, 2022) show that four or five aligned transients among nine on a pre-1957 photographic plate would be a strong indicator of non-terrestrial artefacts. Adherents read this work as a sign that watchers could already be close by, unnoticed. Freitas and Valdes (Icarus, 1980) searched the Earth-Moon L4 and L5 points and found no objects. Davies and Wagner (Acta Astronautica, 2013) propose scanning Lunar Reconnaissance Orbiter images at 0.5 m resolution, while noting only a tiny probability of finding alien traces. Adherents answer that most of the Solar System has not been explored at a resolution sharp enough to find such probes.
Kardashev, in Soviet Astronomy (1964), ranked civilizations by energy: Type I at about 4 x 10^12 W, close to the level then reached on Earth; Type II at about 4 x 10^26 W, harnessing its own star; Type III at about 4 x 10^37 W, on the scale of a galaxy. Dyson, in Science (1960), had already proposed searching for infrared from artificial stellar sources. Gray (AJ, 2020) shows that Sagan, in The Cosmic Connection (1973), suggested decimal steps and classed Earth as Type 0.7, though Sagan presented no equation. Wright and colleagues argue that detectably large alien energy supplies can plausibly be expected to exist. Adherents read the scale as a map of where advanced civilizations should be, and of how far humanity has to go. Griffith and colleagues, using WISE on about 100,000 galaxies, found none reprocessing more than 85 percent of their starlight into mid-infrared. Zackrisson and colleagues, studying 1,359 disk galaxies, found none standing out as strong Type III candidates. Adherents answer that these surveys set upper limits, not zero.
Technosignatures are observable signs of technology. Cocconi and Morrison (Nature, 1959) proposed searching for interstellar radio communications. NASA's Technosignatures Workshop (Lunar and Planetary Institute, Houston, 26 to 28 September 2018) produced a report edited by Jason Wright and Dawn Gelino, and Wright and coauthors (ApJL 927, L30, 2022) argue technosignatures may be abundant, long-lived, highly detectable and unambiguous. Adherents read this work as a sign that alien technology is now a serious scientific question, and that it may already be in the data. Price and colleagues (AJ 159, 86, 2020) searched 1,138 stars at Green Bank and 189 at Parkes and, after excluding interference, were "left with zero candidates," finding no transmitters above about 2.1 x 10^12 W (Green Bank) and 9.1 x 10^12 W (Parkes). A ten-year Breakthrough Listen review (MacMahon and Czech, arXiv, October 2026) notes that its best-known candidate, BLC1, was ultimately attributed to terrestrial interference, the conclusion Sheikh and colleagues reached with a technosignature verification framework. Adherents answer that these searches covered a small sample of stars and a narrow band of radio frequencies.
A narrowband signal at about 982 MHz was recorded toward Proxima Centauri with the Parkes "Murriyang" telescope in observations that began on 29 April 2019. The Breakthrough Listen team says it persisted over five hours and had some of the expected characteristics of an extraterrestrial transmission. The Guardian reported on 18 December 2020 that scientists were investigating it, and Andrew Siemion told Scientific American: "It has some particular properties that caused it to pass many of our checks, and we cannot yet explain it." Adherents read it as a possible beacon from the nearest star. Smith and colleagues (Nature Astronomy, 2021) attribute it to "an unusual but locally generated form of interference," and Sheikh and colleagues conclude it was an intermodulation product of local interferers, and report dozens of lookalike interference signals at frequencies harmonically related to common clock oscillators. A Research Notes paper reports no re-detection in 39 hours of reobservation. Adherents answer that, in the original observation, the signal appeared only in pointings toward the star.
Siraj and Loeb (arXiv 2019; ApJ 2022) reported that the fireball of 8 January 2014, catalogued as CNEOS 2014-01-08 and later called IM1, came from an unbound hyperbolic orbit "with 99.999% confidence." A U.S. Space Command memorandum dated 1 March 2022 and signed by Lt Gen John E. Shaw, Deputy Commander, repeats that figure as the paper's claim and says Dr Joel Mozer, Chief Scientist of Space Operations Command, "confirmed that the velocity estimate reported to NASA is sufficiently accurate to indicate an interstellar trajectory." From 14 to 28 June 2023, a Galileo Project expedition towed a magnetic sled about 85 km north of Manus Island, Papua New Guinea, and found about 850 spherules; Loeb and colleagues classed 22 percent as differentiated (D-type) and reported a subset with Be, La and U excess "distinctly different from coal fly ash." Adherents say the object was technological, and that pieces of it were recovered. Brown and Borovicka (ApJ 2023) suggest the simplest explanation is that the catalogued speed is substantially overestimated. Vaubaillon (2022) finds no scientific ground to conclude an interstellar orbit and calls finding pieces on the ocean floor extremely unlikely. Rudraswami, Singh and Pandey (Chemical Geology 2025) argue that most of the spherules, including the D-type group, are volcanic. Adherents answer that a U.S. military scientist backed the velocity estimate, and that the chemistry of the unusual spherules is still in dispute.
Dyson proposed in 1960 that advanced civilizations might be found by the infrared glow of the starlight they capture. Project Hephaistos (Suazo and colleagues, MNRAS 2024) screened about five million Gaia, 2MASS and WISE sources and named 7 candidates, all M dwarfs within 300 pc, whose infrared excess known processes cannot easily explain; the paper notes that a Dyson sphere cannot be proven from photometry alone. VASCO (Solano, Villarroel and Rodrigo, MNRAS 2022) lists 298,165 sources seen only on 1950s POSS-I plates, 5,399 still unidentified. Villarroel and colleagues (2021) describe nine point sources that appeared within half an hour on a red plate from 12 April 1950, and Bruehl and Villarroel (2025) report transients 45 percent more likely within one day of a nuclear test. Adherents read the infrared excesses and the vanishing lights as the first outlines of megastructures, or of objects in orbit before Sputnik. Zackrisson and colleagues (2026) used James Webb to trace the excess of candidates D and E to background galaxies. In Scientific American, Nigel Hambly urged checks of the original plates, and Sean Kirkpatrick pointed to nuclear test effects and high-altitude balloons. Adherents answer that the other five candidates were not part of the James Webb study, and that the plate transients are still of unknown origin.